From the Bookshelf of Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

It's always scary to reread your adolescent favorites and worry about whether you had absolutely awful taste back then.
I did not. ...more
I did not. ...more

I was a little worried at first that maybe this was just going to be a sort of typical teenage/young adult whine-fest sort of book. It started off a little bit "mean-girlsy" for me. But in all honesty, that really is how high school girls are a lot of the time. Trust me, I know, I substitute teach part time at an all girls private school! And then, I was worried it might take a sort of Harry Potter turn, and I was getting all: "Ugh, I've read this story already!"
But, I kept with it, and it reall ...more
But, I kept with it, and it reall ...more

i liked it. definitely enough to pick up the next book - it was an easy read for me, and i liked gemma. i did not like ann very much, but felicity is amusing (in a good way) and pippa has an interesting storyline.
i also like the historical setting, gemma coming from india and then back to mother england. kartik, carriages pulled by horses, gypsies speaking romani. it's a very pretty book. which i was in the mood to appreciate. plus, i liked the mystery of it. and it wasn't a veiled critique on ...more
i also like the historical setting, gemma coming from india and then back to mother england. kartik, carriages pulled by horses, gypsies speaking romani. it's a very pretty book. which i was in the mood to appreciate. plus, i liked the mystery of it. and it wasn't a veiled critique on ...more

This was pretty good, although it did annoy me at times. I'm interested to know what the heck is going on, so I guess I have to read the rest of the series---I hate that the book didn't really have closure.
...more
...more

Jun 09, 2007
Heather - hturningpages
rated it
really liked it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
loved-it
For a girl with a wild and reckless imagination! Read on a stormy night under the covers...


Feb 16, 2008
Amanda
added it

Sep 19, 2011
Laura
marked it as to-read

Jan 01, 2015
Katie
marked it as to-read

Jan 30, 2018
Rhosyn Goodfellow
marked it as to-read

Oct 15, 2021
Katy
marked it as to-read