From the Bookshelf of Once Upon a Time...…

American Gods

Neil Gaiman

Discussion: Mythology

Why we're reading this: 09/23/22 Nominated by Lisa
[close] 09/23/22 Nominated by Lisa

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 4 topics — 60 comments total

Mythology

Circe by Madeline Miller - June 2025
By Gem , Belle · 15 posts · 10 views

last updated Jul 07, 2025 12:29PM

The Bear and the Nightingale (The Winternight Trilogy #1) by Katherine Arden - December 2024
By Gem , Belle · 6 posts · 9 views

last updated Jan 15, 2025 09:13PM

What Members Thought

Jan 23, 2012 Jessica Andersen rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-fantasy

This book was amazing. I think it will take more than one reading to take it all in. It was the first thing I'd read by Neil Gaiman, and it won't be the last!

I just reread this book in excitement over the upcoming Starz series. Now that we are getting some information about casting, I needed a refresher. I really paid attention to character descriptions this time around. And some of the plot points. I remembered very little from my first read in 2012, other than broad impressions and some idea o ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 28, 2012 Kirstie rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: urban-fantasy

I love Neil Gaiman's work, his comics, his tv shows, his children's books but this was my very first attempt at reading his fiction for adults. American Gods was a thrilling novel with great characters deep settings and a lot to say, but I must admit I didn't quite enjoy it as much as his 'kiddy' works (does that mean I'm a child, not sure).

This does not men I didn't enjoy the book, far from it, I loved it. I didn't guess the twist ending (though I must confess the secret of the town (won't go i ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

May 31, 2017 Susan rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: audiobook, contemporary, fantasy, mythology, urban-fantasy, action-adventure

Shadow Moon is being released from prison a little early on account of the unexpected passing of his wife Laura. On his way home to the funeral, he meets Mr. Wednesday who offers him a job that is part body guard and part problem solver. Without anything else to lose, he makes it official. Then weird stuff starts happening. TV characters talk to him. A leprechaun teaches him a special coin trick after beating the crap out of him. Someone wants to give his skull a love tap with a large hammer. Th Shadow Moon is being released from prison a little early on account of the unexpected passing of his wife Laura. On his way home to the funeral, he meets Mr. Wednesday who offers him a job that is part body guard and part problem solver. Without anything else to lose, he makes it official. Then weird stuff starts happening. TV characters talk to him. A leprechaun teaches him a special coin trick after beating the crap out of him. Someone wants to give his skull a love tap with a large hammer. That’s just the start of things.

I’ve read this book multiple times over the years but this was my first time experiencing the full cast audio production. It was quite good and lived up to my expectations. Shadow is so easy to connect with. He’s got this big heart at his center but he also doesn’t want to be anyone’s push over. Mr. Wednesday was highly amusing with his love for bad food and lust for life. He’s a conman and makes no attempt to hide this from Shadow. These two make an unlikely team and you can’t help but wonder what is Wednesday’s final end game. You can see that Shadow is wondering the same thing and yet he’s still drawn to this man and sucked into whatever he’s playing at.

There’s several female characters in this tale, though they are all pretty minor. Laura has the biggest role in that her actions affect the other characters, though she doesn’t have much actual page time. Bilquis and Easter were my favorite side gods. One is worshiped through sex and the other provides a bounty of food for the homeless in a park. If there is one weakness to this book, it is that all the main characters are male and almost all the decisions and action in this book are carried out by male characters. I would have liked a bit more gender balancing.

Some of my favorite scenes for this book happen in a small frozen town during winter. Shadow has been sent there to lie low while Mr. Wednesday works on whatever scheme he’s got underway. While there, Shadow gets to know some of the people and he learns about some missing kids. In a way, it turns into a little murder mystery. Then there’s also the mortuary and that crazy carousel and the final vibrant scenes at the conclusion of Mr. Wednesday’s big scheme. In some ways, the story is all over the map (sometimes literally as Shadow travels around the US), but it is these American versions of various deities along with the newly minted technology and media-oriented deities that tie everything together. I was glad to see entities that represented the Native Americans as well.

This edition, the 10th anniversary edition, includes an afterword by Neil Gaiman. There he talks about his own journey in coming up with this extraordinary story and characters. He also includes a scene that has Jesus and explains why he ultimately decided not to place that scene within the story. It was great to hear the author’s thoughts on this well loved book.

The Narration: This full cast production was very well done. There were no volume issues and whenever there are two or more characters talking, they sound like they are in the same room. Ron McLarty, Daniel Oreskes, Oliver Wyman, Dennis Boutsikaris, and the rest (though I haven’t been able to find a complete cast list online) did a great job with the various characters. Oliver Wyman makes a great 6 foot tall drunken, angry, magic coin producing leprechaun. McLarty does well with Mr. Wednesday’s character, though in my head I always revert to George Guidall for Mr. Wednesday (Guidall narrated the original version of American Gods and it’s also quite good). ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 20, 2012 Katharina Gerlach rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: young-adult

Well, since I grew up on German folklore and European Gods, I wasn't impressed. The only thread I liked, and the only one I fully remember is that of the missing kids in the Northern town -- and it was only a minor side-thread in the novel. One scene I enjoyed despite not much liking the rest, and that was the visit to the House on the Rocks in Wisconsin. I've been there myself and the description captured the essence of the building very well. It shows that Gaiman does know how to write captiva ...more

Like · see review