Good Strategy Bad Strategy: The Difference and Why It Matters
Rate it:
Open Preview
40%
Flag icon
The chain-linked activities should form an unusual grouping such that expertise in one does not easily carry over to expertise at the others.
40%
Flag icon
talented leaders seek to create constellations of activities that are chain-linked.
40%
Flag icon
to unstick a stuck chain-linked system, a strong leader must possess the insight and fortitude to make the necessary investments in each link of the chain.
41%
Flag icon
three aspects of strategy
41%
Flag icon
premeditation, the anticipation of others’ behavior, and the purposeful design of coordinated actions.
41%
Flag icon
A fundamental ingredient in a strategy is a judgment or anticipation concerning the thoughts and/or behavior of others.
42%
Flag icon
It is often said that a strategy is a choice or a decision.
42%
Flag icon
The problem with this view,
42%
Flag icon
is that you are rarely handed a clear set of alternatives.
42%
Flag icon
many effective strategies are more designs than decisions—are more constructed than chosen.
42%
Flag icon
master strategist is a designer.
43%
Flag icon
I want to emphasize the issue of mutual adjustment.
43%
Flag icon
there can be sharply peaked gains to getting combinations right and sharp costs to getting them wrong.
43%
Flag icon
A good strategy coordinates policies acr...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
43%
Flag icon
to get more performance out of a system you have integrate its components and subsystems more cleverly and more tightly. On the other hand, if capabilities (technologies) could be improved, the demand for tight, clever integration was lessened.
43%
Flag icon
A design-type strategy is an adroit configuration of resources and actions that yields an advantage in a challenging situation.
43%
Flag icon
These principles mean that resources and tight coordination are partial substitutes for each other.
43%
Flag icon
Implicit in these principles is the notion that tight integration comes at some cost.
44%
Flag icon
when the competitive challenge is very high, it may be necessary to accept these costs and design a tightly integrated response.
44%
Flag icon
A high-quality strategic resource yielding a powerful competitive advantage makes for great strategic
44%
Flag icon
simplicity.
44%
Flag icon
It did not need much in the way of a design-type strategy because its resource position—its patent—insulated it from competition and because the product’s value to buyers was so much greater than the cost of making one.
44%
Flag icon
the cleverest strategies, the ones we study down through the years, begin with very few strategic resources, obtaining their results through the adroit coordination of actions in time and across functions.
44%
Flag icon
peril of a potent resource position is that success then arrives without careful ongoing strategy work.
45%
Flag icon
Paccar’s strategy—its design—is its way of dealing with these three obstacles to being a quality leader.
45%
Flag icon
Paccar views quality through the eyes of the owner-driver.
45%
Flag icon
Paccar’s strategy is based on doing something well and consistently over a long period of time.
46%
Flag icon
All of this works, in part, because it is not in a high-growth industry
Matthew Ackerman
Strategic design depends as much on coordinated action as it does on environment. That is, diagnosing the problem and determining a guiding policy should lead to coherent action with outcomes predicted based on internal and external factors. If the parts do not add up, the actions even if coherent will fail to yield positive results.
46%
Flag icon
Paccar’s design is expressed in actions that are consistent with its positioning and that are consistent over time.
46%
Flag icon
The product-buyer focus is maintained by its dealers, designers, and engineers.
46%
Flag icon
The various elements of Paccar’s strategy are not general purpose—they are designed to fit together to make a specialized whole.
46%
Flag icon
Good strategy is design, and design is about fitting various pieces together so they work as a coherent whole.
46%
Flag icon
This defensive structure can probably be maintained as long as there are no significant structural changes in the industry’s economics or buyer behavior.
Matthew Ackerman
Strategy depends on the actions of others and response to environment. Paccars strategy will need to adapt when the market changes (i.e. How will paccar adapt to self driving fleets of heavy trucks?)
46%
Flag icon
To begin identifying a company’s strategy, it is usually most helpful to examine the competitive
46%
Flag icon
environment.
47%
Flag icon
“If we are not going to automatically accept the opinions of others, how can we independently identify a company’s strategy?
47%
Flag icon
We do this by looking at each policy of the company and noticing those that are different from the norm in the industry. We then try to figure out the common target of such distinctive policies—what they are coordinated on accomplishing.”
47%
Flag icon
I have lectured on how to tackle seemingly formless questions like this. The first trick is to replace general nouns with specific examples.
47%
Flag icon
The discipline of analysis is to not stop there, but to test that first insight against the evidence.
47%
Flag icon
The technical assistance policy seems to have small companies as a target and the rapid response policy seems to target rush orders. These two targets are not quite the same thing. Let’s take a look at another policy.”
48%
Flag icon
Smaller customers … rush orders … speed … less production per customer … higher prices?”
Matthew Ackerman
Guiding policies to address diagnosis
48%
Flag icon
“Crown does short runs,” exclaims Julia, an entrepreneur. “The majors accept long runs of standard items to avoid costly changeovers. Crown does the opposite and has a focus on shorter runs.”
48%
Flag icon
The phrase “Shorter runs” ties the company’s focus to the essential problem faced by producers in the industry—the very high costs of switching a can line from making one product to another,
Matthew Ackerman
Diagnosis of the industry problem
48%
Flag icon
It’s time to figure out how all of this allows Crown to earn higher margins.”
48%
Flag icon
Instead of one customer with several competing suppliers, Crown is a supplier with several customers per plant.
48%
Flag icon
Going for long runs made the majors captive.
48%
Flag icon
Crown hasn’t given up its bargaining power like th...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.
48%
Flag icon
attacking a segment of the market with a business system supplying more value
48%
Flag icon
to that segment than the other players can—is called focus.
48%
Flag icon
coordination of policies that produce...
This highlight has been truncated due to consecutive passage length restrictions.