Breathe (Breathe, #1) in And So It Begins Reading Challenge

Mar 08, 2012 Carrie Ardoin rated it it was ok

Shelves: posted-on-blog, edelweiss, dystopia, what-a-letdown

*Below is a review that will most probably make people mad at me...*

Quinn, Alina, and Bea are teenagers in a dystopian future where the atmosphere has been depleted of oxygen, making it impossible for anyone to breathe. As a result, The small population of survivors from The Switch now lives in a structure called The Pod, where air is pumped in and pretty much every aspect of life is controlled by an oppressive government (any of this sounding familiar yet?).

Quinn is the oldest son in a promine *Below is a review that will most probably make people mad at me...*

Quinn, Alina, and Bea are teenagers in a dystopian future where the atmosphere has been depleted of oxygen, making it impossible for anyone to breathe. As a result, The small population of survivors from The Switch now lives in a structure called The Pod, where air is pumped in and pretty much every aspect of life is controlled by an oppressive government (any of this sounding familiar yet?).

Quinn is the oldest son in a prominent family, and happens to be best friends with Bea, a brilliant but poor girl who has high aspirations. Alina is a member of a resistance group that plans to bring Breathe (the government) down. When Quinn meets Alina, he immediately becomes interested in her, and soon all three of the kids' lives are intertwined, for better or worse.

Breathe was one of the most anticipated releases of Fall 2012. I was one of those bloggers who heard about it ages ago and immediately put it on my TBR list. But unfortunately, the book description that roped me into wanting to read this book was just about the only compelling thing about it.

I was so excited to start reading this book, but once I started, the many shortcomings I found made me not want to finish it. First off, maybe it's just me having dystopian overload, but I feel like I have read this story. So. Many. Times. Pure by Julianna Baggott comes to mind, countless others. It's kinda like the author went down a dystopian novel checklist:
-Oppressive Government: CHECK
-World changing event THAT IS NEVER TRULY EXPLAINED: CHECK
-Resistance group with a crazy leader: CHECK

Then there was a YA checklist:
-Love triangle: CHECK
-Non-existent/non-caring parents: CHECK
-Whiny girl, idiot boy, kickass (but not quite) heroine: CHECK

So many things about this book didn't make sense to me. Just for example: the kids find a drifter, an older lady named Maude. She explains that before The Switch, she was training in the medical field. That would take a person with fairly high intelligence, correct? Well, in this book she talks as if she just stepped out of 1870's Appalachia. "I weren't no threat." and such. Maybe I picked things apart, but hey, I'm a reviewer so things like this catch my attention.

Characterization was severely lacking in this novel, and I'd be hard pressed to say I found redeeming qualities in any of the characters. Quinn made me want to punch him several times, Alina just wasn't the smartest, and Bea had no backbone. The sort-of-but-not-quite love triangle was very annoying.

There are several other things I had issues with, but honestly, I am tired of talking about this book and I'm ready to get it out of my mind. I only finished it because I started it...and I kind of wish I hadn't. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 27, 2012 Ally rated it liked it

Okay, I was really excited for the idea of this book because it really does seem like something that could happen someday.

It's been a good while since I've read a multiple POV novel and it was easy to distinguish who was who because each character had their own distinct voice.

I just, I don't know, something didn't strike me when I was reading Breathe.They live in this dome because there was this thing called The Switch and oxygen levels plummeted and there is no life outside the dome. All the tr ...more

Like · see review