Dead Water (Roderick Alleyn, #23) in Reading the Detectives

Oct 26, 2019 Susan rated it liked it · review of another edition

This is the twenty third book in the Roderick Alleyn series, which was first published in 1963. The mystery is set in Portcarrow, where a sudden miracle, in a local spring, sees a young boy cured of his warts. This leads to a great deal of tourist money pouring into the local community. Major Barrymore has more guests as the ‘Boy and Lobster,’ the Reverend Carstairs finds his Church Fund suddenly has a surge of donations, Miss Cost opens her ‘Gift Shoppe,’ and even Dr Maine finds himself extendi ...more

15 likes · Like · see review

Nov 09, 2019 Bev rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: british-mystery, marsh-challenge, bought-2019, mystery, silver-age-mystery

Dead Water (1963) by Ngaio Marsh takes us back to the village setting--this time a small fishing community at Portcarrow. It begins with a scene two years in the past when a young boy by the name of Wally Trehern experiences what seems to be a miraculous cure. Plagued by warts all over his hands, he has suffered the jeers and taunts of his schoolmates for years. On this occasion he runs away from them to a local spring where he encounters a lady in green who tells him to wash his hands in the sp Dead Water (1963) by Ngaio Marsh takes us back to the village setting--this time a small fishing community at Portcarrow. It begins with a scene two years in the past when a young boy by the name of Wally Trehern experiences what seems to be a miraculous cure. Plagued by warts all over his hands, he has suffered the jeers and taunts of his schoolmates for years. On this occasion he runs away from them to a local spring where he encounters a lady in green who tells him to wash his hands in the spring water...and if he believes his warts will be cured. The next day his warts have fallen off as if by magic and soon the legend of the green lady and the newly christened "Pixie Falls" is spread.

Mrs. Fanny Winterbottom , the current owner of the land where the spring is found has no problem with pilgrims coming to the site and the village making what profit they can from the magical waters. An entry fee is established, a gift shop is set up, and the local pub/inn begins turning a profit for the first time in recent memory. And then...two years later, Mrs. Winterbottom dies and her sister Miss Emily Pride, a French language expert, comes into possession. Miss Pride doesn't hold with commercializing people's belief in mystical cures. She sends messages to the village that all commercial enterprises connected to the spring must stop--she won't prevent folks from coming to the spring if they want to, but there will be no more advertisement and no more profiting from it. She also announces her intention to visit the area to see what exactly needs to be done to return the spring and surrounding land to its former condition.

Well...naturally this doesn't go down so well with those who have made a business of the thing and Miss Pride receives threats made of cut-up newsprint. So, she calls upon the help of one of her former pupils--Superintendent Roderick Alleyn. He advises her to give up the plan to visit Portcarrow and to conduct her business through an attorney. But Miss Pride is a determined woman and believes in facing up to one's obligations. She goes anyway...and is the victim of an assault (from rock-throwing) and more threats. Alleyn arrives in the village for the first (and, if Miss Pride has her way, only) Pixie Falls Festival and is just in time to discover the body of a middle-aged woman, knocked out and drowned at the spring. Surprisingly enough, it's not Miss Pride who has been murdered, but Elspeth Cost--a middle-aged woman who has been the driving force in the mystification and veneration of the spring. Was she, as it appears, mistaken for Miss Pride and then killed anyway to prevent her from identifying the attacker? Or were there reasons for someone to kill Miss Cost? Alleyn will have to sort that out in order to identify the killer.

This wound up being a middle-of-the road Marsh book for me. I had better memories of it (from my first reading 30ish years ago) than were realized in this go-round. The best of the book was Miss Emily Pride--even though she is well-named and pride almost goes before a fall. She is a determined and independent lady and it was nice to see Marsh portray a spinster in a more favorable light. I did appreciate her principled view of the supposed miracle cures. She didn't imply that they were fake, but she absolutely refused to be a party to anyone taking financial advantage of the situation. I was also amused by her relationship with Alleyn--it was fun to see him so disconcerted by his former French tutor.

The book turns Alleyn into an action figure of sorts at the dramatic end--with the murderer bolting and Alleyn giving chase through a coastal storm and finding himself in danger of life. Not the usual drawing room summing up. With a fairly good plot (I didn't guess the murderer this time) and the exciting finish, this comes in at a solid ★★★.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting review content. Thanks. ...more

6 likes · Like · see review

Oct 01, 2019 ShanDizzy rated it liked it · review of another edition

"That's Wally's cottage. We're about to climb Wally's Way - and that is Wally's mama, another alcoholic, by the by, leering over the back fence. His father is ferryman at high tide and general showman in between. The whole boiling of them - the Barrimores, the Parson, the Doctor, the Major, the Treherns, Miss Cost herself, with pretty well everybody else in the community - stood to lose by Miss Pride's operations. Apart from arousing the cornered fury of a hunted male, it's difficult to discover ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Mar 31, 2019 Jacqueline Vick rated it really liked it

Shelves: mysteries

Ngaio Marsh, like many of her contemporaries, takes time to introduce the characters and the situations before bringing in Chief Inspector Roderick Alleyn. Though I am sometimes impatient for his appearance, I do enjoy this buildup. Dead Water has a cast of colorful and suspicious characters. The murder takes place around the Festival of the Green Lady, and Marsh shows us how easy it is for people to join in the worship of anything, whether their motives are greed, a need for attention, or a des ...more

Like · see review