Persuasion in Our Shared Shelf

Sep 12, 2008 Iamshadow rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction, history, classic

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. This is definitely my favourite Austen novel, though I like aspects of all of them.

Why this above the others, though?

Well, for me, this novel is, and always has been since the first time I read it at sixteen, a much more mature work than Austen's earlier novels. I can relate better to Anne Elliot than to some of her other heroines. The relationships she has with people are more believable and understandable, too, and Anne's situation isn't one of a whirlwind courtship and marriage. Indeed, the o This is definitely my favourite Austen novel, though I like aspects of all of them.

Why this above the others, though?

Well, for me, this novel is, and always has been since the first time I read it at sixteen, a much more mature work than Austen's earlier novels. I can relate better to Anne Elliot than to some of her other heroines. The relationships she has with people are more believable and understandable, too, and Anne's situation isn't one of a whirlwind courtship and marriage. Indeed, the only 'hasty' marriage in the whole work is that of Louisa and Captain Benwick, and even that makes some sense given Louisa's change of character after her accident; her new reserve suits Benwick's personality perfectly.

While Pride and Prejudice and Sense and Sensibility are about young, new love, Persuasion is about two people, long separated by life and circumstance, reconnecting and finding that what they felt, years beforehand, remains unchanged. Anne and Captain Wentworth's romance is an adult one, with a slow, gradual 'sounding out' of each other's feelings (naturally, with a typical Austenian rogue thrown in to complicate matters somewhat).

And the clincher for me as to what makes this the best Austen novel is the well-developed and likeable cast of supporting characters. The Musgroves leap from the page; vibrant, warm and natural. Anne's sister Mary is contrary and frustrating to live with, no doubt, but is incredibly enjoyable to read and much less grating on the nerves than Mrs Bennett of Pride and Prejudice. Benwick, the melancholy scholar with a tragic past, who finds solace in Anne's attentions and then the arms of Louisa, and the Crofts, both worldly and cultured and completely without artifice, are also dear to my heart. But my favourite supporting character of all would have to be Mrs Smith. Though she features only in a handful of short scenes, most of which she is used mainly as a vehicle for exposition, I really do adore her.

For those who like this book, I highly recommend the 1995 TV adaptation. It's very faithful to the book, and the casting is superb. Sophie Thompson's portrayal of Mary Musgrove is wonderful. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Nov 27, 2014 Cynthia Paschen rated it liked it

Shelves: book-group

I was really struggling with this and waiting for something to happen besides furtive glances and dialogue that hinted at something, and oh, goodness.

Then on page 100 we were introduced to Captain Benwick, a true brooding romantic hero! Shortly thereafter, Louisa has a concussion and things start to happen. Woot! Stuff is happening!

Many of my friends adore this book, and Anne Elliot. I tried, I read every page, but I can not love Jane Austen.

2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 21, 2022 Christine Hopkins rated it liked it

Shelves: classics, books-i-own

"It is the worst evil of too yielding and indecisive a character, that no influence over it can be depended on. You are never sure of a good impression being durable. Every body may sway it; let those who would be happy be firm."

3.5 controversial to many stars

This is my first Austen book and I think I may just prefer the Bronte sisters to her. There was a lot of telling instead of of showing or conversation that bogged me down. I know so many people adore Austen, though, so I'm definitely going ...more

Like · see review

Feb 04, 2010 Anna rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

As always, I love Austen. I love her use of language and her characters.

Like · see review

Feb 12, 2011 Claire rated it it was amazing

Shelves: classics, fiction

I varied between kicking myself for never picking this book up until now and congratulating myself for saving it until I could appreciate it most. What a lovely read!

Like · see review

Sep 18, 2016 Ashley rated it it was amazing

Jane....what else can I say?

Like · see review

Jun 10, 2011 melissa added it

Shelves: women

(Not a review, just notes for myself)
I think I read this in or right after college. Then I started it again in 2011, but I don't think I finished it (at least I never updated it here). I saw a few reviews of the new Netflix movie and had an itch to read it again. ...more

Like · see review