From the Bookshelf of Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought

Except for the fair that is held in a mysterious meadow once every nine years, the people of Wall never cross the wall into the faerie meadow.
Dunstan Thorn meets a beautiful, enslaved woman at the fair and nine months later a baby is delivered to his doorstep.
Dunstan's son, Tristran, grows up not knowing his heritage. When he falls in love, he rashly promises his beloved that he will do anything for her. Not really taking him seriously, she asks him to bring her back a falling star.
Tristran set ...more
Dunstan Thorn meets a beautiful, enslaved woman at the fair and nine months later a baby is delivered to his doorstep.
Dunstan's son, Tristran, grows up not knowing his heritage. When he falls in love, he rashly promises his beloved that he will do anything for her. Not really taking him seriously, she asks him to bring her back a falling star.
Tristran set ...more

A lovely, fairy-tale of a novel, written with Gaiman's usual ability to carry the reader into the world he creates. His words are so beautiful, his ideas out of the ordinary! This passage describes a fairy market:
"There were wonders for sale, and marvels, and miracles; there were things undreamed-of and objects unimagined (what need, Dunstan wondered, could someone have of the storm-filled eggshells?).
A flaw that bothered me: there were times when the plot should have been filled in more, rather ...more
"There were wonders for sale, and marvels, and miracles; there were things undreamed-of and objects unimagined (what need, Dunstan wondered, could someone have of the storm-filled eggshells?).
A flaw that bothered me: there were times when the plot should have been filled in more, rather ...more

Except for the fair that is held in a mysterious meadow once every nine years, the people of Wall never cross the wall into the faerie meadow.
Dunstan Thorn meets a beautiful, enslaved woman at the fair and nine months later a baby is delivered to his doorstep.
Dunstan's son, Tristran, grows up not knowing his heritage. When he falls in love, he rashly promises his beloved that he will do anything for her. Not really taking him seriously, she asks him to bring her back a falling star.
Tristran set ...more
Dunstan Thorn meets a beautiful, enslaved woman at the fair and nine months later a baby is delivered to his doorstep.
Dunstan's son, Tristran, grows up not knowing his heritage. When he falls in love, he rashly promises his beloved that he will do anything for her. Not really taking him seriously, she asks him to bring her back a falling star.
Tristran set ...more

I liked this book, but didn’t love it. There were parts and characters that were funny, scary and interesting but at times it almost seemed like Gaiman was over doing it. Why do there have to be the dead brothers of Stronghold? And the witches? Really? I guess you just don’t go out to Faerie and not encounter danger, but at the same time it seemed a little like following every fairy tale plot device all in one book. It is possible that my viewing of the movie right before reading this book color
...more

Nov 29, 2010
Dana
marked it as to-read

Jan 09, 2011
Erica
marked it as to-read

Feb 24, 2011
Tara
marked it as to-read


Jun 12, 2012
Julia
marked it as to-read

Jun 28, 2012
Jenny
marked it as to-read

Nov 19, 2012
Shannon
marked it as to-read


Dec 27, 2015
katy
marked it as to-read

Jan 03, 2016
Julie C.
marked it as to-read

Apr 23, 2016
Lorna
marked it as unfinished