From the Bookshelf of Around the Year in 52 Books …
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

Audiobook performed by Susan Denaker
From the book jacket When college sophomore Laurel Estabrook is attacked while riding her bicycle through Vermont’s back roads, her life is forever changed. Formerly outgoing, Laurel withdraws into her photography and begins to work at a homeless shelter. There she meets Bobbie Crocker, a man with a history of mental illness and a box of photographs he won’t let anyone see. When Bobbie dies, Laurel discovers that he was telling the truth; before he was homele ...more
From the book jacket When college sophomore Laurel Estabrook is attacked while riding her bicycle through Vermont’s back roads, her life is forever changed. Formerly outgoing, Laurel withdraws into her photography and begins to work at a homeless shelter. There she meets Bobbie Crocker, a man with a history of mental illness and a box of photographs he won’t let anyone see. When Bobbie dies, Laurel discovers that he was telling the truth; before he was homele ...more

The first thing I did before I started this book was head to Wikipedia and read a summary of The Great Gatsby, since it’s been 12+ years since I read it, and it’s really an integral part of this book. I recommend that to anyone who picks this up.
I often start thinking about what I’m going to say about a book before I finish it. As I neared the end of this, my thoughts were “this wasn’t as good as Midwives or Water Witches“. Then, Bohjalian gives you a very M. Night Shyamalan-esque twist that com ...more
I often start thinking about what I’m going to say about a book before I finish it. As I neared the end of this, my thoughts were “this wasn’t as good as Midwives or Water Witches“. Then, Bohjalian gives you a very M. Night Shyamalan-esque twist that com ...more

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.

I had a hard time with this book. Chris Bojalian uses the Great Gatsby characters as if they were real people and the events depicted in the Great Gatsby really happened. I felt like this was pretty cheesy but I eventually bought into it for the sake of reading the story. The ending of the book has a real twist and I felt like Bojalian betrayed the reader with the ending. I felt a little conned by the whole thing.

Recently reread Gatsby...rumor has it that it's a good link to this one...will let you know!
Update...seems predictable about 1/2 way in...and the author refers to the "color" of things in 1922 pictures...not so believable. There are also these bizarre/unrelated rants interspersed.
In the very end, it comes together fairly well; however, it took too long... Not nearly as good as Midwives. ...more
Update...seems predictable about 1/2 way in...and the author refers to the "color" of things in 1922 pictures...not so believable. There are also these bizarre/unrelated rants interspersed.
In the very end, it comes together fairly well; however, it took too long... Not nearly as good as Midwives. ...more

This book really threw me for a loop!! What a surprise ending!!! I think I'll have to read it again very soon.
...more


Jul 10, 2010
Beth F
marked it as owned-and-unread

Oct 09, 2011
Shani
marked it as to-read

Oct 10, 2014
Bea
marked it as wishlist

Dec 01, 2014
Meghan
marked it as to-read

Mar 11, 2017
Sonya
marked it as to-read

Oct 04, 2017
Melissa Seng
marked it as to-read

Jan 26, 2022
Carrie Gray
marked it as to-read

Jul 14, 2022
John Warner
marked it as to-read