Gina’s Comments (group member since Jul 02, 2009)

Gina’s comments from the Team Jacob group.

I want to hear more of Alice's story personally. I want to know more about her human life because she doesn't remember it

I read Midnight Sun and I actually liked Edward a little more than before. He is still creepy tho...like the whole oiling the window so watch Bella sleep. I thought it was so funny the whole time (in Midnight Sun) he wanted to read Bella's mind. In my head I was like 'Don't worry Edward all she is thinking about is how good looking you are.'

It's funny I loved the Twilight books but hated Bella. Jacob made me love the books. I especially loved Breaking Dawn where you got to read from his prospective.

girl

I agree with what everyone posted !

omg it has happened to me too...and even if he did force Bella to kiss him she was toying with him the whole time...she made me so mad! Jacob is a million times better than Edward. Bella seems almost scared of Edward. Like when she secretly left to got to La Push to see Jacob she is worried about how much 'trouble' she is going to be in with Edward. That part really pissed me off he is way to controling of her.


UH! don't get me started. I just don't get why so many girls are in love with Edward. They look at me like I have 5 heads when I tell them I am a Jacob girl.

I love Jacob for all the reasons mentioned above. Edward is creepy, over protective, and just plain annoying. I feel Bella had a much healthier relationship with Jake than with Edward she was obsessed, her whole happiness depended on him. To me that just seemed crazy. Maybe because the book is geared to a YA audience and I am in my 20’s but the type of relationship Bella had with Jacob seemed all together better. They were friends she was happy with who she was with him. She never longed to be anything better. When ever she was with Edward I always felt it was a very vain attraction she had towards him (Edward) because all she ever thought about was how handsome he was (Ha! Give me tall, dark and handsome any day). She never felt good enough for Edward. She always felt like Edward was some how better than she was.

Maybe it is just my silly imagination but in New Moon Jacob really reminded me of my boyfriend. His height and the sarcastic things he would say. I am reading Eclipse right now and I guess I have to wait till I finish Breaking Dawn to really judge the characters…but as of this moment I am a total werewolf girl!