Burial Rites in Crazy Challenge Connection

Mar 20, 2015 Book Concierge rated it really liked it

Shelves: 19th-century, debut, historical-fiction, literary-fiction, concierge, strong-women, women-writers, crime, library, social-commentary

Audiobook performed by Morven Christie

Agnes Magnusdottir has been convicted of a brutal murder and sentenced to death. Lacking any public facilities for imprisonment, the district commissioner declares that she shall be kept on a district farm, where the fine upstanding Christian family may provide a good example to her and lead to Agnes’s repentance. Margret and Jon are not happy with this arrangement but have little choice in the matter, treating Agnes as a servant on the farm. Their daughters Audiobook performed by Morven Christie

Agnes Magnusdottir has been convicted of a brutal murder and sentenced to death. Lacking any public facilities for imprisonment, the district commissioner declares that she shall be kept on a district farm, where the fine upstanding Christian family may provide a good example to her and lead to Agnes’s repentance. Margret and Jon are not happy with this arrangement but have little choice in the matter, treating Agnes as a servant on the farm. Their daughters Steina and Lauga have decidedly different reactions; 21-year-old Steina is fascinated by Agnes and tries to draw her out, while Lauga is angry and judgmental, refusing to have anything to do with the murderess. The only person who seems to care about her is Rev Thorvadur Jonsson – Toti – who tries to draw her out and is willing to listen to her story.

This novel is based on a true incident in history. In January 1830 Agnes Magnusdottir became the last person to be executed in Iceland; she was beheaded for her role in the murders of Natan Kittelson and Petur Jonsson. Kent has crafted a wonderfully complex character study based on this incident, relying on historical records for the timeline and central facts, but embellishing with what she has imagined might have happened.

We have all witnessed the storm of controversy and conflicting reports that attend a high-profile crime. People are quick to judge and may misrepresent or “misremember” facts to suit their interpretation or pre-conceived notions of guilt (or innocence). This is not a new phenomenon; it just spreads faster with 24-hour news channels and internet coverage.

Like the farm family, I was initially put off by Agnes’s closed-off and close-mouthed demeanor; she seemed somewhat haughty for someone in her position. Agnes is a woman who has nothing, and expects nothing. But just as the family, Agnes and Toti slowly come to know and trust one another, I came to trust Agnes and found myself eager to hear her side of the story. I loved the way that these relationships slowly thawed while the landscape slowly froze.

I liked the way Kent began each chapter with either some historical document of the period or a poem or excerpt from a saga. In many ways the novel reminded me of oral story-telling traditions, where a (possibly) true incident is passed down generation to generation, taking on epic proportions and imparting some life lesson to the listeners. This was particularly evident when Agnes would relate dreams and try to interpret their meanings.

As in real life, there are no perfectly evil (nor perfectly good) characters here. The ending, however inevitable, is written in a way that still builds suspense and left me breathless.

Morven Christie does an acceptable job performing the audio version. She has good pacing, but limited voice artist skill and there was little difference in “voice” from character to character, which sometimes confused me.

...more

8 likes · Like · see review

Oct 01, 2014 Stacy rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: audiobooks, read-in-2014, historical-fiction

This was excellent on audio.

I just finished reading Burial Rites and I can't stop thinking about this book. I wish I could give it 5 stars, but there was so much of Agnes's thoughts and dreams that were just dreary and did not add much to the story IMO. Perhaps her prolonged thoughts and dreams (her sad upbringing, babbling about ravens) could have been interlaced with the story more. It is maddening that we had to wait until the very end to get the complete story about what happened.

I think so ...more

6 likes · Like · see review

Jul 04, 2024 Avigail rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: challenges, audiobook, 5-stars, 2024, librofm, physical-book

When people talk about Burial Rites, I only hear incredible things and praises. The truth is, I have had Burial Rites for many years on my long TBR shelf, and I don't know why I was so hesitant to pick it up. Historical fiction, especially based on real stories, is my favorite genre.
I would have loved Burial Rites if I had read during the winter months because of the isolated landscapes of 19th-century Iceland; I would have found myself drawn into the haunting tale of Agnes Magnúsdóttir, a wom ...more

5 likes · Like · see review

Feb 07, 2017 Nancy rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: historical-fiction

This book earned its five stars from the sheer beauty of the writing, although don't read this book if you are looking for something uplifting because it is a tragically sad story of a woman condemned in nineteenth century Iceland. I listened to the audio, and the narrator and her pronunciation were exceptional. She made the place names and the names of the characters sound like music. The way the book unfolded and the story was revealed was magnificent yet subtle - this book certainly deserves ...more

3 likes · Like · see review

May 02, 2015 Barbara ★ rated it liked it

Shelves: challenge-books, fiction, zzz-cover-body-part, x-set-in-europe, christian-religious, read-2015, zz-cover-blue, x-set-in-europe-iceland

Though the story is well-written evoking the life and times (and weather conditions) of old Iceland, I honestly found the story rather boring and depressing. Though I must say that this kind of book is not my thing. I need a little romance and/or excitement in my books and this provided neither.

Did I believe everything Agnes said? No I think she was a desperate girl who simply needed someone's kindness and she grabbed onto Natan because he showed her some. Unfortunately he played her and when s ...more

2 likes · Like · see review