Aksnowgirlknitter’s answer to “What was going on with the increasingly bad smell in Erin's room? I know she didn't want to see he…” > Likes and Comments

26 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Felicia Bessen I caught that too


message 2: by judith (new)

judith Those big plans sounded totally fake to me...Erin could move out any time she wanted, she already had money so it isn't dependent on any convention some vague time "in the summer ." That's just not ever gonna happen!


message 3: by Anna (new)

Anna Riley I don’t catch that about the smell. Interesting! I thought initially it was that she never left her room and that it was defecation.


message 4: by judith (new)

judith If there even is a real smell, it could be Erin's hygiene, but if so that doesn't stop Walter from going in there. Josie could be imagining it because she believes Walter is abusing Erin in her room every night.


message 5: by Alison (new)

Alison Frontier I like this idea- But at one point Josie and Walter have a conversation and Walter says something like it’s not that bad yet?


message 6: by judith (new)

judith Been awhile, I don't remember Walt saying that, but I never trusted him or Erin! When she alludes to moving out & says Josie "could smell it" it sounded like a cover-up.


message 7: by John (new)

John Leonard Entirely convincing. Thank you.


back to top