Defiance (Defiance, #1) in And So It Begins Reading Challenge

Feb 23, 2012 Ezmirelda rated it liked it

Shelves: romance, arc, fantasy, beautiful-cover, 3-point-5, drags-in-middle, deathly-hallows, abrupt-ending, fire-breathing-dragon, girls-with-red-hair

The huge scary thing is a dragon…right?

The two words that best describe my feelings after reading DEFIANCE are bittersweet confusion. First I would like to point out that it took me awhile to realize “the Cursed One” was actually a dragon. Call me slow but they never actually call the creature a dragon. I guess it was up for the readers to figure it out and I got it like halfway through the story. The thing flies (I think), it breathes out fire, it’s huge enough to cause everyone in the entire c The huge scary thing is a dragon…right?

The two words that best describe my feelings after reading DEFIANCE are bittersweet confusion. First I would like to point out that it took me awhile to realize “the Cursed One” was actually a dragon. Call me slow but they never actually call the creature a dragon. I guess it was up for the readers to figure it out and I got it like halfway through the story. The thing flies (I think), it breathes out fire, it’s huge enough to cause everyone in the entire continent to fear it and build huge walls to keep it out. Yeah, sounds pretty dragon-ish to me. Once I figured out the whole dragon thing I got this medieval feel of the book, but then at the same time I got a steam-punkish feel from all the talk about technology. I guess in the end the only real genre I’m sure I could put a label on this is fantasy.

Introducing Merida's twin, Rachel...

description

Rachel is a fiery character with equally fiery red hair and a desire to wield a weapon and fight. She is not at all concerned with being the average Baalbooden girl like the evil commander wants her to be. I read this book shortly after watching the Disney movie Brave so she pretty much looked like Merida to me the entire novel. Logan is the guy who (sort of) turned her down when she confessed to him one day. I feel like the whole I-hate-you-cause-you-rejected-me vibe readers get from the beginning of the book is completely overrated once you actually read how things really went down. The first huge turning point of the novel is when things started to slow down for me. The beginning was like an adrenaline rush (meaning I read it pretty quickly without putting it down) and then it just…stopped. Then finally when I made it to the end it was all types of confusion and abruptness. So many things happened in the last chapter that could’ve been spanned out a little more or even carried onto the next book.

Overall…

My feelings for DEFIANCE are pretty split. It started off great, with characters I found interesting and a world I was keen on learning more about. Heck, I was even fascinated by the descriptions of the gadgets and took joy in reading those. Then towards the end….the excitement sort of fizzled out. I have always had troubles with books that pull what I call the “Deathly Hallows” trick over the readers unless it’s necessary to the plot and makes sense. I did not feel the Deathly Hallow string of events in DEFIANCE was necessary, for the plot or for Rachel’s character development. It would have been better suited for a later books in this series. Overall, I recommend this book because I loved the first part of it, and it's nice seeing a female character who is more into saving others than being saved. To me this feels like something people will either love or shelve as DNF.

3.5

Many thanks to Edelwiess and Baltzer + Bray for providing a copy for review. ...more

4 likes · Like · see review

Jul 02, 2012 Kirstyn rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: favorites, favorite-authors, beautiful-cover

I'm so mad at myself that I waited this long to read Defiance! This book was amazing; couldn't put it down. Even when I was forced to, I kept thinking about the characters and what might happen next. That's how you know a book is great :) The world building was fantastic; I could picture myself in the city-state and out in the Wastelands with Logan and Rachel. The Commander was very creepy..knowing that (view spoiler) is frightening; ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Mar 14, 2012 Paula Phillips rated it really liked it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. With the sudden oomph of Dystopian to the world of books, it's no surprise that it still remains popular as many authors continue to bring them out with a hint of other genres. In Defiance , parts of it reminded me of The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood , The Selection by Kiera Cass and The Maze Runner by James Dashner. What I really love to about the genre of Dystopian is that unlike the Vampire Craze where it tended to be the Males as the heroes and a few female heroines, in the world of Dys ...more

4 likes · Like · see review

Aug 01, 2012 Kam Brooksmoore rated it really liked it

Shelves: dystopia, read-in-2013, fantasy, young-adult

Wow…just…wow. I don't know how to explain how utterly awesome this book was. It had everything you could possibly hope for: action, romance, loss, grief, and especially DEFIANCE. A big element of the book. Only because the main characters, Rachel and Logan, are defying their leaders and doing the unthinkable...starting a revolution!!!

The main characters of this book were Rachel and Logan. Rachel was a VERY stubborn girl who rarely follows orders and acts on her own accord, unlike the other women ...more

Like · see review