Castles’s review of Voices from Chernobyl: The Oral History of a Nuclear Disaster > Likes and Comments

11 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique Hi Castles!
You actually grew up around Chernobyl? Or around people who left Chernobyl? In the Soviet Union?, or later in Israel?
Thank you for your review.


message 2: by Castles (new)

Castles Hi Epoque! no I'm not russian nor Belarusian at all, I was talking about the people from the soviet block who came to Israel (Aliya). many of my friends from there, including the city I grew up in who took in a large part of them. it's not rare to hear here about health issue up until today with people who grew up around Chernobyl.


message 3: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique I see! Really interesting. I guess you've been discussing the book with them...?
I too -quite often actually- watch videos about Pripyat, to see the growth of the trees that have taken over the town.


message 4: by Castles (new)

Castles not yet, just picked this book randomly actually because of your recommendation on zinky boys, after it was on my radar for a few years, and decided to continue with her books.

I also find myself fascinated with clips from there. I don't know if you happened to stumble upon this vlogger named "bald and bankrupt" who once randomly visited an old man there in some abandoned village, and later came back to him a few times. it's fascinating. I'm not sure I still understand what's actually dangerous and not in "the zone" and just how far is it unsafe to live there.


message 5: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique From what I understand about those videos of the people who have remained there, it is not that dangerous anymore, and quite a few inhabitants who had refused to leave on the mass bus exodus have actually survived.
Animals don't seem to have minded the radiations and have reproduced practically normally (with some genetic bizarreries). Trees didn't mind at all.
The area is still fenced off, but you know the Russians... Afraid of not much.


message 6: by Castles (last edited Nov 20, 2026 11:20AM) (new)

Castles if you happen to see that vlog I talked about, sure some people stayed, but those were so much ww2 people, they couldn't bare facing any other world than their own back yard (understandable). some of them live in abandoned villages almost by themselves, no electricity. it's wild.

as for animals, I did understand that frog there are now black instead of green because of melanin, and that dogs there are genetically different from their fellow dogs just a few kilometers away. surely I'm not jealous!

let's not forget that last year russia punctuated that massive led cover of Chernobyl with a drone in the current war... also wild


message 7: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique Another of the Alexievitch books I read is the one about women in WWII. Very good. Impressive women.
Her style I now find a bit tiring; as you say there is little that she actually writes. She lets the people write her stories. After a while, her books end up being factual compilations.


message 8: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique "War's Unwomanly Face".


message 9: by Castles (new)

Castles epoqueepique wrote: ""War's Unwomanly Face"."

yup, as I wrote here I got her thing and it's only the second book I've read of hers, I also have what you mention waiting for me. I mean, I know Russians, I know how poetic and smart they can get, but it gets really suspicious that every second testimony in her books is a modern Dostoyevsky talking. totally get your point


message 10: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique She was very much criticized for constructing literary works out of oral testimonies, reworking the interviews, dramatizing them, even playing with history (depending on the political position of the critique), while showing little literary talent of her own.
She called it "documentary literature" where her critics wanted investigative journalism. (Not dissimilar to Kapuschinki actually!)
Did her "interpretations" stem from ideological purposes? I think the question is still open.
There is little of all that in "War's Unwomanly Face". No political agenda.
Anyway, the human testimony is what we remember from her writings, and it is vast and scary.


message 11: by Castles (last edited Nov 20, 2026 11:51AM) (new)

Castles epoqueepique wrote: "She was very much criticized for constructing literary works out of oral testimonies, reworking the interviews, dramatizing them, even playing with history (depending on the political position of t..."

yes when I researched a little before writing this review I took a hint about her critics claims, and let's be real - there's statistically zero chances that all the people she meets are so highly articulated and hold a literary talent this sophisticated.

actually, there's a passage I deleted from the review because I felt it was too out there when it comes to Chernobyl. I wanted to write it all felt a little to "easy", you know? isn't it the easiest thing to focus your camera on the victim and ignore what, the rest of the whole geopolitical situation. you'll always find sense in the tragic, in this way. war is bad, believe it or not! and I mean the zinky boys. what do I know if that war was right or not? maybe I'm not to judge what the soviets did while america was arming Afghanistan to the neck? who know, surely not me. it all brings me back to October 7, that is - have someone with zero understanding or care judge everything because he once read a book somewhere, or saw it on tv...


message 12: by epoqueepique (last edited Nov 20, 2026 12:12PM) (new)

epoqueepique Maybe it was her way of avoiding the Lubyianka dungeons... Let the people speak and don't comment on what they say. An easy way out of danger maybe.
As for October 7th's idiotic pundits and all the others, it is pure ignorance. So much hate stemming from unforgivable ignorance I have never witnessed before.


message 13: by Castles (new)

Castles epoqueepique wrote: "Maybe it was her way of avoiding the Lubyianka dungeons... Let the people speak and don't comment on what they say. An easy way out of danger maybe.
For October 7th's campus idiotic pundits, it is ..."


indeed, and ever since October I'm way more careful to pass judge on other historical events, especially when they come in a package of a debate that turns to your emotions and try to stir rage over tragedy...


message 14: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique I agree, and that is why I read books and you too.
To fly, and get the birds eye view.
Cheers Castles!


message 15: by Castles (new)

Castles cheers my friend, indeed well put!


message 16: by epoqueepique (new)

epoqueepique Castles wrote: "if you happen to see that vlog I talked about, sure some people stayed, but those were so much ww2 people, they couldn't bare facing any other world than their own back yard (understandable). some ..."

Huh, I hadn't seen that post.
Yes, I guess some of the videos I saw were that guy's. An obstinate refusal to submit to yet other untrustworthy orders...
I didn't know about the frogs!


message 17: by Castles (new)

Castles epoqueepique wrote: "Castles wrote: "if you happen to see that vlog I talked about, sure some people stayed, but those were so much ww2 people, they couldn't bare facing any other world than their own back yard (unders..."

yup, cheers to our commerce Kolya! he's a king


message 18: by Matty (new)

Matty Excellent review!


message 19: by Castles (new)

Castles Matty wrote: "Excellent review!"

thank you dear Matty. I was wondering if you ever got to this book


message 20: by Matty (new)

Matty Castles wrote: "Matty wrote: "Excellent review!"

thank you dear Matty. I was wondering if you ever got to this book"


Dear Castles, I've read a few books and plenty of articles about Chernobyl, since I was working on a project related to the disaster at one point. Right now, I'm not sure I'm ready for this one. Still, it seems like a great read, so I'll have to give it a try someday.


message 21: by Castles (new)

Castles oh yes, emotionally speaking, especially for people familiar or involved, this is a very triggering read... warning should be advised.


back to top