Sarah Page’s answer to “Is The Secret Place on par with Faithful Place? I didn't care for Broken Harbor. Thanks.” > Likes and Comments
2 likes · Like
In the Woods will always own my heart. Close second, The Likeness. Then Faithful Place, Broken Harbor. I haven’t finished The Secret Place yet, though I am close, but it might be between Faithful and Broken. Let’s see. But I agree with you, all of them are great and I love how they are different from each other.
My ranking is extremely similar, I would just swap Faithful Place with In the Woods. I didn't really like Faithful Place because I felt it too slow and Mackey has never been that likable or interesting to me.
The Likenes is definitely at the bottom of my list. Worst premise by far.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Cosette
(new)
Sep 06, 2014 05:47AM
In the Woods will always own my heart. Close second, The Likeness. Then Faithful Place, Broken Harbor. I haven’t finished The Secret Place yet, though I am close, but it might be between Faithful and Broken. Let’s see. But I agree with you, all of them are great and I love how they are different from each other.
reply
|
flag
My ranking is extremely similar, I would just swap Faithful Place with In the Woods. I didn't really like Faithful Place because I felt it too slow and Mackey has never been that likable or interesting to me.
The Likenes is definitely at the bottom of my list. Worst premise by far.
My least favorite was Faithful Place; predictable.
