If the Shoe Fits (Meant to Be, #1) in B.A.B.s

Sep 21, 2022 Tali rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: 2022, babs, 2024

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

Like · see review

Mar 19, 2024 Kristi Brokaw marked it as to-read

Like

Mar 19, 2024 Hilary added it

Like

May 31, 2024 Allyson rated it it was amazing

Shelves: 2024

Like

May 01, 2024 Adrienne Fike rated it really liked it

Like

May 29, 2024 Darcy rated it it was ok

Before we get to the review, I want to take a moment to feature a GoFundMe on distributing food and medicine to Palestinians in Gaza. Abedelsalam S Abu Halima is a 23-year-old Palestinian who was born and raised in Gaza. While he and his family are enduring the hardships of the Israeli occupation, they are working very hard to raise donations to help the rest of the innocent civilians. What is happening now in Gaza is beyond the capability of comprehension regarding the state of their mental hea Before we get to the review, I want to take a moment to feature a GoFundMe on distributing food and medicine to Palestinians in Gaza. Abedelsalam S Abu Halima is a 23-year-old Palestinian who was born and raised in Gaza. While he and his family are enduring the hardships of the Israeli occupation, they are working very hard to raise donations to help the rest of the innocent civilians. What is happening now in Gaza is beyond the capability of comprehension regarding the state of their mental health. They are now being starved to death, with 7 cases in the North have already died from hunger and malnutrition. Along with the lack of fruits and vegetables, anything they eat costs $100-$200. Gaza is in need for access to meals. Palestinians have been working non-stop to help others, with no pay whatsoever. With Abedelsalam and his family’s bravery, they are initiating a crucial mission to help feed Palestinians, Inshallah. They will help distribute meals for the people in the Gaza strip – starting in Deih-Al-Blah. With these donations, they can help prepare meals and decrease death rates from starvation. Please help donate whatever you can so we can help feed the children and families in Gaza. They need just under $7,000 to reach their goal ($30,000), so anything helps make a difference.

I really wanted to like this book. It was the book club pick for this month and many of them adored the novel. So I expected to have something really fun and enjoyable to read. That wasn’t what I experienced, sadly.

First off, the parts I did love. The modern-day twist was wonderful! I love the idea of Cinderella as a shoe designer and as a fat woman (or plus size as so many people are afraid of saying fat like it’s an insult). The stepmother and stepsisters were amazing! I actually liked them a bit more than Cindy’s story line. It was great to see that the stepmother and stepsisters were not “evil” and actually, truly cared about Cindy. Other than these few points, the rest was either boring or flat.

Speaking about the family, it annoyed me to high heaven when Cindy kept going on and on about how she doesn’t have a home or a family. I understand that she’s coming off a period of mourning for her dad, which she didn’t do when he initially died, but the amount of care and love that Erica, Drew, and Anna is totally antithetical to Cindy’s whining. If she felt more at home in New York than in L.A. that’s one thing, but it wasn’t written in a way to convey that. It was written where Cindy has this distant feeling from her step-family even though they all treat her like she’s their sister/daughter.

So, as a fat person myself I hate critiquing books that have fat representation because I want the representation to stay. With Cindy, her entire personality was about how she’s fat. It was brought up ALL THE DAMN TIME. Plus, she assumed or prescribed feelings or thoughts on to others when they didn’t have or say anything remotely horrible or derogatory.

Speaking of derogatory, let’s bring up our mean girl, Addison. If we can even call her a real character because she was just a prop, a stand in for a mean girl. There was absolutely no depth to her character, but we need the evil contestant on this Bachelor-esque type show. I definitely wanted to know what Addison said on her one-on-one date with Henry that he was ready to kick her off the show. It would’ve been a great chance to actually see Cindy be confident when we are told this OVER and OVER again that she is but never see it.

By the ending, I was ready to be done, especially after Cindy’s fight with Erica. Yes, it says in the epilogue that they had a conversation and everything was patched up. But that just didn’t satisfy me, especially considering everything Erica has done for Cindy, how much she loves and supports her, and all Cindy can do is throw it back in her face. I would’ve actually liked to have read the scene of Cindy apologizing to Erica and them talking things out then just told about it.

This is the main issue with the book. It had such great bones but needed more book to it and a bit more edits. There was so much telling and not enough showing, which is were it falls flat. Again, this was such a great concept and plot, it just needs a bit more work! ...more

Like · see review

From the Bookshelf of B.A.B.s…

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

What Members Thought

B.A.B.s