Bjørg (mellom linjene)’s review of Kairos > Likes and Comments
595 likes · Like
i felt much the same
You have captured my reaction to the book. Thanks for articulating what I was struggling to piece together.
I agree. So much time wasted on the relationship, was this really necessary? It just made me angrier about her staying with this narcissist. The last part of the book, after the wall goes down is so interesting. Still I did not love the book.
I agree. I absolutely loved how intense the first part was. Excellent writing. Each sentence so dense with emotion.
Totally agree! Her language is phenomenal and I found the premise of the book very intriguing. But where was the editor??
I am in the middle. I was about to give up. Your review gives me courage to persevere. I am 3 yrs older than the main character and I cannot relate to her at all, but I am really enjoying this from the historical perspective. Just wish for more history and less French Connection
I had read this review and prepared myself for a similar experience - but didn’t really have it. I also enjoyed the first part of the book and then, by about p. 140, had really started to dislike the Hans character. However, I didn’t feel that it was overdone- the point of the repetition and tedium of his abuse surely was to underline these character elements in a way that resonates with the lived experience of a declining relationship, I.e., it goes on longer than it should. I also thought the return to the more overt political setting at the end worked well.
That was my first reading of Erpenbeck’s writing so I was not disappointed. It sits somewhere between classic Cold War espionage and writing like Funder’s Stasiland. Not sure about a meta-take away point, other than the blossoming of human relationships against a blighted context. In that respect cf. the ‘sex crime’ in Orwell’s 1984. Probably the most recurrent association I had was with Kundera’s Unbearable Lightness of Being (book, and film).
" it started out so much better than it turned out" says it all for me, though it is the first of Jenny Erpenbeck's novels I have read.
Me too! The first third is great, then it becomes a fairly tedious round of Hans being, frankly, an emotionally abusive creep.
I get that Hans and Katharina’s relationship is an allegory for the fate of the DDR. A beginning full of utopian promise, before a slide into despotism and recrimination, then a brief glint of hope for reconstruction before the thing ends. But, I couldn’t help but feel we didn’t need 100+ pages of the two characters being desperately unhappy and repeatedly telling each other so.
It does get much better again once 1989 swings around. However, like others, I found the cultural memory and history aspects far more interesting than the characters love affair.
I’m a real nerd about the DDR and was hoping this would be the novel to capture what it was like to lose one’s country and cultural identify. Alas, it was a bit meh.
I agree, too, but in the same time, while being really impatient about the ongoing relationship, I read it as a metaphor for the people in the GDR and their disfunctional relationship to their own state. I think the experience of discontentment while reading is part of the artwork of Erpenbeck. Really fascinating in my view.
Totally agree. Not only am I bored by the dysfunctional relationship after so many pages, most importantly, I am disgusted by his behavior. I get it, but enough already. I know the relationship is a metaphor, but still.
Kudos, great review pretty much matched my experience just wanted it to end during Box 2. I don’t think it help that Hans seemed to be such a self absorbed character and so abusive, and she allowed the relationship to continue well past me still caring about it!
I believe that the repetitions are to show how abusive he was , and how resistant the government of GDR to change , which was inevitable; since the relationship is an allegory of the GDR.
Whether you read it as a metaphor or not, the repetitions in the second part of the book are boring and I was also disgusted with the older man´s behaviour toward his girlfriend whom he used and manipulated. The advantage of a metaphor is that it should be short and vividly show a certain truth; here the relationship was shown in too much length when nothing was really changing anymore. Still, the writing style was good and I did really enjoy the first part.
For me, it became less interesting as it went on - got quite turgid in fact - but it did pick up again. So, I ended up rating it more highly than I had expected to.
Exactly how i feel after just finishing it. I got so annoyed with Hans egocentric character. Still worth the read as you said, especially the first part. Glad I finished the book. Thanks for sharing your review.
These were my exact thoughts on the book, although I also agree with others that it was probably purposeful that it was so drawn out and had so many reputations. But still. Didn’t make it an easy read!
I also bought Go. Went. Gone when I was in tje first half of the book when it was still enjoyable so I’m happy to hear it’s a good book!
Great review! I went through a similar proces as you.
Around page 150 I started to get such an aversion, better: disgust for Hans that I considered putting the book aside.
Am I happy that I did'nt ? Not really.
The Stasi part I did no really get: what influence did it have on their relationship, if any?
I agree with your review! The first third was amazing. I got tired of Hans and would have liked for explanation on what happened after the wall fell and Katarina’s empowerment
This is exactly how I felt too throughout the book. I fully agree with all you say. Many thanks for sharing this review.
I have just started reading this book and I love it so far. But I am so puzzled by the claim that their ages add up to 100. She is 19. He is 32 years older, 51. 51+19 = 70 unless arithmetic is different in German 😆. Anybody else notice this?
I feel heard by this review! While I understand that the idea was to show the reader how the relationship was falling apart, I also disengaged from the book a bit at this point. Still worth the read, though.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Tim
(new)
Jul 11, 2023 06:12PM
i felt much the same
reply
|
flag
You have captured my reaction to the book. Thanks for articulating what I was struggling to piece together.
I agree. So much time wasted on the relationship, was this really necessary? It just made me angrier about her staying with this narcissist. The last part of the book, after the wall goes down is so interesting. Still I did not love the book.
I agree. I absolutely loved how intense the first part was. Excellent writing. Each sentence so dense with emotion.
Totally agree! Her language is phenomenal and I found the premise of the book very intriguing. But where was the editor??
I am in the middle. I was about to give up. Your review gives me courage to persevere. I am 3 yrs older than the main character and I cannot relate to her at all, but I am really enjoying this from the historical perspective. Just wish for more history and less French Connection
I had read this review and prepared myself for a similar experience - but didn’t really have it. I also enjoyed the first part of the book and then, by about p. 140, had really started to dislike the Hans character. However, I didn’t feel that it was overdone- the point of the repetition and tedium of his abuse surely was to underline these character elements in a way that resonates with the lived experience of a declining relationship, I.e., it goes on longer than it should. I also thought the return to the more overt political setting at the end worked well. That was my first reading of Erpenbeck’s writing so I was not disappointed. It sits somewhere between classic Cold War espionage and writing like Funder’s Stasiland. Not sure about a meta-take away point, other than the blossoming of human relationships against a blighted context. In that respect cf. the ‘sex crime’ in Orwell’s 1984. Probably the most recurrent association I had was with Kundera’s Unbearable Lightness of Being (book, and film).
" it started out so much better than it turned out" says it all for me, though it is the first of Jenny Erpenbeck's novels I have read.
Me too! The first third is great, then it becomes a fairly tedious round of Hans being, frankly, an emotionally abusive creep. I get that Hans and Katharina’s relationship is an allegory for the fate of the DDR. A beginning full of utopian promise, before a slide into despotism and recrimination, then a brief glint of hope for reconstruction before the thing ends. But, I couldn’t help but feel we didn’t need 100+ pages of the two characters being desperately unhappy and repeatedly telling each other so.
It does get much better again once 1989 swings around. However, like others, I found the cultural memory and history aspects far more interesting than the characters love affair.
I’m a real nerd about the DDR and was hoping this would be the novel to capture what it was like to lose one’s country and cultural identify. Alas, it was a bit meh.
I agree, too, but in the same time, while being really impatient about the ongoing relationship, I read it as a metaphor for the people in the GDR and their disfunctional relationship to their own state. I think the experience of discontentment while reading is part of the artwork of Erpenbeck. Really fascinating in my view.
Totally agree. Not only am I bored by the dysfunctional relationship after so many pages, most importantly, I am disgusted by his behavior. I get it, but enough already. I know the relationship is a metaphor, but still.
Kudos, great review pretty much matched my experience just wanted it to end during Box 2. I don’t think it help that Hans seemed to be such a self absorbed character and so abusive, and she allowed the relationship to continue well past me still caring about it!
I believe that the repetitions are to show how abusive he was , and how resistant the government of GDR to change , which was inevitable; since the relationship is an allegory of the GDR.
Whether you read it as a metaphor or not, the repetitions in the second part of the book are boring and I was also disgusted with the older man´s behaviour toward his girlfriend whom he used and manipulated. The advantage of a metaphor is that it should be short and vividly show a certain truth; here the relationship was shown in too much length when nothing was really changing anymore. Still, the writing style was good and I did really enjoy the first part.
For me, it became less interesting as it went on - got quite turgid in fact - but it did pick up again. So, I ended up rating it more highly than I had expected to.
Exactly how i feel after just finishing it. I got so annoyed with Hans egocentric character. Still worth the read as you said, especially the first part. Glad I finished the book. Thanks for sharing your review.
These were my exact thoughts on the book, although I also agree with others that it was probably purposeful that it was so drawn out and had so many reputations. But still. Didn’t make it an easy read!
I also bought Go. Went. Gone when I was in tje first half of the book when it was still enjoyable so I’m happy to hear it’s a good book!
Great review! I went through a similar proces as you.Around page 150 I started to get such an aversion, better: disgust for Hans that I considered putting the book aside.
Am I happy that I did'nt ? Not really.
The Stasi part I did no really get: what influence did it have on their relationship, if any?
I agree with your review! The first third was amazing. I got tired of Hans and would have liked for explanation on what happened after the wall fell and Katarina’s empowerment
This is exactly how I felt too throughout the book. I fully agree with all you say. Many thanks for sharing this review.
I have just started reading this book and I love it so far. But I am so puzzled by the claim that their ages add up to 100. She is 19. He is 32 years older, 51. 51+19 = 70 unless arithmetic is different in German 😆. Anybody else notice this?
I feel heard by this review! While I understand that the idea was to show the reader how the relationship was falling apart, I also disengaged from the book a bit at this point. Still worth the read, though.






