Eclipse (The Twilight Saga, #3) in Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge

Apr 15, 2009 Carla rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: not-own, 2009

This volume was a deception, after New Moon and the changes it might bring to this series. I was hoping for some confrontation, between werewolves and vampires, maybe even some fights and duels. In the beginning it really seems you might get that action, while Bella tries to remain neutral, though her task is somewhat difficult as her choice was already made. But what really disappointed me the most was the other two vertices of the love triangle. Unfortunately Edward tries to become the better This volume was a deception, after New Moon and the changes it might bring to this series. I was hoping for some confrontation, between werewolves and vampires, maybe even some fights and duels. In the beginning it really seems you might get that action, while Bella tries to remain neutral, though her task is somewhat difficult as her choice was already made. But what really disappointed me the most was the other two vertices of the love triangle. Unfortunately Edward tries to become the better person of the book, the one that will give up his loved one not to hurt her, as he did on the second book, and from jealous he turns into a very comprehensive boyfriend, trying not to get between Bella's and Jacob's relationship. Jacob, on the other hand, turns from comprehensive into jealous and manipulator.

The whole book revolves around these 3 characters relationship, which was a bit annoying and boring when I was really hoping that the Seattle's mystery and the whole situation with Victoria would have more prominence. However, just like it happened on the first volume, these elements of action are left to the last part of the book. In my opinion, the book would only gain to resume itself to this part and to the stories of Rosalie, Jasper and of the Quileutes. The story of the last ones was a bit disappointing too, as I thought werewolves were made to destroy vampires, so I was surprised to learn they had become enemies by chance, but it makes the union against Victoria more plausible and satisfactory.

I think this book, besides being very predictable, brought little to the story. It enlightens us when it comes to the author mythology but, as I said, it would be better if it had fewer pages and more action. It seems Meyer is afraid of working around mysteries and action sequences, preferring to evolve relationships that, in my opinion, don't have much more to evolve. Meyer's world and mythology, even though she sets away from the main canon, seems a lot more interesting than Bella's love life, as I don't even care that much about her character. It's a pity the author doesn't stay out of the romance more often; I think she would only gain to have more action on her books. ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Dec 14, 2008 Lianne rated it liked it

Shelves: urban-fantasy

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

Like · see review

Nov 21, 2008 Jennifer rated it it was ok

Shelves: kiddie, vampire

I don't like these books. They're silly. And yet... I simply cannot put them down. Book crack. Just give in- read the series. You'll hate me for it. But you won't really mind.

I thought this was much better than book 2, for the record. And it's killing me not to read the next one until I finish a book for book club. Evil crack books, I tell you. ...more

Like · see review