The Goldfinch in Around the World in 80 Books

Nov 18, 2014 Gabriella rated it really liked it

Shelves: queer-lit

Ah, The Goldfinch...

This has to be one of the books I waited the longest to read. Got it on my Kindle when it first came out, was a bit put off by the hype, started plowing into the initial section, found myself very bored, found the writing pretentious. Stopped reading, dismayed.

And then I went back recently, picked it up again and found, to my surprise... that once Theo moved in with his school chum Andy and the Barbour family, the writing perked up, the book gripped me, and I swept through th Ah, The Goldfinch...

This has to be one of the books I waited the longest to read. Got it on my Kindle when it first came out, was a bit put off by the hype, started plowing into the initial section, found myself very bored, found the writing pretentious. Stopped reading, dismayed.

And then I went back recently, picked it up again and found, to my surprise... that once Theo moved in with his school chum Andy and the Barbour family, the writing perked up, the book gripped me, and I swept through the rest of it as fast as I could. I was particularly taken by the Las Vegas section where Theo is taken off to live by his scoundrel of a father, who gambles for a living, and takes up with a young Ukrainian/Australian guy, Boris, who is even more rootless and unparented than Theo himself. Theo and Boris take lots of drugs, steal for kicks, they experiment sexually... Donna Tartt's writing here is superb, showing the boy's world opening up rather than shutting down.

But back in claustrophobic New York, torn away from Boris by his father' timely, or untimely, death, depending on how you look at it, Theo hits a bit of a slump that seems like it will last the rest of the novel.

Unlike many of the reviewers on Amazon, who loved the first, "arty" section of the book, and hated the philosophical, open-ended ending and the scenes in Amsterdam, I found that Tartt exploded her own pretensions by driving a bus through her own literary novel. Theo's world "explodes" again at the end, and we're led to believe that at least he is taking his life in his hands...somewhat. (Mostly by not killing himself, ironically.) But what would have really pleased me would have been a recontinuation of the relationship with Boris. These are two characters who seem to want to be together, no matter how much their author wants to dub them as straight, on different tracks, etc.

To sum up, I'm very glad I read the Goldfinch! It's a nineteenth-century novel at heart; it luxuriates in its own length. Theo's "bad" friend Boris ends up giving him closure on the biggest wound of his life outside of his mother's death, his ownership of the famous painting, which has become a terrible burden. Once he realizes that he hasn't even had the painting in his possession for years—a delicious twist that Tartt pulls off well—Theo's life begins to change. And for a book that says over and over again that people can't change, Tartt does offer a little smidgen of hope for Theo. But it IS a dark and sad book, no doubt. Those who have suffered loss and who have PTSD (and Tartt does not shy away from labeling Theo this way) will understand the bleakness. Without the tragicomic character of Boris, this book would have been a terrible slog. Luckily, Tartt allows that relationship to become central, and to my mind it saves the book. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 06, 2014 Sara rated it really liked it

About halfway through the book, I decided that it's really not about the bird or the painting but rather a boy who becomes just like his despised father....
In the end, I changed my mind. As written in the last few pages:
"The bird looks out at us. It's not idealized or humanized. It's very much a bird. Watchful, resigned. There's no moral or story. There's no resolution. There's only a double abyss: between painter and imprisoned bird; between the record he left of the bird and our experience of ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 10, 2014 Karen rated it it was ok

Shelves: 2014-chunky-book-challenge

Maybe 2 1/2 stars would be more appropriate, I don't know. I can't honestly say that I liked this book (to make it a 3 star). Tartt's writing is very good no doubt, but I came away from the book with such a sense of hopelessness. I agree with other reviewers that this book is too long and I for one, love long books: Anna Karenina, War and Peace, Bleak House and David Copperfield. This book was too long because it has too much chaff and not enough wheat. I would say only 100 - 150 pages of this w ...more

Like · see review

Jul 08, 2014 Lara rated it it was amazing

I loved it and kept being surprised that I did. The character development is masterful. I feel like I know everyone in the book personally. The plot was unpredictable and suspenseful and in the end, I really liked the themes she worked with. 5 stars!!

Like · see review

May 31, 2014 Sunflower rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction-read-2014

This is a sprawling, incredibly well-written novel that takes you through the life of a boy and... a painting. These collide early in the book, back when the boy has an almost normal life, but from the time of the initial catastrophic event things begin to unravel for him. I don't think that any further outline from me can do this book justice, except to say that it is an exceptional read. And that I was completely unaware that the painting actually exists until after I'd finished it. ...more

Like · see review

Apr 18, 2014 Tanya rated it liked it

Shelves: format-audiobook, 2016, challenge-2016-colapub, challenge-2016-popsugar

So glad this is done. I picked it up three times before finally finishing it. Too long, too much info about wood refinishing and too much about drugs. I had a hard time rich listening to this when the kids were home, if it was a chapter that featured Boris, due to all of the cussing. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone as it is a significant investment of time, but if someone already felt compelled to read this, I would be interested to have a discussion. ...more

Like · see review