Anya’s answer to “When Autumn confronted Marnie, Marnie told her that she had spoken to her brother. If this was tru…” > Likes and Comments
3 likes · Like
Maybe but kind of weak if that’s true But I appreciate your answer and you may be right
Okay, what perplexed me was Autumn (Darah) even KNOWING and REMEMBERING she had a brother to begin with! I mean, wasn’t she technically “Autumn” and had zero memories of being Sarah?? As for Marnie talking to her brother, I figure Marnie deep dived into Autumn’s history and maybe did a picture search on Google where she found Sarah and from there contacted the brother and got the story from him. I’m totally stretching here and I shouldn’t have to! Plus I highly highly doubt Sarah would keep that information from Ben and her parents. Marnie would have blabbed about it around town, it was her character.
I love Minka but this novel just had so many problems. From the awful ending with the crime author to major continuation issues like Daphne pours one more drink and goes upstairs to draw a bath. Then, after some exposition, Daphne pours one more drink and she still downstairs, all in the present! Also red to blonde to red hair for Daphne and the flowers changed.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Michelle
(new)
Mar 19, 2018 01:58PM
Maybe but kind of weak if that’s true But I appreciate your answer and you may be right
reply
|
flag
Okay, what perplexed me was Autumn (Darah) even KNOWING and REMEMBERING she had a brother to begin with! I mean, wasn’t she technically “Autumn” and had zero memories of being Sarah?? As for Marnie talking to her brother, I figure Marnie deep dived into Autumn’s history and maybe did a picture search on Google where she found Sarah and from there contacted the brother and got the story from him. I’m totally stretching here and I shouldn’t have to! Plus I highly highly doubt Sarah would keep that information from Ben and her parents. Marnie would have blabbed about it around town, it was her character. I love Minka but this novel just had so many problems. From the awful ending with the crime author to major continuation issues like Daphne pours one more drink and goes upstairs to draw a bath. Then, after some exposition, Daphne pours one more drink and she still downstairs, all in the present! Also red to blonde to red hair for Daphne and the flowers changed.
