From the Bookshelf of Overdue Podcast…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

Also posted on my blog, with a little more blather.
Edison single-handedly discovered electricity. Paul Revere made a midnight ride to warn village folk that the British were approaching. Of course, Christopher Columbus was the first European to discover America. Richard III had his two young nephews killed off in the Tower of London. These are some "the sky is blue, grass is green" basic truths of history.
Well, the sky does, often, appear blue, and grass is, under certain conditions, green. As ...more
Edison single-handedly discovered electricity. Paul Revere made a midnight ride to warn village folk that the British were approaching. Of course, Christopher Columbus was the first European to discover America. Richard III had his two young nephews killed off in the Tower of London. These are some "the sky is blue, grass is green" basic truths of history.
Well, the sky does, often, appear blue, and grass is, under certain conditions, green. As ...more


When you think about it, taking this on was a brave endeavor. If you're working on the 5th installment in a detective series you might assume that your readers have certain expectations. But here there is no body in the library, no witnesses or suspects to question, no way to end it conclusively. Only a face that doesn't quite fit what the history books say. And yet, this is named "one of the best mysteries of all time". I can't disagree.
Tey's writing is emblematic of the time period and I love ...more
Tey's writing is emblematic of the time period and I love ...more

I know I read this in high school, but had forgotten basically everything except that it went a long way towards exonerating Richard III, making a solid case against the Tudor story that he'd been responsible for the deaths of his nephews. Tey strips our notions of what makes a detective story down to the studs: what is a detective story but a question puzzled over & over until a theory of the case develops? Does a detective have to zip about his service area himself, interviewing people of inte
...more

It took me about 100 pages to get into this book. As a history lover, I wasn't too fond of the constant "historians are so misguided; you can't trust history books." But the piecing together of the evidence and the discussion of the ramifications of each piece was pretty interesting.
...more

I expected a mystery, and it isn't, really. It's more of a historical research book. I think I would have enjoyed it more if I were more familiar with English history and the succession of the throne. I can barely keep Henry VIII's wives in my head, so this, even with a family tree in the front, just didn't work well for me (other than for putting me to sleep.) Still, if that is something you enjoy (history! research! kings!) I think you will like it.
...more

Reread March 2008: A re-read of one of my favourite books. It always makes me happy, and angry, and sad. I still think someone could make this into a really good movie.
Reread May 2010. (After reading The White Queen by Philippa Gregory, I had to re-read this to get Alan Grant's opinion on the Woodvilles and the whole situation.)
Rereading February 2013, prompted by the discovery of Richard's bones.
Reread April 2016. ...more
Reread May 2010. (After reading The White Queen by Philippa Gregory, I had to re-read this to get Alan Grant's opinion on the Woodvilles and the whole situation.)
Rereading February 2013, prompted by the discovery of Richard's bones.
Reread April 2016. ...more

Mar 15, 2013
Maggie M
marked it as to-read

May 11, 2017
Mayumi
marked it as to-read

Aug 15, 2019
Sarah
marked it as to-read

Dec 01, 2019
Thorn
marked it as to-read

Jan 29, 2022
Kellee
marked it as dnf
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
recommended-by-modern-mrs-darcy

Jun 22, 2022
Nichole Cianci
added it

Jan 03, 2024
Shannon
marked it as to-read

Mar 24, 2025
Caitlin
marked it as to-read