Autumn’s Comments (group member since Mar 14, 2009)

Autumn’s comments from the Twifanatics group.

Clara wrote: "Not when every conversation is awkward. In the book they actually talk back and forth, forth and back. You can believe their falling in love because they actually know things about the other person..."

I know, it's just funny sometimes. I do wish they had real conversations. Maybe in New Moon. Oh, what did you think of Jacob? I don't think he's hot or anything, but he does do a good job.

You mean like the only light coversation they have is when Edward says, "He's not looking. Oh, wait. He just looked." But the awkward moments are funny.

Clara wrote: "Yeah, there should have been more about the other Cullens. I loved Carlisle - my goodness, I almost fainted when I saw him. The sparkling was seriously lame. And they ruined one of my favorite scen..."

Except for Alice, I thought she was pretty darn good. And Rosalie was awesome. Not that I like her, but she was portrayed really well. Yeah, the forest schene was almost laughable. I really missed the meadow schene. That is one of my favorites! And then afterwards when Bella finds out he watches her sleep. "You did say my name." "How often?" "How much is often?" "Oh, no!" I love that part and was mad they didn't have it.

They didn't really show any of the other Cullens' personalities. I wish they had shown Emmett's comical side. Actually I don't even remember him truly speaking.

Lara wrote: "Here's what I thought was wrong with the movie

1. It seemed to angsty and forced.... in the book everything was more fluid
2. The sparkling was seriously disappointing
3. The way the truth came o..."

Yeah, I didn't like Jasper. Not the way I imagined him. Edward would never reference Google or spider monkeys so that didn't make sense. I didn't get why they couldn't have had Bella tell Edward what she knew in the car. What did you think of Carlisle? I thought he was even better than my imagination.

I thought the movie was pretty good. They followed the story line better than I thought they would. But pbviously they couldn't do everything right. Here's what I think was wrong:

1. They didn't talk about the other characters. I wish they had talked about the other Cullens more. You couldn't get a sense of their personalities.
2. Eric. Tyler. I don't think the actors chosen for them really worked. And Eric was supposed to be chess club nerd, not whatever he was in the movie.
3. Edward in the sun. I really didn't see anything different when he was in the sun. Of course I probably will now that I've had my eye surgery. But still, it wasn't dramatic.

Why do you want her to wait???????? That's crazy!!!!! Read it now! Or I'll print it and give to you, strap you to a chair, and force you!

I'm with you there, girl. He sure can rock someone's box of socks. He He He.

I must say that I have read the partial rough draft and I loved it. I hope that Stephenie Meyer will finish this book sometime soon. What I've gathered from reading it, I can see Edward's character a lot better. She really needs to continue despite this "complication."

Yes, major downs. At least with vampire relationships you can live forever and work things out.

Yes let's all make Edward hurt in our demented thoughts. No I could not stand him in pain. I would just want to...well kiss him and make him better. Actually, I'm pretty weak so Renesmee probably wouldn't be around if I were Bella. You would think Carlisle would think of blood on his own.

I think it was right for Bella to keep Renesmee. But I wish Edward hadn't been hurting so much. I don't like him being the burning man.

That is the depressing part. All relationships have ups and downs. This was the major down for both of them.

It doesn't even matter that he's part myth. Nothing beats Edward and his awesomeness.

So let's say Edward never left. Let's say he didn't leave because he wanted to protect Bella from what Jasper might have done. What would have happened? I think Bella wouldn't have found out about Jacob the wolf. It's sad to think they might not have been friends. But I wish he hadn't left. She got so depressed. No shrinks please.

Duh Edward's better. Jacob has friend qualities, only. And, honestly, what's so exciting about Bella being the wife of a werewolf? I mean, come on. Hello! Vampire. Awesome!