From the Bookshelf of The Reading Prismatic Arch…

The Golden Compass (His Dark Materials, #1)

Philip Pullman

Start date: February 1, 2014

Finish date: February 28, 2014

Discussion: The Golden Compass

Why we're reading this: This is our book for February, the winter-y themed The Golden Compass.
[close] This is our book for February, the winter-y themed The Golden Compass.

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 1 of 1 topics — 3 comments total

The Golden Compass

The religious controversy over The Golden Compass (probably has Spoilers)
By Cameron · 3 posts · 4 views

last updated Feb 23, 2014 03:32PM

showing 2 of 2 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Jun 08, 2011 Cameron rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: fantasy, young-adult

I would actually give this one 3.5 stars. So this is the first time I have read this book since I first read it, about 7 years ago. I was a little disappointed. I remember this book being fantastic, amazing, a literary masterpiece. Reading it again, after being introduced to great literature, I realized it wasn't as well written as I had once believed. Don't get me wrong, it was still very good. The problem is that I have been reading books that are amazing at showing me characters. To be clear, I would actually give this one 3.5 stars. So this is the first time I have read this book since I first read it, about 7 years ago. I was a little disappointed. I remember this book being fantastic, amazing, a literary masterpiece. Reading it again, after being introduced to great literature, I realized it wasn't as well written as I had once believed. Don't get me wrong, it was still very good. The problem is that I have been reading books that are amazing at showing me characters. To be clear, the authors showed that a character was brave, wild, loyal etc. by showing me their actions and their thoughts. Pullman, in The Golden Compass, does more telling. "Lyra was a fierce and wild child." I know it's a small thing but I feel that it was less enthralling a read. I actually had to kind of force my way through it at times because it wasn't as engaging.

On to the story. I still really like the world he built. The idea of daemons, people's conscience or soul, being a spirit animal always by their human's side was immensely intriguing. Pullman explored many aspects of the idea and did very well with it. I have read other reviews criticizing Lyra as being an overly passive protagonist. While I do agree that she is not as active as other heroes, she is still doing things and being proactive. I liked her, and the rest of the cast for that matter.

Now on to the other controversy of this book, the religious one. Now it is my opinion that the trilogy is very anti-christian. However, this book isn't. It does bash a parallel universe's version of the Catholic Church, and let's be honest, only some of those jabs are being made at the real Catholic church. Most of the ones that do apply, apply to some of the acts the Catholic church made in the dark ages, some of which were kind of horrendous. Modern day Catholicism is a very different thing than it was during that time and I've known some very devout Catholics that I believe are some of the best people I've known (Looking at you Elder family). Really, the thing that I feel he openly bashes is the idea of original sin. Now, as a mormon, I don't believe in the idea of original sin. I believe that man will be punished for his own sins and not for Adam's transgressions. As such, I didn't find this part to be very offensive, but I can see how for some it might be. All-in-all, it does feel as though Pullman might have had a bit of an agenda here. However, it doesn't detract from the story. And, as I am not Catholic, I didn't find it very offensive.

Overall I'd suggest this book. I liked it. The concept of daemons, or spirit animals or whatever, is really cool and I kind of wish it was one that another, more skilled author would look into it as well. ...more

Like · see review