Cleopatra's Daughter in Senatus Populus Que Romanus

Mar 05, 2011 Stephanie rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Because I have a short reading attention span, reading Cleopatra: A Life reminded me that I had this book on my mental to-read list. And today I decided to take a detour into reading Cleopatra's Daughter before resuming that one. I wasn't super impressed with Nefertiti; in presentation, it struck me as a warmed over The Other Boleyn Girl... this time in Egypt! (And with a more interesting main character, to be fair.) Still, I have been curious about Cleopatra Selene for some time now and histori Because I have a short reading attention span, reading Cleopatra: A Life reminded me that I had this book on my mental to-read list. And today I decided to take a detour into reading Cleopatra's Daughter before resuming that one. I wasn't super impressed with Nefertiti; in presentation, it struck me as a warmed over The Other Boleyn Girl... this time in Egypt! (And with a more interesting main character, to be fair.) Still, I have been curious about Cleopatra Selene for some time now and historical fiction is like my literary comfort food. tl;dr: I was totally destined to read this someday and, hurray!, this book proved to be well worth my while.

I will say that I was frustrated in some points; some of the character are tiresome caricatures and boring tropes, sticking out like sore thumbs among the more well-developed ones. Likewise, Moran's writing style is a puzzle to me, wherein stronger emotions occasionally fall flat. Nothing comes across as maudlin, but she had an unenviable task considering the sheer number of tragedies in Selene's life. Also, and this is probably petty, but I rather wish this book had been a duology. I really wanted to read about Selene's life after the time span covered in this book, because it's some pretty fascinating stuff. As it stands, the ending feels a bit abrupt, and I think a chapter or two more wouldn't have hurt.

Still, Cleopatra's Daughter is compulsively readable and ridiculously entertaining. Prickly, conscientious Selene is an appealing heroine, and a number of the side characters are equally interesting. Julia in particular steals the show, and I was so glad that the author made her and Selene have a somewhat complicated relationship. (Actually, and this might have been because I was just reading this books, I was slightly reminded of Gemma and Felicty from A Great and Terrible Beauty. This is a good thing!)

Moran is also pretty decent about sticking to historical fact. She does invent a slave uprising out of whole cloth, but this didn't bother me. It fit well into the climate of the day, and it didn't come across as the author going "well I think THIS should have happened instead!" Furthermore, Cleopatra's Daughter does a pretty damn decent job of developing the character's personalities, rather than merely going from point A to B in history.

This is more like a 4.5. Pretty much a perfect rainy day read! ...more

6 likes · Like · see review

May 29, 2014 Susanna - Censored by GoodReads rated it really liked it · review of another edition

A slight whiff of YA (probably because the narrator is an adolescent), but an enjoyable read.

For further review: http://susannag.booklikes.com/post/89... . ...more

4 likes · Like · see review

May 18, 2011 Christina rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: roman-history, italy, historical-fiction

I enjoyed the book esp. b/c it was from the point of view of a young character. I liked that it included the youthful aspect of many the secondary figures of the "imperial" family. I am not sure I agree with the overly harsh way that Livia was characterized. I do think the Red Eagle devise was a bit much esp. when it turns out to be a key person and real historical figure. I think when you do something such as that you should make the entire person fictional and even then, I am not sure I would ...more

Like · see review

Oct 13, 2014 rzells rated it liked it

Shelves: ancient-rome

Good story but the writing was not the best. The story was told in simple words, as if the author never took the pains to be creative. I did love the characters, especially the twins. I wonder if these authors are popular for their writing or the content and setting of their stories?

Like · see review