Unpopular opinion: an impossible twist is usually a bad twist > Likes and Comments

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Morrow People often praise a thriller by saying, “I never saw the twist coming.”

But if there were no real clues and the reveal could have been literally anything, is that actually clever, or is the author just cheating?

I’d rather guess part of the truth from fair clues than be shocked by something random on the last page.

Which do you prefer: a twist you might predict but that makes perfect sense, or one you could never see coming?


message 2: by Sean (new)

Sean Peters  (A Good Thriller) Always love a twist I never saw coming


message 3: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Morrow Sean wrote: "Always love a twist I never saw coming"

Same! 😄 I love being surprised. I just want that moment afterward where I think, “How did I miss that? The clues were right there.”


message 4: by Anya (new)

Anya Exactly! A really good twist is when you didn't see it coming ALTHOUGH the clues were there!


message 5: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Morrow Anya wrote: "Exactly! A really good twist is when you didn't see it coming ALTHOUGH the clues were there!"

Yes! That’s the best kind. When you finish the book and immediately want to go back because suddenly all those little details mean something completely different 😄


message 6: by Sean (new)

Sean Peters  (A Good Thriller) This has happened with two recent reads

Both 5 star reviews

Deception by Jack Jordan

and

The Only One Left by Riley Sager


message 7: by Mike the Magnificient (last edited Aug 17, 2026 08:31AM) (new)

Mike the Magnificient For me, it makes a difference where the 'twist' comes in the storyline. I'm more tolerant of a twist that comes 'out of the blue" (with little or no support from the story) if it comes in the middle (or even at three-quarters). When there's still more of the story to tell, I'm usually willing to accept the 'twist' as just another clue to solving the mystery. But if an unsupported twist that comes at the end of the book, to tie up all the loose ends, it's a cheat IMHO. It's deus ex machina. It's lazy writing and I don't care for it.

When Ellery Queen was at the top of the charts, his claim to fame was a promise to his readers that all the clues needed to solve the mystery had been presented to the reader before the big reveal, and the reader was encouraged to pause and try to solve the mystery before the truth was made known. In fact, at one point he had a radio program where a mystery was presented and a guest star would then give his prediction of 'whodunit' and the reasons why before the narrator would finish the story. I've listened to a few of the shows and they're pretty cool!


message 8: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Morrow Mike the Magnificient wrote: "For me, it makes a difference where the 'twist' comes in the storyline. I'm more tolerant of a twist that comes 'out of the blue" (with little or no support from the story) if it comes in the middl..."

That’s exactly the distinction I was trying to make. I don’t mind being surprised — I just want to be able to look back and think, “Damn, it was there the whole time.”


message 9: by Sean (new)

Sean Peters  (A Good Thriller) Yes, hidden in the story, and you think, I should have seen that


message 10: by Steven (new)

Steven Harrison Unpredictability isn’t enough. The best twist surprises me in the moment and feels inevitable afterwards. If I missed it because the author successfully redirected my interpretation, that’s good construction. If I missed it because information known to the viewpoint character was deliberately withheld, that feels like cheating.


message 11: by Jonah (new)

Jonah Whitmore I think there's a difference between a twist that is impossible and a twist that is simply something the reader didn't expect.

I actually enjoy twists that completely change my understanding of the story. But afterward, I want to be able to look back and see that the information was there.

If the explanation only works because the author suddenly introduces a rule, character, technology, or fact that we were never given, it feels less like a twist and more like the story changing the rules at the last minute.

The most satisfying twists make you think, “Wait... how did I miss that?”)


message 12: by Vera (new)

Vera Mercer Natalie wrote: "People often praise a thriller by saying, “I never saw the twist coming.”

But if there were no real clues and the reveal could have been literally anything, is that actually clever, or is the auth..."


I’d take the fair twist every time. If the clues are present, being wrong feels like part of the pleasure; if a new rule arrives on the last page, I can admire the surprise but not the construction. The best reveal changes how I read an earlier decision, not just who I suspect.


message 13: by Justin (new)

Justin Not only do I love twists that I never see coming(assuming they are done the right way) but I also write twists that you never see coming. To me, if a story is great but you kind of see what's going to happen, it's just kind of bland. But, if it's a thought-provoking story that leaves you guessing as to what's been happening and what's going to happen only to realize a twist takes place that leaves you in awe, that is an amazing story and a excellent use of a twist.


message 14: by Aline (new)

Aline Rosenthal Guessing who did it doesn't have to spoil the rest. You can have the right person and still be completely wrong about why. A last-page secret twin is a harder sell, especially if nobody has mentioned a twin for 300 pages!


message 15: by Chris (new)

Chris Johnson I don't mind "out of the blue" twists, although I like the "Oh, the clues are there, how did I miss that" types too.

But the twist has to be logical or fit. Otherwise it's too "hand wavey".


message 16: by Richard (new)

Richard Pidwell Steven's line about information the viewpoint character knows being withheld is the one that gets me. Is there a thriller you reckon plays that fair with an unreliable narrator?


message 17: by Conan ಇ (new)

Conan ಇ If a twist does not answer my questions then it's definitely a bad twist


message 18: by Sean (new)

Sean Lyle From the writing side, the test I use is whether the twist can be traced back. If I can point to three or four earlier moments that only make full sense after the reveal, it's fair, however surprising it feels. Aline's point is a good one too: knowing who did it and still being wrong about why leaves plenty of room for a surprise that doesn't cheat. The twists that feel like cheating usually add a brand-new fact at the end instead of reframing old ones.


message 19: by Liz (new)

Liz Anya wrote: "Exactly! A really good twist is when you didn't see it coming ALTHOUGH the clues were there!"

Agree!


message 20: by Vera (new)

Vera Mercer Sean wrote: "From the writing side, the test I use is whether the twist can be traced back. If I can point to three or four earlier moments that only make full sense after the reveal, it's fair, however surpris..."

Three or four earlier moments is a useful test because it separates concealment from invention. I also like when each clue had a convincing first meaning; otherwise the book is technically fair but still feels staged. The reveal should reframe ordinary details, not advertise which details are clues.


message 21: by Chirag (new)

Chirag Sindhu Vera, the convincing first meaning is crucial. A character checking the time might look impatient on the first read and become an alibi problem after the reveal. The detail still belongs in the scene either way. What bothers me more than guessing the culprit is discovering that the narrator quietly avoided a thought they would obviously have had.


message 22: by Kadie (new)

Kadie Vellis I'm with you on this. The twists I love are the ones where you go straight back to the start and realise every clue was sitting there in plain sight, you just didn't want to see it. If the narrator was hiding something from me the whole time just to pull a rabbit out of a hat on the last page, I feel conned, not clever.


message 23: by Sean (new)

Sean Lyle Vera, "a convincing first meaning" says it better than I did. Chirag, the avoided thought is the one I watch for most when drafting. If a narrator would naturally wonder about something, the page has to let them wonder and then give them a believable reason to set it aside.


message 24: by Kadie (new)

Kadie Vellis The twist you don’t see coming in is like a Scooby Doo twist. Do you remember watching that years ago and all of a sudden the villain would be someone that wasn’t even in the first place? You could never have guessed if you tried? 🤣🤣


back to top