From the Bookshelf of The Read Around The World Book Club…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
Which book are you reading for this prompt?
By Melanie · 16 posts · 51 views
By Melanie · 16 posts · 51 views
last updated Apr 25, 2019 06:37AM
What Members Thought

I loved this book a lot. Set in 1930ies Melbourne, young Lily meets Eva at school, the daughter of a modernist painter and gets sucked into the family’s eccentric lifestyle. Told in retrospect, I thought this was an excellent debut novel, even if I thought the last third to be a bit weaker than the book overall.

I read this book as part of Aussie April. It certainly wasn't what I expected. I thought it would mostly be about the relationship between Lily and Eva. Actually it is about all the strays that come to live in Eva's home, most of them invited by Eva's parents, Evan and Helena, to join their artists' commune in Australia during the 1930's. Lily and even Eva and her two sisters, Beatrice and Heloise are also treated as strays in this free-wheeling lifestyle, where Beatrice, as Evan comments, is mo
...more

Well this book disappointed me. As a Stella Prize winner I expected depth and intrigue and great passages of words that left me sitting there thinking. Especially after I saw the others that were on the Stella Prize longlist in 2015.
Instead I got just a shallow, easy to read book.
The characters were cliche, their interactions with each other were cliche, their interactions with the world outside their artist commune were unbelievably easy for people who were supposed to be breaking every societa ...more
Instead I got just a shallow, easy to read book.
The characters were cliche, their interactions with each other were cliche, their interactions with the world outside their artist commune were unbelievably easy for people who were supposed to be breaking every societa ...more

IT took me two goes to get into this story. Once I did, I'm hooked.
The characters are all so compelling and well drawn. I found my allegiances changing over the course of the novel which was an indication a great study of the family dynamics.
The descriptions of Melbourne at the time and the differences between the working (traditional) family compared to the bourgeois artsy family were wonderfully clever.
Really good Australian writing.
...more
The characters are all so compelling and well drawn. I found my allegiances changing over the course of the novel which was an indication a great study of the family dynamics.
The descriptions of Melbourne at the time and the differences between the working (traditional) family compared to the bourgeois artsy family were wonderfully clever.
Really good Australian writing.
...more

Apr 28, 2019
Jennie
rated it
it was ok
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fiction,
book-club-reads
Book review here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8_lO... ...more
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8_lO... ...more

Apr 26, 2015
Jess
marked it as to-read

Feb 09, 2016
Simon C
marked it as to-read

Nov 02, 2016
Aileen Sitero
marked it as to-read

Feb 08, 2017
patrice
marked it as to-read

Aug 27, 2017
Ashley
marked it as to-read

Sep 26, 2017
Emmy B
marked it as to-read

May 01, 2019
Roz
marked it as to-read