A Soldier of the Great War

by Mark Helprin

“You see,” the attorney Giuliani said, “not only is there no comfort in unanimity, but they cannot even achieve it.” “I could unify them.” “That’s silly, Alessandro. If they supported you, or even listened, it would be because you flattened yourself and your ideas until everything that once was steep and noble was gone.” “What if I speak my mind, forcibly, and carry them along with me? “That would make you a demagogue, a windbag. Why do you think great leaders and great orations are coincident with wars, revolutions, and the founding or ending of governments and states? Common interests then are so clear that speeches are effortlessly drawn, but at present neither the facts nor the consequences are sufficiently clear to make oratory legitimate. This is the kind of war that will wind on and make fools of its partisans and opponents both.”