The Cave and the Light: Plato Versus Aristotle, and the Struggle for the Soul of Western Civilization
Rate it:
Open Preview
41%
Flag icon
“it is difficult, or rather impossible, either to maintain a republican form of government in states which have become corrupt or to create such a form afresh.”
41%
Flag icon
Final disaster comes not from outside, but from within.
42%
Flag icon
doctrine of love as the desire for beauty had a peculiar attraction in quattrocento Florence.
42%
Flag icon
Thomistic man’s proper place is at the center of creation, because he is the crucial mediating point between spirit and matter. Ficino’s Platonic man occupies the same slot in the divine hierarchy.
43%
Flag icon
Plato locates Love at the very heart of the primeval Chaos from which cosmic order will emerge.
43%
Flag icon
This was to prove that all religions and philosophies, ancient and modern, pagan and Christian, actually formed a single body of knowledge.
43%
Flag icon
Pico even drew up a final list of nine hundred theses that underpinned all philosophies and religions and doctrines, drawing from such diverse sources as the followers of Plato and Aristotle, but also from Thomas Aquinas and Duns Scotus, the Hebrew Kabbalah and Arab philosophers and Pythagoras—even the magical treatises of the mysterious ancient alchemist Hermes Trismegistus.
43%
Flag icon
why Pico immersed himself in the Kabbalah and studied the ancient Orphic hymns in hopes that their harmonies might reveal special magical properties.
43%
Flag icon
“Divine subjects and the secret Mysteries must not be rashly divulged,” Pico says. All “divine knowledge … must be covered with enigmatic veils and poetic dissimulation.…”
43%
Flag icon
but by design.
43%
Flag icon
would lead the Renaissance mind down some dark passageways, including alchemy and black magic.
43%
Flag icon
Rosicrucians and the possibility that a secret brotherhood of the Rosy Cross controlled access to the world’s final hidden truths.23 Still
44%
Flag icon
“Virtue’s what Heaven must despise … seeing they would give us a dead tree from which to pluck our fruit.”
44%
Flag icon
Michelangelo constantly compares love to a burning fire that sears the consciousness and torments the body, but also scours away worldly corruption, so that the soul “like gold purged in a fire returns to God.”
44%
Flag icon
By the time he finished four years later, he had transformed the pope’s commission into his personal statement on the grand themes of the Platonism of his day—and into the artistic masterpiece of the Renaissance. It is the perfect counterpart to The School of Athens, and Giovanni Pico would have been the perfect person to decipher the ceiling’s rich complexity and its various veiled meanings. For instance, he would have immediately recognized why Michelangelo broke the ceiling down into three separate zones, each stacked above the other. The lowest, running along the tops of the chapel’s ...more
44%
Flag icon
The third realm, the great spine of Michelangelo’s plan, are the panels depicting the Book of Genesis, where the soul experiences God’s presence directly. The entire work gives us a visual tour of what a disciple of Ficino would call deificatio, or the soul’s return to God, the final consummation of spiritual enlightenment. The Sistine ceiling contains no direct references to Christianity or Christ. Michelangelo the Platonist didn’t feel the need for any, because his message is more universal. Instead all the scenes are from the Old Testament, which every Renaissance Platonist knew to be the ...more
44%
Flag icon
It is only when we come to the central panels that we see that Michelangelo has moved Renaissance Platonism to a new level of consciousness. As art historian S. J. Freedberg observes, there is nothing like it anywhere in th...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
45%
Flag icon
Physics and Metaphysics and On the Soul.
45%
Flag icon
Oxford
46%
Flag icon
In Praise of Folly.
46%
Flag icon
Most teachers were scarcely older than their teenage charges. They preferred to stick to rote memorization and to the traditional trivium of grammar, rhetoric, and logic, the last of which had come to mean memorizing the rules for conducting a formal dialectical disputation. No one ventured to discuss God or the soul or the Bible in class. With the Inquisition always watching, it was much too dangerous.
47%
Flag icon
Still, both Luther and Calvin display the power of Plato’s thymos in action. It is the enemy of moderation—but
47%
Flag icon
I pull out a ruler and compass. I begin tracing circles and measuring their diameter and their circumference. I split them into sections, first on paper, then in my mind. I am in Plato’s realm of dianoia, the realm of geometry and number.3 I continue to draw and calculate and watch as the shapes dissolve into lines, points, triangles, and parabolas. Finally, only the numbers are left. I realize they express mathematical formulae that exist in perfect proportion to each other, with each ratio (1:2, 1:3) leading constantly to a higher and higher level of abstract order. Then I have it. This ...more
47%
Flag icon
am in Plato’s realm of dianoia, the realm of geometry and number.
48%
Flag icon
Book VI of Plato’s Republic.
48%
Flag icon
Ficino and Michelangelo to Erasmus. It also lurks in the deepest recesses of modern science.
48%
Flag icon
Ficino’s divine and profane love.
48%
Flag icon
Padua’s teachers stressed the original principle of Aristotle’s philosophy of nature: that knowledge is a process of discovery using the power of our senses.
48%
Flag icon
The reason is that Vincenzo Galilei was a mathematician as well as a musicologist. His goal was to return musical theory to its Pythagorean roots. The father, like the son, understood the power of number not as a way to count or measure, as Aristotelians did, but rather as Number, reason’s window into the hidden order of nature.
49%
Flag icon
Aristarchus.§
Cosmic Arcata
Hermetic
49%
Flag icon
dialogue in everyday Italian, called Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems.
50%
Flag icon
Bruno’s belief in Egyptian magical religion, which he shared with Ficino, would go on to become a key ingredient in Freemasonry.
50%
Flag icon
Harvey’s fellow Englishman, Sir Francis Bacon, supplied one answer: It leaves us firmly in charge. As self-declared pundit of the new science, Bacon was delighted to see Aristotelian natural philosophy with its “contentiousness” (an odd complaint from a lawyer) and its fetish for words, not deeds (ditto), get swept away.2
50%
Flag icon
Descartes was steeped in it. Reducing the operations of the universe to a series of lines, circles, numbers, and equations suited his reclusive personality. His most famous saying, “I think, therefore I am”
50%
Flag icon
“What is beyond geometry, is beyond us,”
50%
Flag icon
Marsilio Ficino.
51%
Flag icon
1661
51%
Flag icon
After Newton’s death in 1727, when he was the acknowledged scientific genius of his age, the dozens of folio notebooks he had filled with his biblical studies were discovered.
51%
Flag icon
These forces, Newton showed, exert a palpable and mathematically predictable influence on the behavior of all physical bodies. Yet they are entirely invisible and beyond any purely physical or mechanical explanation.
Cosmic Arcata
Gematria
51%
Flag icon
His spirit provides the space through which all objects pass, from birds and trees to comets and stars in the sky; and His infinitude is found in the infinity of the cosmos, stretching out beyond our solar system into eternity.
51%
Flag icon
Supreme Being supervised and guided the complex workings of the universe, including their own actions.
51%
Flag icon
The Royal Society of London for Improving Natural Knowledge,
51%
Flag icon
1660.
51%
Flag icon
Alexander Pope
51%
Flag icon
the notion of a cosmic order built on the will of God was about to show a very different, more sinister face.
51%
Flag icon
What the visitors were seeing was more than a prodigious appetite in action. They were witnessing how the richest and most populous kingdom in Europe had been made to revolve around a single man, in a ritual of obedience as solemn as the Last Supper. They were also watching the poverty of politics in 1600s’ Europe.
51%
Flag icon
Self-governing societies seemed doomed to be free but unstable. Because they existed in time, and were therefore subject to the vicissitudes of change and to men’s passions, they would inevitably hit a wall.† Like ancient Rome and Renaissance Florence, they were doomed to fall into the hands of a despot in order to save society from mob rule. Freedom, in short, must eventually lead to unfreedom.
Cosmic Arcata
Freedom ends with unfreedon
51%
Flag icon
Like the Sun King, all of them turned their nation’s printing presses and church pulpits into royalist propaganda machines. What was then “the mainstream media” routinely pointed to the monarch as an essential link in the Great Chain of Being, the center of a divinely preordained and fixed order.
52%
Flag icon
Versailles was clear: Your only alternative is mob rule and apocalypse.
53%
Flag icon
Jefferson had to conclude that Plato had always been a fraud, “a dealer in mysticisms incomprehensible to the human