Memoirs of a Geisha in Our Shared Shelf

Mar 14, 2008 Caroline Donahue rated it really liked it

beautiful and all the more impressive that someone both different in culture, gender, and era could create such a convincing character.

2 likes · Like · see review

Feb 02, 2016 Lacey Louwagie rated it liked it

Shelves: historical-fiction, 2016-aty-reading-challenge

Around the Year Reading Challenge Item #2: A book set in a different continent

The more historical fiction I read, the more I wonder whether it's just not the genre for me, even though I like history and the ability to travel "back in time" through reading.

But despite all the accolades this book has received, I kept wondering when the story was actually going to get STARTED. To me, the book primarily felt like a way for the author to show off his intimate knowledge of Japanese history and "Geisha Around the Year Reading Challenge Item #2: A book set in a different continent

The more historical fiction I read, the more I wonder whether it's just not the genre for me, even though I like history and the ability to travel "back in time" through reading.

But despite all the accolades this book has received, I kept wondering when the story was actually going to get STARTED. To me, the book primarily felt like a way for the author to show off his intimate knowledge of Japanese history and "Geisha" culture. The minutiae of the historical details, from the designs on the kimonos to the classes Geisha took, got to be a little much for me, especially since this book fell into the common pitfall of historical fiction, in which events that seem important enough to be dramatized in scenes are skimmed over in summary instead.

The characters were believable, and some of them were intriguing. I was especially interested in Mameha. But I didn't like how much of the book was centered around girl-on-girl aggression, "mean girl" tactics, and female jealousy. About halfway into the book, I found myself thinking, "Huh, I didn't know this book was going to be mostly about female rivalry."

The love story was only moderately satisfying to me -- I could understand why Sayuri was so drawn to The Chairman, but (view spoiler)

I did like the way this book explored issues of privilege and choice -- despite the luxurious and glamorous lives that some geisha lived, and despite the satisfaction they drew from their profession, they are still essentially slaves who must make their decisions out of necessity rather than any true agency or desire. Sayuri's desire to set her own course despite these restrictions creates most of the tension in the second half of the book, and while I could understand her reasons for doing the things she did, I still found myself feeling a little annoyed with her. (view spoiler)

Overall, I am not sorry I read this, and the book's second half definitely moves along at a better pace than the beginning. But I remain somewhat suspicious of a Western, white man's interpretation of a Japanese woman's life, even if he did hold advanced degrees in Japanese history, especially since he gives her the incongruous and Western-valued blue eyes. I would have much rather read a real memoir from a real geisha.

A note on the movie: This is one of those rare instances in which I rated the movie higher than the book. I gave the movie 4 stars. It was visually beautiful, and it was also faithful to the book without getting bogged down in so many of the details. There were a few things I would have done differently -- (view spoiler) So I think this is a movie best enjoyed after reading the book, and even then, perhaps only if, like me, you didn't like the book all that much, anyway. (A friend of mine who liked the book thought the movie was awful.)

There's an interesting article about the Japanese reaction to the movie here: https://www.quora.com/How-do-Japanese... ...more

Like · see review

Jun 23, 2008 Heather rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: adult

Well, my last book on the GR most-read-all-time list (world) was somewhat disappointing. Have you ever read a book that everyone has loved, found it to be less than amazing, and wondered if you're just an idiot who's missing something?...Yeah. While parts of the story were interesting and I found myself getting caught up in them, and it was basically likable most of the time, I also had many criticisms and was somewhat surprised this was a most-read. My critiques:
1. Tedious! Some of the details ...more

Like · see review