From the Bookshelf of Building a SciFi/Fantasy Library…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

Jul 13, 2008
Jamie Collins
rated it
liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
science-fiction,
scifi-aliens
This sequel to The Sparrow is worth reading, but I didn't enjoy it as much as the first book. It begins well enough but loses steam about halfway through.
I liked the second revealing look at the events which occurred at the end of The Sparrow, even though the author cheats: it turns out that something you thought happened in the first book didn't really happen. The new characters aren't as well-developed as the original set, and I thought the aliens were more interesting when they were more myst ...more
I liked the second revealing look at the events which occurred at the end of The Sparrow, even though the author cheats: it turns out that something you thought happened in the first book didn't really happen. The new characters aren't as well-developed as the original set, and I thought the aliens were more interesting when they were more myst ...more

This book was, arguably, just as good as it's predecessor, but since I expected it to be really good and deal with complicated issues of theology, relationships, aliens, life, etc., I was not as blown away when it did so. Because I expected it to be really good and it was.
A worthy successor to a fantastic first book. ...more
A worthy successor to a fantastic first book. ...more

I read this one faster than The Sparrow, but I think the whole thing was starting to wear a bit thin. Russell has a way of imbuing her characters with traits that you can some how tell she thinks are her best traits, and that starts to grate on your nerves (It somewhat similar to when parents get excited that their small children like a particular type of music that they think is "cool" even though the child only is interested in it because it was foisted upon them by the very same parent). She
...more

Oh joy, a happy ending for Emilio! Unfortunately it's the ending of chapter 13, not the book. Well, he has a moment anyway, before things get eventful again. While full of heartrending tragedy like the first book, this one does heal some of the wounds. I plan to read everything else I can find by Mary Doria Russell.
...more

Apr 09, 2013
Tracey
marked it as to-read
Stephanie gave 4 stars; Jaime gave 3 & Osho gave 2 stars

Sep 02, 2007
Cindywho
added it

Feb 06, 2011
Andrew
marked it as to-read

Jul 18, 2013
Beth Tabler
marked it as to-read

Oct 10, 2014
Gaijinmama
marked it as to-read

Nov 08, 2015
Kym
marked it as to-read

Jul 31, 2017
JM
marked it as to-read

Oct 30, 2017
Nicky
marked it as to-read