L.S.’s review of The Rouse > Likes and Comments

22 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dax (new)

Dax Whoa!


message 2: by Michael (new)

Michael Kuehn Ouch!


message 3: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Dax wrote: "Whoa!"

I will possibly review it. But am formulating substantial opinions at the moment.


message 4: by Goatboy (new)

Goatboy I'm only 50 or so pages in but am so far unimpressed.


message 5: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Goatboy wrote: "I'm only 50 or so pages in but am so far unimpressed."

Yeah, the remainder will likely also not impress you then.


message 6: by Paul (new)

Paul Dembina You are spot-on with your analysis - totally agree with you.


message 7: by Magdelanye (new)

Magdelanye Mieville bland and uninspired? oh no
I've been jonesing for a new China and this review is crushing. Will i try it anyway? Probably. But I will braced against disappointment


message 8: by Jen (new)

Jen Jen sad.


message 9: by Jacob (last edited Nov 15, 2026 12:23AM) (new)

Jacob I'm pretty sure I found a typo early on, somewhere in the first couple hundred pages, but there's no way I'm going back to look for it now.

I was on the fence about this book the entire time I was reading it. The first hundred pages were incredible, the next 500 or so were compelling (if confusing) enough to keep me reading, and then the second half just kept going, and never really concluded in a satisfactory manner. Part of me wonders if I read it too quickly and didn't take more time (I only had it from the library for a month), but there's no way I'm rereading it anytime soon.

(I'm rereading the Bas-Lag books instead. Much more satisfying.)


message 10: by Jacob (new)

Jacob None of the quirkiness of those off-the-wall characters.

You just know China Mieville of 10 or 20 years ago would've taken that helicopter cult idea and done some bonkers things with it. That was my biggest disappointment.


message 11: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Jacob wrote: "None of the quirkiness of those off-the-wall characters.

You just know China Mieville of 10 or 20 years ago would've taken that helicopter cult idea and done some bonkers things with it. That was ..."


Yes, the concepts were somewhat interesting. They could've made for a few decent novellas. The whole issue was just the trimmings.


message 12: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Jen wrote: "Jen sad."

I'm sad that you're sad.


message 13: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Jacob wrote: "I'm pretty sure I found a typo early on, somewhere in the first couple hundred pages, but there's no way I'm going back to look for it now.

I was on the fence about this book the entire time I was..."


I will reread Bas-Lag as well. I actually never finished the whole series. Nows as good a time as any. Still, thanks for joining my reading group. I have another one planned for Januaryish.


message 14: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Magdelanye wrote: "Mieville bland and uninspired? oh no
I've been jonesing for a new China and this review is crushing. Will i try it anyway? Probably. But I will braced against disappointment"


Thanks for your comment. Perhaps it hurt more when I read it because of my high expectations.


message 15: by L.S. (new)

L.S. Popovich Paul wrote: "You are spot-on with your analysis - totally agree with you."

Gracias. Hopefully the next Reading Group will be more fruitful.


message 16: by Paul (new)

Paul Dembina I look forward to it


back to top