STEP 1 | Wait for you puppy to sit before tossing the toy: Show her the toy but hold it far enough out of her reach that she does not try to jump. If she does try to jump, pull it away further so it’s clear that her jumping removed the toy. STEP 2 | Toss the toy: When she sits, to make it clear to her that sitting is what earns the toy, toss it for her.

