One Hundred Years of Solitude in Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge

Apr 05, 2013 Jennifer rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: fiction, translated, bookslut-100-books

(review originally written for bookslut)

Getting One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcia Marquez on the Bookslut list was hard work. Both my sister and Mike were opposed to it making it on the list, I was the only one who insisted. Having not read the book myself, I was basing this opinion on what I had read, here and there, describing the book as influential, it's inclusion on other lists of great books, and certainly also on the recommendation of several of my friends, all of whom profe (review originally written for bookslut)

Getting One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcia Marquez on the Bookslut list was hard work. Both my sister and Mike were opposed to it making it on the list, I was the only one who insisted. Having not read the book myself, I was basing this opinion on what I had read, here and there, describing the book as influential, it's inclusion on other lists of great books, and certainly also on the recommendation of several of my friends, all of whom professed to love the book. My husband had read the book just a year before and seemed to really enjoy it. So I thought it deserved a place on the list.

Now that I've read it, I'm not so sure. The book was interesting, I enjoyed several of the characters, it addressed many grand themes in life, but.... The book moved in circles, constantly repeating itself, and the ending was unsatisfactory. I suppose that this is more like real life than most fiction with their clear plots and neat endings, but this book was anything but realistic, with its man who was always followed by yellow butterflies and young woman who ascended straight up into heaven. And although I certainly understand the point of many of the characters having the same names, it definitely made following along difficult, especially with the author's habit of jumping backward and forward in time, sometimes for no clear reason.

This isn't to say that I wasn't totally engrossed in the book for periods of time. But was it compelling enough to be on the list of best books of the century?

The book is the story of one couple, all their descendants, and the town they lived in. Unfortunately, nearly all of these descendants end up with a name that is some combination of the names Jose Arcadio, Aureliano, and Amaranta. The names themselves seem to be a curse, as each new child seems to end up with the personality and/or unfortunate fate of their namesake. With the family's matriarch so paranoid about inbreeding creating children with pigs' tails, one might think she would eventually clue in to the fact that innaming was doing far more damage to the family. But no one seems to learn anything at all in this book. The family just goes on and on, making the same mistakes over and over. I kept struggling through it, hoping for a moment of redemption that never came.

It's entirely possible that there was some point, some greater meaning to the book that I just didn't get. I am willing to concede that, but I am equally unwilling to read the book again in order to discover it. From now on when I want "magical realism," I'll turn to Salman Rushdie and Ben Okri. ...more

Like · see review

Sep 22, 2007 Arianna rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: storedmd

Beautiful story, but...I wasn't in love with it as I know others have been. Perhaps that was because I had to spread it out over a long period of time, and read intermittently between schoolwork. But it was well-written; I was often frustrated by the closeness of names, though, and of stories referred to that I'd already forgotten or confused. I might have to read this one more than once to tease out the true meaning. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 24, 2011 Deb rated it did not like it · review of another edition

Maybe I should have read this as part of a college literature class, with guided and deep conversations... because not only did i not "get"it, I don't care to get it. Ouch. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Sep 15, 2009 Jessica rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: re-reads

This was my second time reading One Hundred Years of Solitude, but enough time had gone by that I remembered liking the book but didn't remember much about what happened in it, so it was really enjoyable to come back to it after all that time.

García Márquez is famous for his use of magical realism, but I think what makes his books stand out so much from others in that genre is how understated the magical elements are. Weird things happen, but they happen so matter-of-factly, and in such minor ro ...more

Like · see review

Oct 30, 2012 Alya rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: 2012, grad-school

This remains one of my favorite books every time I read it. And now, Studying it in grad school, I understand so much the more where the magic comes from and the frightening truths about Columbia and Latin American history... Just a brilliant read.

Like · see review