The Science of Fear: How the Culture of Fear Manipulates Your Brain

by Daniel Gardner

we see movies and TV dramas as nothing more than entertainment, so we approach them with lowered critical faculties: Gut watches while Head sleeps. Unfortunately, almost no research has examined how fiction affects risk perception. One recent study, however, found just what psychologists would expect. Anthony Leiserowitz of Decision Research (a private research institute founded by Paul Slovic, Sarah Lichtenstein, and Baruch Fischhoff) conducted cross-country surveys in the United States before and after the release of The Day After Tomorrow, a disaster film depicting a series of sudden, spectacular catastrophes unleashed by global warming. The science in The Day After Tomorrow is dubious, to say the least. Not even the most frightening warnings about the effects of global warming come close to what the movie depicts. But that made no difference to the influence of the film. Across the board, more people who saw the film said they were concerned about global warming, and when they were asked how likely it was that the United States would experience various disasters similar to those depicted in the movie—flooded cities, food shortages, Gulf Stream shutdown, a new Ice Age, etc.—people who had seen the movie consistently rated these events more likely than those who didn’t. The effects remained even after the numbers were adjusted to account for the political leanings of respondents. Of course, Head can always step in, look at the evidence, and overrule. As we have seen, it ...