The Underground Railroad in Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge

Dec 13, 2016 Cathy rated it it was amazing

Can I give this six stars? I am blown away and crushed under the weight of this novel at the same time. I initially resisted reading this book, as it had received so much acclaim. I am ever wary of hype. I also had read one of Colson Whitehead's previous books, Sag Harbor, which I enjoyed, but was light and fluffy and didn't make me think he could do the subject of slavery justice. I here and now eat my hat. This is his magnum opus. I stand in awe of his growth as a writer. This book is about Co ...more

9 likes · Like · see review

Mar 01, 2017 Sarah rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction, black-history-and-culture, american-fiction, classics

Closed out Black History Month by finishing this one. Five stars is deceptive - do not read this if you don't want to have some unspeakably violent images seared into your mind. You will remember some of the scenes Whitehead so graphically depicts for the rest of your life, regardless of how hard you may try to get rid of them. And the book is also realistically bleak, much of the time. It's merciless. But... I would argue that that bleakness and those scenes are precisely why you should read it ...more

4 likes · Like · see review

Feb 05, 2017 Nadine in NY Jones rated it it was amazing

Shelves: pulitzer-winner, lotsa-buzz, alternate-planes-and-histories, only-reading-because-of-the-buzz, 100-best-of-21st-c, literary-schmiterary, historical-fiction, national-book-award-winners, era-early-mid-1800s

She let the farm convince her the world is other than what it will always be.

I was surprised by how much I liked this. I had read Zone One and thought it was good but not great, and I usually don't like Oprah picks, and the reviews for this book on FR are mixed, and the subject matter sounded pretty depressing .... but my Goodreads group chose it for the February read, and my hold came in at the library, and I sat down just to read the first few pages, and holy cow I didn't want to put it do

She let the farm convince her the world is other than what it will always be.

I was surprised by how much I liked this. I had read Zone One and thought it was good but not great, and I usually don't like Oprah picks, and the reviews for this book on FR are mixed, and the subject matter sounded pretty depressing .... but my Goodreads group chose it for the February read, and my hold came in at the library, and I sat down just to read the first few pages, and holy cow I didn't want to put it down. Whitehead's slightly emotionless style, which bugged me in Zone One, is perfect here. The only way to get through these atrocities is with the Emotion Meter turned way way down.

I'm not really sure if it's okay to say I "liked" it, or it was "great" - because can you say that about books that include rather vivid descriptions of atrocities and torture? I wanted to keep reading it, I wanted to know what happened to Cora next. I could barely stand to put it down. It was riveting, in the best and worst ways.

After I finished this, I had to set it down and think for a while, to figure out what it was I had just read. I ended up adding it to my "alternate planes and histories" shelf, because I think this is more of an alternate history than a real history. The atrocities happened, the runaway slave advertisements were real, but the rest of it is just slightly skewed. (The most obvious example: there was not an actual underground railroad, as there is in this book. But that's not the only difference, it's just the one that people seem to notice first. The descriptions of the country in this book are not historically accurate, but they feel accurate, because each situation did happen, in another way. (view spoiler) As Whitehead puts it: "each state is a different state of American possibility. ... And each time our protagonist gets out of the station in a new place, we sort of rebooted America in a different sort of way." you can read the rest of his interview here: http://www.npr.org/2016/08/06/4889698...) That off-kilter nature of the story keeps you just a little more uncomfortable than you might otherwise have been, and that really added to the reading experience for me. This is not a history book!

This book is about power. It’s about the power of words, to create a world for the reader. It’s about the power in learning how to read. It’s about the power that some people wrongly hold over other people. It’s about the power of a group of people acting together, and the power of a group of people acting against each other. It’s about the power of truth, and fable, and falsehoods; the power that a falsehood can hold, believing it to be true all your life, and how that affects your actions (or doesn’t affect your actions). And it’s about the power of the hidden truth that you never learn. And this book is about the power of the reader, to interpret things as she will, not necessarily as the writer intended. Each meaning is the true meaning.

Cora kicked Ridgeway in the face three times with her new wooden shoes. She thought, If the world will not stir itself to punish the wicked. No one stopped her. Later she said it was three kicks for three murders … But that was not the truth of it. It was all for her.

And this book is about inevitability. The inevitability of life is that it just keeps coming, every day, until it stops, and you never know what’s around the corner. Most days are just like every other day, until one day is not, and you don’t know, you can’t see it coming. And sometimes there is power in never giving up, in never accepting the inevitability of your circumstances, even if maybe you can never change them. Sometimes there is no power at all.

In life some people will betray you, and some people will help you, and most people will be indifferent to you. And you can’t always tell who is who, not even after it happens. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Dec 06, 2022 Loretta rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: audiobooks

Unlike most of my audio reads, I had to take this one slowly, in small pieces. It is, unsurprisingly, a hard read (any book about /set in chattel slavery should be a hard read, and if it isn't hard it's probably not an honest depiction). But it is a powerful, vivid, beautifully crafted word that should be read and taken in. And if you are a white reader, I do recommend taking it slow so you can notice your own reactions and defensiveness and desire to turn away. We cannot turn away. This history ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Sep 23, 2016 Jess rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fiction, south, family, horror, terror, death, retelling, metafiction, community, crime

I'm not exaggerating when I say that this should be required reading for every American. An extraordinary retelling of African-American history through one woman's experience in / of slavery. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Jan 13, 2017 Jennifer rated it it was amazing

Shelves: tob2017longlist, tob2017, 100best21stcen

I didn't go into this expecting it to be a pleasant ride, but I still wasn't quite prepared for the casual cruelty of the real and imagined world it portrays. I think this will be a strong contender in the TOB. ...more

Like · see review