Matthew Ted’s review of Life of M > Likes and Comments

90 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ken (new)

Ken From awful to bar fights. Life of M as in Miserable. Reviews of this are all over the alphabet.


message 2: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Ken wrote: "From awful to bar fights. Life of M as in Miserable. Reviews of this are all over the alphabet."

Indeed, Ken. The naïve will still be drawn in by the Natalie Portman PR stunt surrounding this novel, I'm sure.


Tom the Teacher That cadaver line is BRUTAL 😂 I do love a scathingly well-written review.


message 4: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Tom the Teacher wrote: "That cadaver line is BRUTAL 😂 I do love a scathingly well-written review."

Ha, thanks Tom!


message 5: by emilee (new)

emilee I definitely share the same sentiment. I read Outline earlier this year and didn’t really care what Rachel Cusk was putting out next, I wanted to read it. This was such a letdown. Not only that, I found it a little invasive with the way it ended. Exploitative rather


message 6: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted emilee wrote: "I definitely share the same sentiment. I read Outline earlier this year and didn’t really care what Rachel Cusk was putting out next, I wanted to read it. This was such a letdown. Not only that, I ..."

I was expecting to be in the minority with this one, but not yet. Goodreads averages are completely meaningless, but I can't help but notice 3.13. Low.


message 7: by Yalla (new)

Yalla Balagan I loved the book and your review too. What am I to do?


message 8: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Yalla wrote: "I loved the book and your review too. What am I to do?"

Implode


message 9: by Emma (new)

Emma Hughes Respect for your honesty


message 10: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Emma wrote: "Respect for your honesty "

It is the best policy


message 11: by Alan (new)

Alan 3


message 12: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Alan wrote: "3"

3 strikes before you get blocked


message 13: by Alan (new)

Alan Matthew Ted wrote: "Alan wrote: "3"

3 strikes before you get blocked"


I crossed those boundaries years ago mate I think I'm safe.


message 14: by Lizp (new)

Lizp There was nothing wooden and lifeless about this book! I have been reading Cusk since 1993, and I found this to be a beautifully written book with flawlessly perfect sentences!


message 15: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Lizp wrote: "There was nothing wooden and lifeless about this book! I have been reading Cusk since 1993, and I found this to be a beautifully written book with flawlessly perfect sentences!"

Luckily, it's all a matter of opinion. That's why this website exists.


message 16: by Lizp (new)

Lizp My gut says that you possibly have a grudge (for whatever reason) with Cusk! Nobody who is being genuine or real could ever call her perfect sentences wooden and lifeless!


message 17: by Matthew Ted (new)

Matthew Ted Lizp wrote: "My gut says that you possibly have a grudge (for whatever reason) with Cusk! Nobody who is being genuine or real could ever call her perfect sentences wooden and lifeless!"

On the contrary, if you read my review beyond the first line, you will see I consider her Outline trilogy one of best pieces of fiction this century so far. People have differing opinions. Art is subjective. Your opinion is as worthy as mine, though they differ. I can't fathom suggesting that someone's opinion is 'not real'.


message 18: by Ken (last edited Nov 18, 2026 05:16AM) (new)

Ken (buys popcorn and takes a seat)


message 19: by Alan (new)

Alan Lizp wrote: "My gut says that you possibly have a grudge (for whatever reason) with Cusk! Nobody who is being genuine or real could ever call her perfect sentences wooden and lifeless!"

Almost on a daily basis, I am reminded that basic tenets of discussion and philosophy are completely absent in weirdly large chunks of the population. Perhaps the funniest overlooked tenet is that of the parable of the stones being thrown by the residents of glass houses. I could make an equally inane statement by pointing out that an enjoyer of "One-Star Romance" by Laura Hankin (to the tune of 5 stars!) should have their opinions on "perfect sentences" come with a content warning. But I won't do that.


message 20: by Lizp (new)

Lizp Ooooh! Alan is sticking up for his ju jitzu throwing shapes pal who is jealous of Rachel Cusk! You haven’t even read One Star Romance, cretin! So you just sound like a puerile, spiteful schoolboy who creepily stalked through my reviews by knocking it! I stand by my 5 stars. I was reading great books long before a little loquacious know nothing scut like you ever infected this world with your obnoxious presence! Reading for 58 years, since I was 4. You have a very steep learning curve ahead of you, boy!


message 21: by Lizp (new)

Lizp Matthew, I read your review in its entirety at the outset. It does not change my opinion one whit. People develop grudges with others at all stages for various reasons! As for your sycophantic, cowardly, creepy little pal Alan who in anticipated lily livered fashion put his account on private, his stalking through my reviews and having a go at One Star Romance which he has not even read simply makes him look puerile!


back to top