From the Bookshelf of Mock Caldecott 2026…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
*
Our 2018 Mock Caldecott Award Winner is:
By Kristen · 24 posts · 186 views
By Kristen · 24 posts · 186 views
last updated Feb 17, 2018 05:02PM
What Members Thought
11/24/2017 ** A poem about the bygone days of milk delivery and the steady devotion of the horse that draws the cart. the line sketches by Erin Stead add to the sense of peace in the early morning. The poem and illustrations work well together.
Though this was discussed early (August) as a potential Caldecott and was on a few lists, I chose not to include it in the books my students will consider. It didn't seem to have enough appeal to children. ...more
Though this was discussed early (August) as a potential Caldecott and was on a few lists, I chose not to include it in the books my students will consider. It didn't seem to have enough appeal to children. ...more
Extremely charming little story about a horse that pulls a milk delivery cart. Erin Stead's illustrations are just lovely. The story behind this book is incredible and worth reading about. Erin Stead found this poem in a newspaper, finally tracked down the author only to learn he had died. The writing in the book is Galing's, published posthumously. Just a neat story of inspiration.
...more
3.5
Quiet story with muted illustrations that perfectly reflect the early morning setting and the nostalgic topic.
Quiet story with muted illustrations that perfectly reflect the early morning setting and the nostalgic topic.
3 stars text, 5 stars illustrations. Gorgeous sketches by Erin Stead. Hazy and detailed at the same time.
Historical fiction life story without a story -- a day in the life. Pretty but not very interesting.
Beautiful and simple illustrations
Very simple and spare, but beautiful. This is a very understated story, about the morning rounds of a horse and man who deliver milk, etc. early in the morning, and the (unseen) man or boy who loves to come out and greet the horse each morning. The illustrations are beautifully executed, the colors very muted grays, greens and yellows. It reminds me a bit of A Sick Day for Amos McGee, but the latter uses more color.
Small moment story of the memory of the milk wagon pulled by a horse named Tony. Illustrations by Erin E. Stead are a perfect match to this book. Such a soft and peaceful sense to them. This book BEGS to be shared, especially with a grandparent and a grandchild as they may remember when milk was delivered to houses.
Tony is a horse who delivers milk, eggs and cheese. Simple, old fashion feel to it. Illustration are similar in style and colors used to Uncorker of Ocean Bottles. - Same illustrator.
What beautiful illustrations!
Mar 08, 2017
Patty Barr
marked it as to-read
May 10, 2017
Katie Ruth
marked it as to-read
Aug 21, 2017
Heather
marked it as to-read
