Julie’s review of The Great Gatsby > Likes and Comments
72 likes · Like
Julie wrote: "I've been wanting to reread this for a while now. It's been so long since I've read it, my strongest memory of the story is the eyes on that billboard that seem to bear witness to everyone's bad be..."
Oh, definitely a reread AJ. I've probably read it three times over the years, and it never loses its hold on me. In fact, the older I get, the more I understand it. For me, it's the extraordinary sense of longing that runs through the whole book — the yearning, the desire, the almost unbearable ache of wanting something just beyond one's reach. Fitzgerald captures something so deeply human in that impossible reaching for a dream, even when we know it can never quite be recaptured. I suppose if one doesn't have that particular spiritual makeup, that capacity to feel the pull of longing and desire, the book might well fall flat. But that's the beauty of literature: we each bring our own sensibilities to what we read. I can only speak for myself — and Fitzgerald has always known how to reach me.
I figured it was a reread for you. I more recently read TENDER IS THE NIGHT for my 30s project, and I really couldn't stand it. It made me wonder how a GATSBY reread will go for me. I loved it the first time around, but I was always a much bigger fan of his short work. "Berniece Bobs Her Hair," for one, has stayed in my mind for many decades. I think that's a tremendous achievement, to write something so short and meaningful and doesn't leave a reader's mind.
Julie wrote: "I figured it was a reread for you. I more recently read TENDER IS THE NIGHT for my 30s project, and I really couldn't stand it. It made me wonder how a GATSBY reread will go for me. I loved it the ..."
I really can't choose between Fitzgerald's novels and his short stories. I love both, and think he's every bit as accomplished in one form as the other. His novels have that wonderful richness and depth, but his short stories can pack a really good punch. Bernice Bobs Her Hair is a great example. I actually find it rather sad and cruel beneath all the wit. In my younger days, I might have thought Marjorie got her just desserts, but I find myself looking at it rather differently now. Bernice's eagerness to belong is painful enough to watch, but the spitefulness of her revenge leaves me uncomfortable too. I wonder if that wasn't rather Fitzgerald's point. He sees straight through the social games, the vanity and the little cruelties, and gets right to the heart of human nature.
Great exposition of the themes in this novel, Julie. You're making me want to go back to re-read this one.
I particularly liked this point:
"he cannot entirely escape the past, nor does he really want to. He creates a new identity, but his imagination remains tethered to an earlier version of himself and to the life he believes should have been his."
Your review really got into Gatsby's psychology and it seems like you are pulling out something about the era via Gatsby.
I recently attended a great lecture about Fitzgerald's short stories and learned that (comparing only circulation) Fitzgerald's greatest exposure to a reading public was through his short stories that were published in Vanity Fair, Saturday Evening Post, Colliers, McCalls, etc. And that exposure gave him a bit of celebrity status, which is its own alternate, constructed, ersatz reality. The division between the world we live in and the world we construct for ourselves makes it possible to have two different versions of ourselves.
path wrote: "Great exposition of the themes in this novel, Julie. You're making me want to go back to re-read this one.
I particularly liked this point:
"he cannot entirely escape the past, nor does he reall..."
Thank you for this, path. I've long felt that Fitzgerald understood Gatsby's capacity for self-invention from a very personal perspective. There is a fascinating convergence between the two: Fitzgerald, the young writer who became a celebrity in the very magazines that helped shape popular fantasies of wealth, glamour and success, and Gatsby, who constructs an entirely new identity in pursuit of the life he imagines for himself. Both, in different ways, inhabit a world where the carefully fashioned public image can become almost as important as the person behind it. The lecturer's connection between Fitzgerald's literary success and his own constructed public persona is a particularly perceptive way of illuminating that parallel.
PS I hope you do reread it, as I'd be very interested to read how you feel about it now.
I love this book and have reread a few times. Thank you for the trip down reading lane. Maybe I’m due for another.
The wrote: "I love this book and have reread a few times. Thank you for the trip down reading lane. Maybe I’m due for another."
Maybe! Glad to hear we share the sentiment.
This is a remarkable review of a very good book Julie! "....longing, illusion and the human condition."......that's life really right?
The themes here also are similar to those of Middlemarch, my current read. Re-imagined past's and future's - often leading to disillusionment and trouble. The movie with Leo was great too. Thanks for reminding me of this one Julie 🤓🤗🦘
Gorgeous write-up, Julie - I savoured every word of it, reading it again as soon as I reached your last line - what a sublime piece of writing you dedicated to this novel. After reading 'Tender is the night', which fell entirely flat on me, this novel was such a surprise : the depth, the questions on identity, on what makes one human, the writing, all I am looking for when reading fiction, it was all there. The yearning, the impossible struggle for a place in the sun, you are so right this novel transcends time and place.
Superb review, Julie!
Same as Ilse, I cherished every word of it and I'm grateful to you for summarizing, and at the same time wonderfully elaborating on, why this book deeply spoke to me and readers of so many generations as the decades unfold.
The endless allure of dreaming of a better life, of belonging to a better life full of beauty and hope, however deceitful both are, is what makes us go on, forever trapped between our deliberate illusions and lesser reality.
Wonderful review, Julie! I also adore this book. I love how the phrase 'careless people' has now entered everyday language (such as the title of Sarah Wynn-Williams' book) and we all understand exactly what is meant by it as a result of this novel.
Mark wrote: "This is a remarkable review of a very good book Julie! "....longing, illusion and the human condition."......that's life really right?
The themes here also are similar to those of Middlemarch, my..."
Oh, I love that connection to *Middlemarch*, Mark! Eliot and Fitzgerald both understood the human capacity for reinventing the past and imagining futures that reality has absolutely no intention of accommodating. Disillusionment, of course, is often waiting in the wings.
As for the film, I do like Leo, but I'm afraid he'll have to take a number. Robert Redford IS Gatsby as far as I'm concerned. And what a cast that 1974 version had: Mia Farrow, Sam Waterston and Bruce Dern! Redford had just the right combination of charm, melancholy and that elusive quality that makes Gatsby so compelling. Leo is lovely, but he can't have everything. 😂 😍💔
Ilse wrote: "Gorgeous write-up, Julie - I savoured every word of it, reading it again as soon as I reached your last line - what a sublime piece of writing you dedicated to this novel. After reading 'Tender is ..."
Oh, Ilse, what a lovely thing to say. Thank you. And I love the way you've described what you found in this novel: the questions of identity, of what makes us human, the yearning, the impossible struggle to find our place in the sun. Yes, all of it. I think that's what makes Gatsby so much more than a story of a particular time and place. Fitzgerald gets at something deeply human in our need to invent ourselves, to believe in possibility, to reach for something just beyond our grasp. And that yearning, however misguided or doomed, is both heartbreaking and utterly recognizable. I'm particularly glad you found such a different experience in Gatsby after Tender Is the Night. Perhaps Fitzgerald didn't always strike the same chord, but here, for me, he achieved something close to perfection. And thank you for reading my review not once, but twice. That means a great deal. ❤️
Violeta wrote: "Superb review, Julie!
Same as Ilse, I cherished every word of it and I'm grateful to you for summarizing, and at the same time wonderfully elaborating on, why this book deeply spoke to me and read..."
Violeta, thank you! What a beautiful way of putting it — particularly that tension between our deliberate illusions and the lesser reality we inhabit. I think you've captured something essential about Gatsby, and perhaps about the human condition itself. I've often thought that this longing has been in the human heart ever since our earliest ancestors first looked up at the stars and watched them blinking in the darkness, wondering what lay beyond their reach. And to me, that little green light across the water is such a perfect embodiment of that ancient longing: always visible, always beckoning, always just beyond our grasp. We seem to need our dreams, even when some part of us knows they may be leading us astray. There's something both heartbreaking and strangely magnificent about that refusal to relinquish the possibility of a better life. Perhaps that's why Gatsby continues to speak to us, generation after generation: we recognize that longing, because it has always been ours. I'm so glad the novel spoke to you as deeply as it did to me, and touched that my review resonated with you.
Di wrote: "Wonderful review, Julie! I also adore this book. I love how the phrase 'careless people' has now entered everyday language (such as the title of Sarah Wynn-Williams' book) and we all understand exa..."
Thank you, Di! And what a great insight to pull out that particular phrase. I find it fascinating that Fitzgerald's language has become so woven into our cultural vocabulary. "Careless people" is such a perfect example. What's particularly striking to me is how much more relevant those two words seem to have become as the years pass. If anything, the distance between the novel and our own time has sharpened their meaning. The carelessness Fitzgerald exposed wasn't simply a matter of individual character; it was about privilege, entitlement, and the extraordinary ease with which some people insulate themselves from the consequences of their actions, leaving others to pick up the pieces. Sadly, that feels less like a relic of the Jazz Age and more like an observation about the world we inhabit now. Fitzgerald's vision has aged remarkably well — perhaps rather too well.
I read this enduring (surprisingly short) novel several decades ago, Julie, and you've brought it back to me in glorious Technicolor.
A superb review, my eloquent friend. You've really captured the broader lessons that can be learnt from this modernistic parable.
Kevin wrote: "I read this enduring (surprisingly short) novel several decades ago, Julie, and you've brought it back to me in glorious Technicolor.
A superb review, my eloquent friend. You've really captured th..."
Thanks, Kevin. It really is remarkable how much Fitzgerald managed to pack into such a compact novel. There's something quite extraordinary about his ability to make a story feel so intimate and yet so expansive into so few pages. I'm delighted the review brought it all back to you!
And it's nice to see you here! 😊 Have you been hiding/working hard on your next novel?
Georgia wrote: "Perceptive. Eloquent. Touching. What a review, Julie."
Georgia, you embarrass me — and honour me, in equal measure. What a lovely thing to say. Thank you.
Hmn. Another one of those forced high school English marches (like Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice) that I read and never returned to. But I should, for no other reason than this: 16-year-old me might as well be a stranger to present-day me. No doubt we have vastly different tastes.
Ken wrote: "Hmn. Another one of those forced high school English marches (like Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice) that I read and never returned to. But I should, for no other reason than this: 16-year-old me mi..."
Ha! Sixteen-year-old us really shouldn't be allowed to have the final word on anything, particularly literature. (I wouldn't mind a chance to redo quite a few things about my own 16-year-old self, actually.) It's quite possible you'll wonder what on earth you were objecting to. Or not ...
But I rather like the idea of giving a book a second chance when we're no longer the person who first slammed it shut, and have put a few miles between us and that closed door.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
Julie wrote: "I've been wanting to reread this for a while now. It's been so long since I've read it, my strongest memory of the story is the eyes on that billboard that seem to bear witness to everyone's bad be..."Oh, definitely a reread AJ. I've probably read it three times over the years, and it never loses its hold on me. In fact, the older I get, the more I understand it. For me, it's the extraordinary sense of longing that runs through the whole book — the yearning, the desire, the almost unbearable ache of wanting something just beyond one's reach. Fitzgerald captures something so deeply human in that impossible reaching for a dream, even when we know it can never quite be recaptured. I suppose if one doesn't have that particular spiritual makeup, that capacity to feel the pull of longing and desire, the book might well fall flat. But that's the beauty of literature: we each bring our own sensibilities to what we read. I can only speak for myself — and Fitzgerald has always known how to reach me.
I figured it was a reread for you. I more recently read TENDER IS THE NIGHT for my 30s project, and I really couldn't stand it. It made me wonder how a GATSBY reread will go for me. I loved it the first time around, but I was always a much bigger fan of his short work. "Berniece Bobs Her Hair," for one, has stayed in my mind for many decades. I think that's a tremendous achievement, to write something so short and meaningful and doesn't leave a reader's mind.
Julie wrote: "I figured it was a reread for you. I more recently read TENDER IS THE NIGHT for my 30s project, and I really couldn't stand it. It made me wonder how a GATSBY reread will go for me. I loved it the ..."I really can't choose between Fitzgerald's novels and his short stories. I love both, and think he's every bit as accomplished in one form as the other. His novels have that wonderful richness and depth, but his short stories can pack a really good punch. Bernice Bobs Her Hair is a great example. I actually find it rather sad and cruel beneath all the wit. In my younger days, I might have thought Marjorie got her just desserts, but I find myself looking at it rather differently now. Bernice's eagerness to belong is painful enough to watch, but the spitefulness of her revenge leaves me uncomfortable too. I wonder if that wasn't rather Fitzgerald's point. He sees straight through the social games, the vanity and the little cruelties, and gets right to the heart of human nature.
Great exposition of the themes in this novel, Julie. You're making me want to go back to re-read this one. I particularly liked this point:
"he cannot entirely escape the past, nor does he really want to. He creates a new identity, but his imagination remains tethered to an earlier version of himself and to the life he believes should have been his."
Your review really got into Gatsby's psychology and it seems like you are pulling out something about the era via Gatsby.
I recently attended a great lecture about Fitzgerald's short stories and learned that (comparing only circulation) Fitzgerald's greatest exposure to a reading public was through his short stories that were published in Vanity Fair, Saturday Evening Post, Colliers, McCalls, etc. And that exposure gave him a bit of celebrity status, which is its own alternate, constructed, ersatz reality. The division between the world we live in and the world we construct for ourselves makes it possible to have two different versions of ourselves.
path wrote: "Great exposition of the themes in this novel, Julie. You're making me want to go back to re-read this one. I particularly liked this point:
"he cannot entirely escape the past, nor does he reall..."
Thank you for this, path. I've long felt that Fitzgerald understood Gatsby's capacity for self-invention from a very personal perspective. There is a fascinating convergence between the two: Fitzgerald, the young writer who became a celebrity in the very magazines that helped shape popular fantasies of wealth, glamour and success, and Gatsby, who constructs an entirely new identity in pursuit of the life he imagines for himself. Both, in different ways, inhabit a world where the carefully fashioned public image can become almost as important as the person behind it. The lecturer's connection between Fitzgerald's literary success and his own constructed public persona is a particularly perceptive way of illuminating that parallel.
PS I hope you do reread it, as I'd be very interested to read how you feel about it now.
I love this book and have reread a few times. Thank you for the trip down reading lane. Maybe I’m due for another.
The wrote: "I love this book and have reread a few times. Thank you for the trip down reading lane. Maybe I’m due for another."Maybe! Glad to hear we share the sentiment.
This is a remarkable review of a very good book Julie! "....longing, illusion and the human condition."......that's life really right? The themes here also are similar to those of Middlemarch, my current read. Re-imagined past's and future's - often leading to disillusionment and trouble. The movie with Leo was great too. Thanks for reminding me of this one Julie 🤓🤗🦘
Gorgeous write-up, Julie - I savoured every word of it, reading it again as soon as I reached your last line - what a sublime piece of writing you dedicated to this novel. After reading 'Tender is the night', which fell entirely flat on me, this novel was such a surprise : the depth, the questions on identity, on what makes one human, the writing, all I am looking for when reading fiction, it was all there. The yearning, the impossible struggle for a place in the sun, you are so right this novel transcends time and place.
Superb review, Julie! Same as Ilse, I cherished every word of it and I'm grateful to you for summarizing, and at the same time wonderfully elaborating on, why this book deeply spoke to me and readers of so many generations as the decades unfold.
The endless allure of dreaming of a better life, of belonging to a better life full of beauty and hope, however deceitful both are, is what makes us go on, forever trapped between our deliberate illusions and lesser reality.
Wonderful review, Julie! I also adore this book. I love how the phrase 'careless people' has now entered everyday language (such as the title of Sarah Wynn-Williams' book) and we all understand exactly what is meant by it as a result of this novel.
Mark wrote: "This is a remarkable review of a very good book Julie! "....longing, illusion and the human condition."......that's life really right? The themes here also are similar to those of Middlemarch, my..."
Oh, I love that connection to *Middlemarch*, Mark! Eliot and Fitzgerald both understood the human capacity for reinventing the past and imagining futures that reality has absolutely no intention of accommodating. Disillusionment, of course, is often waiting in the wings.
As for the film, I do like Leo, but I'm afraid he'll have to take a number. Robert Redford IS Gatsby as far as I'm concerned. And what a cast that 1974 version had: Mia Farrow, Sam Waterston and Bruce Dern! Redford had just the right combination of charm, melancholy and that elusive quality that makes Gatsby so compelling. Leo is lovely, but he can't have everything. 😂 😍💔
Ilse wrote: "Gorgeous write-up, Julie - I savoured every word of it, reading it again as soon as I reached your last line - what a sublime piece of writing you dedicated to this novel. After reading 'Tender is ..."Oh, Ilse, what a lovely thing to say. Thank you. And I love the way you've described what you found in this novel: the questions of identity, of what makes us human, the yearning, the impossible struggle to find our place in the sun. Yes, all of it. I think that's what makes Gatsby so much more than a story of a particular time and place. Fitzgerald gets at something deeply human in our need to invent ourselves, to believe in possibility, to reach for something just beyond our grasp. And that yearning, however misguided or doomed, is both heartbreaking and utterly recognizable. I'm particularly glad you found such a different experience in Gatsby after Tender Is the Night. Perhaps Fitzgerald didn't always strike the same chord, but here, for me, he achieved something close to perfection. And thank you for reading my review not once, but twice. That means a great deal. ❤️
Violeta wrote: "Superb review, Julie! Same as Ilse, I cherished every word of it and I'm grateful to you for summarizing, and at the same time wonderfully elaborating on, why this book deeply spoke to me and read..."
Violeta, thank you! What a beautiful way of putting it — particularly that tension between our deliberate illusions and the lesser reality we inhabit. I think you've captured something essential about Gatsby, and perhaps about the human condition itself. I've often thought that this longing has been in the human heart ever since our earliest ancestors first looked up at the stars and watched them blinking in the darkness, wondering what lay beyond their reach. And to me, that little green light across the water is such a perfect embodiment of that ancient longing: always visible, always beckoning, always just beyond our grasp. We seem to need our dreams, even when some part of us knows they may be leading us astray. There's something both heartbreaking and strangely magnificent about that refusal to relinquish the possibility of a better life. Perhaps that's why Gatsby continues to speak to us, generation after generation: we recognize that longing, because it has always been ours. I'm so glad the novel spoke to you as deeply as it did to me, and touched that my review resonated with you.
Di wrote: "Wonderful review, Julie! I also adore this book. I love how the phrase 'careless people' has now entered everyday language (such as the title of Sarah Wynn-Williams' book) and we all understand exa..."Thank you, Di! And what a great insight to pull out that particular phrase. I find it fascinating that Fitzgerald's language has become so woven into our cultural vocabulary. "Careless people" is such a perfect example. What's particularly striking to me is how much more relevant those two words seem to have become as the years pass. If anything, the distance between the novel and our own time has sharpened their meaning. The carelessness Fitzgerald exposed wasn't simply a matter of individual character; it was about privilege, entitlement, and the extraordinary ease with which some people insulate themselves from the consequences of their actions, leaving others to pick up the pieces. Sadly, that feels less like a relic of the Jazz Age and more like an observation about the world we inhabit now. Fitzgerald's vision has aged remarkably well — perhaps rather too well.
I read this enduring (surprisingly short) novel several decades ago, Julie, and you've brought it back to me in glorious Technicolor. A superb review, my eloquent friend. You've really captured the broader lessons that can be learnt from this modernistic parable.
Kevin wrote: "I read this enduring (surprisingly short) novel several decades ago, Julie, and you've brought it back to me in glorious Technicolor. A superb review, my eloquent friend. You've really captured th..."
Thanks, Kevin. It really is remarkable how much Fitzgerald managed to pack into such a compact novel. There's something quite extraordinary about his ability to make a story feel so intimate and yet so expansive into so few pages. I'm delighted the review brought it all back to you!
And it's nice to see you here! 😊 Have you been hiding/working hard on your next novel?
Georgia wrote: "Perceptive. Eloquent. Touching. What a review, Julie."Georgia, you embarrass me — and honour me, in equal measure. What a lovely thing to say. Thank you.
Hmn. Another one of those forced high school English marches (like Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice) that I read and never returned to. But I should, for no other reason than this: 16-year-old me might as well be a stranger to present-day me. No doubt we have vastly different tastes.
Ken wrote: "Hmn. Another one of those forced high school English marches (like Jane Austen's Pride & Prejudice) that I read and never returned to. But I should, for no other reason than this: 16-year-old me mi..."Ha! Sixteen-year-old us really shouldn't be allowed to have the final word on anything, particularly literature. (I wouldn't mind a chance to redo quite a few things about my own 16-year-old self, actually.) It's quite possible you'll wonder what on earth you were objecting to. Or not ...
But I rather like the idea of giving a book a second chance when we're no longer the person who first slammed it shut, and have put a few miles between us and that closed door.


You seem to have had a powerful experience of this story. Was it a first read? A reread?