From the Bookshelf of Beyond Reality…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

I'm not a writer, but as a reader I can say that writing short stories would be hard work. You have to build a universe, develop characters and set up a plot all within a few short pages (I think around 50 pages was the longest story in this book). Ted Chiang does that and more in all of these stories.
I simply enjoyed each one. Granted, I guess I had a favorite ( I don't want to make the other stories jealous, so I'm not telling). I appreciate the direct and unapologetic manner in which themes ...more
I simply enjoyed each one. Granted, I guess I had a favorite ( I don't want to make the other stories jealous, so I'm not telling). I appreciate the direct and unapologetic manner in which themes ...more

Mar 10, 2017
Kerry
rated it
it was amazing
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
8-out-of-10,
2010,
library,
sf,
2021,
reread,
rereads-in-2021,
10-out-of-10,
shorter-than-a-novel,
2017
Previously read single stories, now reading entire collection in 2021.
I managed to finish Stories of Your Life and Others by Ted Chiang today which made me happy. His stories are really good and I'm really glad and everything. I'm just sorry it took me quite as long as it did. So many of the stories, I was reading them thinking Dad would really like this. I wish I could have pushed these on Dad sooner, but it's not making me desperately miserable. It's a melancholy kind of sad that reminds you t ...more
I managed to finish Stories of Your Life and Others by Ted Chiang today which made me happy. His stories are really good and I'm really glad and everything. I'm just sorry it took me quite as long as it did. So many of the stories, I was reading them thinking Dad would really like this. I wish I could have pushed these on Dad sooner, but it's not making me desperately miserable. It's a melancholy kind of sad that reminds you t ...more

Ted Chiang writes sf that makes the reader think. I tend to like a bit more movement and action, which is why I gave it four stars rather than five. Most of these stories have a theological bent, which was another reason. Story of your life, is a story that had my imagination engaged and that is something I, as a writer, do enjoy. I did like most of the stories, they just weren't what I tend to read. Ted Chiang is also somewhat of a scientist and he uses a scientist nomenclature. I had to put th
...more

My favorites:
"Story of Your Life" - This was my favorite in the collection! The narrative style reflects the plot events, and plus, it's all about learning languages (and physics), with some emotional connection thrown in! Yay!
"Liking What You See: A Documentary" - Well-done documentary style. There's a smallish plot thrown in with Tamera, which keeps it a little more interesting.
Stories that were ok:
"Division by Zero"
"Understand"
"The Evolution of Human Science"
Stories I didn't like:
"Hell Is the ...more
"Story of Your Life" - This was my favorite in the collection! The narrative style reflects the plot events, and plus, it's all about learning languages (and physics), with some emotional connection thrown in! Yay!
"Liking What You See: A Documentary" - Well-done documentary style. There's a smallish plot thrown in with Tamera, which keeps it a little more interesting.
Stories that were ok:
"Division by Zero"
"Understand"
"The Evolution of Human Science"
Stories I didn't like:
"Hell Is the ...more

It's amazing how Ted Chiang can write diverse themes: medicine, mathematics, linguistics, physics, magic, religion, a reteling of a myth, you name it. Some are harder to understand (blame it on my lack of knowledge), but I like the way he assumes that the readers are able to sufficiently comprehend it, without going on and on explaining things. I particularly like the one titled "Liking what you see: a documentary" because of its documentary style and inventiveness.
Would love to read more of his ...more
Would love to read more of his ...more

Dec 01, 2010
Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
anthologies-and-collections,
science-fiction
This is a kind of SF few people seem to be capable of writing - literate and literary without being dull, and concerned with the facts of science without just infodumping. Probably more like a 3.5, though. I admit that there were some stories that didn't grab me, but there were some really awesome ones. Particularly the last one.
...more

One of the best short story collections I've read in a very long time.
A mixture of solid 5 star stories and none less than 4 stars; I'm in a generous mood at the moment so giving the overall collection 5 stars.
If you tend towards the more scientific or mathamatical, but also like messing around with the purely fantastical then I highly reccomend giving this collection a try. ...more
A mixture of solid 5 star stories and none less than 4 stars; I'm in a generous mood at the moment so giving the overall collection 5 stars.
If you tend towards the more scientific or mathamatical, but also like messing around with the purely fantastical then I highly reccomend giving this collection a try. ...more

No doubt Chiang is a great short story writer. All of these stories are original and imaginative and are actually quite intellectually challenging. I wasn't highly entertained by them, but I was highly impressed.
...more

Nov 03, 2009
Sarah
added it

Dec 19, 2010
Patrick
marked it as other


Feb 01, 2017
Kevin
marked it as to-read


Jul 29, 2017
Mike
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
science-fiction,
2017



Jul 28, 2019
Tabor Wells
marked it as to-read