ClaireB’s Comments (group member since Jul 06, 2014)

ClaireB’s comments from the Nothing But Reading Challenges group.

Judith wrote: "I think 97% will be out anyway.

The web serial rules from FAQ may also be helpful.

And Claire no worries about your ‘quota’ we are over are min and will be under our max. That’s all that really m..."

They might as well just ban all fanfictions... I suggest mods make it a rule for the next challenge. At least that will be clear, and there will be no dispute anymore... On that subject at least. I've participated in group challenges where fanfics are not allowed. It's no problem. Dura lex sed lex. Like Steven I'm a stong believer in following rules. Just tell me clearly before the game starts. What I don't like about this whole thing is that it feels like the rules are changing mid-game. Me no likey.

Okay, now that's the last thing I'm going to say about fanfiction-gate. Let's put it behind us and concentrate on reading big books. We'll make them regret crossing us. (I'm a scorpio, we are extremely vindictive and they've made me angry!!!!!)

Steven wrote: "Honestly, I think in future tower teams, the spreadsheets need to be viewable only be team members and mods. This whole “I’m gonna spend my time looking through everyone else’s spreadsheets and fin..."

Amen to that !

oh so, all fanfictions are not out!
what are the requirements?

what about The Art of self-fashioning by lomonaaeren? (Sorry I can't link it. I'm on my phone). it's on goodreads. that's the one I'm currently reading.

Nooooooooo!!!!!!
this makes me sad :( all these points gone! and now I'm one book short of my 5 book goal too... And I was half-way through another amazing long fanfic, too. boohoo !

@Sammy, I need reading inspiration to feel better. Do you think you can make it Tom Ellis from Lucifer? Ive started the series last week on Netflix and that guy ! ;)

@Sonia, I hope your headache will get better soon. And I'm sorry if the drama here only added to it. *hugs*

Jenny wrote: "Here are the stories that have been worked out. I will tweak them as needed if books aren't finished or if we can't use one.

Please suggest or edit if you have a better idea!!!!

Story 1

The AMER..."

Awesome! The first one was particularly funny :)

I see you've used my fanfiction there. Does that mean it was approved in the end? Or is that just hopeful thinking? *fingers crossed*

Thanks to me apparently becoming an insomniac, I managed to read a good chunk of American Gods this morning, before going to work. And I still have some time to read on the bus. If I'm lucky I'll be able to finish it during my lunchbreak.
Also I'm not liking it much. I'm giving up on Neil Gaiman. I've only had disappointments with his books.

Amy "the book-bat" wrote: "OMG... slogging through Bridget Jones's Diary
Bridget is such a whiny twat! I'm going to need a way to unread this drivel."

I hated that book! It's another one of those rare books where the movie is better.

Steven wrote: "Clones for everyone!

Did a mod challenge it? Or was it someone lurking and spending time going through people’s spreadsheets instead of reading for their own damn team? Who has time for that? Seri..."

Thanks Steven. This is exactly why I'm mad about the whole thing.

Jenny wrote: "In order to finalize the stories, can you guys confirm that these books will be done by the deadline please?
Claire- American Gods"

I confirm ! I should be done by the end of the countdown.

Lol, it's like a little puzzle

Jenny wrote: "Fine. You can have him. I am a nice person. Just ask my cats."

That's very kind of you ;) And cats a really good judges of character. If they say you're okay, I believe them



lol I keep answering a tiny second too late.

Jenny wrote: "Naked Jamie!!!!!!
Steven, get out your cloning machine because I am about to call DIBS!!!!!"

No Jenny !!! How dare you steal him from me ?!

Sammy wrote: "Because I will probably say something regrettable on the topic of this challenge, you will all have to forgive me if I don't say anything at all, and instead go on to the more fun topic of some rea..."

I call dibs !!!! Jamie is mine !!! My name is Claire, you can't dispute my claim ;)

Jenny wrote: "I just want you to get the points since you read it. But, we will live with whatever ruling there is."

*sigh* same. Even though I read it for pleasure, me participating in this challenge influenced my decision to read it then. It had the adjectives for description I was looking for for the stories, and it had a big page count that would give us points. And it took me hours to read, so I'd really like it to count for someting. Had I known they would dispute it I would have read something else and not wasted time on it.

Jenny wrote: "Honestly though, once you gave it 5 stars, I looked at the description, and it looks fun. I am a huge potter fan, so, is it worth reading? (after this challenge)?"


Yes I really liked it. It reminded me of the fanfictions I used to read as a teenager. But a good one, haha. So nostalgia might have played in my star rating. But I thought it was well written. I liked the story, and the dynamic between the main characters. It was angsty, but fun. :) Just what I needed

What really gets me mad though is that they go to such length to try and dispute something that doesn't really challenge any of the rules. I didn't read this fanfiction to try and cheat. I would have read it regardless of the challenge. Anyway this challenge was set up for us all to have fun, and to encourage us to read. That we win or lose is not what matters to me. (but of course if we win I would not be mad about it, obviously)

Judith wrote: "I’m sorry, that should of been isn’t just that it’s fan fiction. But they are saying it should be treated like a web serial, which mods ruled on earlier.

But doing that pretty much eliminates all ..."

tbf, I don't really get why their web serial can't be used.... as long as it's a complete one.

Judith wrote: "The issue is directly because it’s fan fiction. Partly because it’s been taken down from the original site and therefore doesn’t exist in ebook form. Therefore it’s a serial and not allowed due to ..."

I just want to point out that it's a bit unfair to discount it for the reason that it's a fanfiction, because then what about Fifty Shades of Mr Darcy: A Parody? I know it hasn't been published using the same sort of platform but still. Ultimately it is a fanfiction. They just use the word parody to describe it.

Also it's still possible to find online. How would I have been able to read it otherwise? I found it via a link on the goodreads page, in the question section. here is the link: http://dhr.avada-kedavra.net How would using that link be any different than reading a book I found in second hand, that is out of print??? Or reading an ebook you bought a long time ago that's not available for purchase anymore? It's still on goodreads.

Sorry, but I'm a bit mad they would dispute it. Especially seeing that I asked if reading fanfiction was allowed before reading it. And also, I've read fanfiction for gorup challenges, here on NBRC, before and it's never been a problem.

edit: I'm not saying anything about the page count, because honestly I don't know how to calculate the page number from the word count. To me it varies from one book to the next anyway.

rant over.... for now.

Judith wrote: "Hello Lovely Lusties,

Just wanted to let you know a few things.

Mainly, the captains did some hard looking at the bingo card and moved the 4 squares we are shooting to leave blank.

Also the use..."

Oh really? Why has it been challenged? I thought fanfictions were okay???
If there's a problem about it you have to tell me now because I was planning to read 2 other for next week.

It feel so good to hear other people say they don't like Neil Gaiman. That author is so hyped. I actually felled depressed last time, when I tried reading Neverwhere, and didn't like it. I just was so disappointed by that author that everyone praises so much. But now I accept it. There's nothing I can do. He's not for me, so? That happens. I just won't force myself to read his stuff anymore.