The Fifth Season (The Broken Earth, #1) in /r/Fantasy Discussion Group

Nov 13, 2016 DeAnna Knippling rated it it was amazing

Shelves: authors-of-color

Amazing. Some issues in the opening that I can't talk about without being spoilerrific, so I won't, but. Complex and majestic, dark and tragic. That which endures. ...more

7 likes · Like · see review

Sep 21, 2016 Chelsea rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fantasy, suggested-series-firsts

Stunning novel. Bits reminded me of a compulsively readable Margaret Atwood.

It took me a bit to adjust to the POV and style, but once I did? WOW. Utterly engaging and the story unfolds in a clever and precise way.

HIGHLY recommended. My favorite read of the year so far.

5 likes · Like · see review

Aug 06, 2017 Chris Comerford rated it it was amazing

It's tricky to be objective and rational about a book which is just so demonstrably good. Employing a unique style and a gripping anachronic structure, The Fifth Season is one of the most ambitious books I've ever read. Fortunately, that ambition is more than met by the talents of author N.K. Jemisin.

The world's ending, and Essun has lost her family; her 2-year-old son has been murdered by her husband, and her daughter has gone missing. Leaving the safety of her village to find them, Essun cross It's tricky to be objective and rational about a book which is just so demonstrably good. Employing a unique style and a gripping anachronic structure, The Fifth Season is one of the most ambitious books I've ever read. Fortunately, that ambition is more than met by the talents of author N.K. Jemisin.

The world's ending, and Essun has lost her family; her 2-year-old son has been murdered by her husband, and her daughter has gone missing. Leaving the safety of her village to find them, Essun crosses paths with others who seek to weather the coming apocalypse. Concurrently, a girl named Damaya is forcibly inducted into an order of terrifying power, and a young woman named Syenite travels with her irascible companion to solve a far-off coastal town's shipping woes. All three stories might just be connected to each other.

The vague plot details above are thin frosting on a delicious mudcake of high concept ideas, plot turns and character beats, masterfully put together in a dizzyingly deep world by Jemisin. This is a well-paced story that plays out in an engrossing, richly-layered world which can stand with the best of Brandon Sanderson and J.K Rowling; a living, breathing narrative landscape with an immediate lived-in quality.

As good as it is, The Fifth Season's high quality is matched only by the degree to which one can't (or, perhaps, shouldn't) talk about it. Jemisin succeeds not just in executing the twists themselves, but in developing a method which makes even the more obvious turns much more gripping. I guessed one of the mid-book reveals quite a ways before it came to pass, but I wasn't prepared for how that reveal would be made, nor its ramifications. Veer away from spoilers on this one, folks.

The unique style also comes with a massive Your Mileage May Vary tag, with each plotline told in present tense with both second-person (Essun) and third-person (Damaya and Syenite) viewpoints. That style actually leads to one of the book's more significant plot twist, but it may not work for those who prefer a more straightforward narrative style. I personally loved it, absorbing the story more smoothly than I'd've expected for such an experimental way of telling it.

The Fifth Season is, unequivocally, a must-read. This is not always a happy book, detailing quite a bit of misery and hardship, featuring at least one scene that made my eyes misty. But there's still an innate hope at the centre of its gut-wrenching, apocalyptic narrative, all the better to enliven an enthralling cast of characters in a complex fantasy world. It's a book any self-respecting fantasy fan should read.

Also, it won the 2016 Hugo Award for Best Novel, marking the first time ever that an author of colour has walked away with that accolade. So, y'know, it's kind of a big deal. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 25, 2018 Pam rated it it was amazing

Shelves: fantasy, lgbtq-characters

I started this book with really high expectations. After all, N.K. Jemisin garnered resounding praises from the scifi/fantasy community and won awards to equal those praises, not just for this one novel but also for her other works. Besides that "The Broken Earth" has been likened to "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" writ large; I've read "Omelas" recently and that claim is quite the burden/favor to put on someone's work.

I finished this book in a little over a day -- sleeping and having to go ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Oct 04, 2017 C.M. rated it really liked it

Shelves: science-fiction, fantasy

In the beginning I had a tough time with the multiple POVs, especially with the one in second person. And it was slow. But then mid-book the tension cranked up and I was totally into it. Even for a series I felt the ending was quite abrupt though. Will I read the next book? Maybe not but I am glad I read this one, my main motivation being because it was a Hugo winner.

Like · see review