From the Bookshelf of r/FantasyRomance Goodreads Group

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

No group discussions for this book yet.

What Members Thought

Kristen
Great world building, unique magic system, cute romance. What more could you want?

I devoured this book in two days, reading nearly 300 pages in one sitting. This was one of those books I consumed for the vibes, and sits at 5 stars because I kept wanting to get back into this world.

While I am cranky about the second book and what it means for the romantic subplot, I'm still fascinated in where Gillig will take this fantasy in book 2.
...more
Ariel
Apr 04, 2024 rated it it was amazing
I loved the magic system of the cards and how using the cards can damage you, I have never read anything like that. I like that the magic and the plot was easy to follow, for someone like me who doesn’t do high fantasy this was very approachable without being dumbed down. I loved the nightmare and how he is protective of Elspeth, but also wants to take over her mind. Is he evil? Is he helping her? I still can’t tell. I liked that the romance between Eslpeth and Ravyn was very natural and they pr ...more
Vickie
Mar 11, 2024 rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
I heard so much hype for this book so my expectations were too high. I hate reading rhyming poetry but it was bearable in this book. The world and the card feels magical but I feel no actual connection to the characters. I didn't feel the chemistry between the FMC and MMC.

The only interesting character I would've like to know more about is the Nightmare, Elm, and Emory.
The Nightmare is an interesting character but I eventually got tired of reading all the rhymes and lore and eventually stopped
...more
Denise
Feb 06, 2024 rated it it was ok
The first half was very hard to get into, I liked the last half of the book.
Monic
Oct 12, 2024 rated it really liked it
love me a ragtag group of friends on a mission to save the world
OQ
May 20, 2024 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: physically-owned
Magnificent.

Absolutely incredible. I binge read this in one day. It was so beautifully done.

The world building is amazing, the characters had me sucked in instantly, the slow burn was beautiful, and the nightmare in her head was such an interesting dynamic.

Initially I started this book knowing NOTHING. I didn't even read the blurb. So there I was thinking the love interest would be the creature in her head lmao. Can't deny I felt a prick of disappointment when I realise he was NOT. Because come
...more
Therése
Feb 08, 2024 rated it it was amazing
4.5☆
Worth the hype. The book did get considerably better towards the second half. Beautifully flowing language, it reads like poetry. I love the Nightmare, really interesting banter between Elspeth and him.

Unique magic system, interesting characters, intriguing plot that is constantly moving forward.

(view spoiler)
...more
Ashley
Feb 07, 2025 rated it really liked it
Gothic romances are just chef's kiss!
Here, the magic system was novel, definitely refreshing and new. Providence Cards that anyone can wield, granting a form of power but when used too much also a poison.
Where this fell a bit flat for me was the romance. I was left wanting so much more from Ravyn and Elspeth.
...more
Kori
Dec 22, 2023 marked it as to-read
Abbey Morgan
Mar 01, 2024 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Kayla Conover
Dec 29, 2023 rated it it was amazing
Freya
Jan 01, 2024 marked it as to-read
Laura
Jan 07, 2024 rated it it was amazing
Ashley S.
Jan 28, 2024 rated it really liked it
Taylor
Jan 16, 2024 marked it as to-read
Kimber
Jan 25, 2024 rated it liked it
Beth Kelly
Feb 08, 2024 marked it as to-read
Caitlyn
Feb 15, 2024 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Kimberly
Mar 10, 2024 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Amethyst
Feb 27, 2024 marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
Orlaith
Mar 13, 2024 rated it really liked it
behappy
Apr 08, 2025 rated it really liked it
Claire
Jul 22, 2024 rated it really liked it
Ladyanarchy
Apr 21, 2024 rated it really liked it
Vavo ☆
Apr 28, 2024 rated it really liked it
Magnafeana
Apr 25, 2024 marked it as to-read
Cd
Jun 01, 2024 marked it as to-read
Ashley H
Jun 06, 2024 rated it it was amazing