Sitting at the Feet of Rabbi Jesus, November 19 > Likes and Comments

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tracy (last edited Nov 10, 2026 08:39PM) (new)

Tracy Marks Sitting at the Feet of Rabbi Jesus: How the Jewishness of Jesus Can Transform Your Faith
by Ann Spangler, 264 pages
November 19
facilitated by Rita Wilson


message 2: by Laurie (new)

Laurie Pollack About the Passover chapter.

I am Jewish but far from religious. I consider myself somewhere between Reconstructionist/Renewal Judaism, and Jewish secular humanism. And do not believe literally that the Exodus happened exactly as stated in the Hebrew Bible. Or did it even happen at all all?
However. The Passover seder, to me, is about my ancestors' collective history and an experience they viewed and we view as a symbol of liberation from oppression and becoming a free people. And about the liberation of all people. NOT about Jesus in any way.

The Exodus has been an inspiration to other groups of people. African Americans were nurtured through experiences of terrible oppression by the experiences of liberation from slavery found in the story of the Exodus.

However, I as non-Native-American would never decide that I want to find inspiration for my own spiritual path by putting on a Shoshone ceremony.

I used to attend a multi day peace walk in Nevada. Each morning a Shoshone elder led us in a sunrise ceremony. Most of us were white. He once told us: do not pretend to be Indian. Be a , whatever you are. HE welcomed us to the ceremony. And invited us to pray in our own way. But HE led it. WE did not decide to do a Shoshone ceremony on our own minus any Native American representation, that was about anti nuclear activism.

So I would really hope that Christians wishing to understand more of the life of Jesus as a 1st century Jew, consider attending an actual Jewish seder. The seder IS a Jewish ceremony. Many community ones are open to visitors of all faiths. Before trying to hold one on your own that is centered on Jesus.

The issue of if Christian seders are appropriation or appreciation has been discussed online and you can Google it to get different views.

I am not insisting my view is the only one. And welcome disagreement.
But i hope this post will spark discussion at the meeting.


message 3: by Tracy (last edited Nov 10, 2026 04:36PM) (new)

Tracy Marks Discussion questions for Sitting at the Feet of Rabbi Jesus Oct 2026

1. How important do you think it is today to have some knowledge of the language and culture used over two-thousand years ago to better understand the teachings of Jesus?

2. How much do you think Jewish language and culture is considered today in our Western churches?

3. After reading this book do you personally have a better understanding of Jesus' Jewish background and if so, how does this understanding change your perception of His teachings?

4. Jesus used the typical rabbinic teaching methods of debate, storytelling, and parables in his interactions with other rabbis, his disciples and followers. If his methods were “typical” what made his teachings have such an impact then and now?

5. There are four types of learners that sat in the presence of the rabbi, the sponge, which absorbs everything, the funnel, takes in at this end and lets out at the other, the strainer, lets out the wine and retains the dregs and the sieve which removes the shaft and retains the fine flour.

a) What type of disciple/learner are you?

b) Do you think the type of learner you are affect your beliefs, decision making and ultimately your actions? If so, how?

c) What type(s) of disciples/learners are in the western Christian churches today? How does the type(s) of disciples/learners in the western Christian churches today affect their beliefs, decision making and ultimately their actions? If so, how?

6. Throughout history, the Jewish people have always believed that God would again send redemption on Passover and the timing for Jesus’s final days coincides with that belief. So, how did the Jewish idea of liberation differ from God’s plan?

7. The author states that “A plane ticket to Israel is not necessary because fresh insights into scripture and Jesus’s teaching is as close as your own bible.

a) Agree? Disagree?

b) What are your thoughts about how travel can have a significant impact on individual opinions and worldly views?

d) Can you give an example of how a travel experience significantly affected you or someone you know?

8. The authors present a view that building community and interactions with others are more important that the solitude. Many believers, especially priests, saints and mystics sought in their paths of faith in solitude.

a) Is seeking solitude going out of style?

b) How do you see solitude being practiced today Jewish and Christian faiths?

c) In the discussion of “vain” prayers such as asking God to give you a baby boy or upon hearing about a car accident, asking that no one you know be involved, why would these be considered vain prayers?

The legalisms suggest that there is no point in asking God to change the sex of a baby that already had been determined. We would be asking God to magically change reality to suit us. And if we asked that no one we know would be hurt in an accident, we would be again asking God to change reality. Even worse, we would be asking God to send trouble to someone else.

All of this is a way legalisms attempt to guide people of the Jewish faith in their prayers on how to pray appropriately to GOD. Do you agree or disagree with the idea of NOT praying in “Vain?

Major Jewish Feasts
9. Major Jewish Feasts are listed below. After reading “Sitting at the Feet of Rabbi Jesus” do you have some different or deeper reflections regarding these Holidays or Jewish Feasts?

a) Passover (Pesach)
1) Meaning: Commemorates the Exodus from Egypt and the liberation of the Israelites from slavery.
2) When: Begins on the 15th of Nisan (March/April) and lasts for 7 or 8 days.

b) Shavuot (Feast of Weeks)
1) Meaning: Celebrates the giving of the Torah at Mount Sinai.
2) When: Occurs 50 days after Passover, on the 6th of Sivan (May/June).

c) Sukkot (Feast of Tabernacles)
1) Meaning: Remembers the Israelites' wandering in the desert and their reliance on God.

2) When: Begins on the 15th of Tishrei (September/October) and lasts for 7 days.
d) Rosh Hashanah (New Year)
1) Meaning: Marks the Jewish New Year and a time of reflection and
repentance.
2) When: Falls on the 1st and 2nd of Tishrei (September/October)

Yom Kippur (Day of Atonement))
1) Meaning: The holiest day, dedicated to fasting and repentance.
2) When: Occurs on the 10th of Tishrei (September/October).

f) Chanukah (Festival of Lights)
1) Meaning: Celebrates the rededication of the Second Temple and the miracle of the oil.
2) When: Begins on the 25th of Kislev (November/December) and lasts for 8 days.

g) Purim
1) Meaning: Commemorates the saving of the Jewish people from Haman in the Book of Esther.
2) When: Falls on the 14th of Adar (February/March).

10. The Hebrew word for law is Torah and it means teaching or instruction. It is related to the Hebrew verb meaning to aim or have the intention to guide. It is thought by Jewish people that the teaching of the Torah can turn a person from the snares of death.

By obeying the laws of the Torah, the Jewish people believed that it displayed your trust in God even if you did not agree with or understand the law’s intent.

What is your view of the Jewish book of law, the Torah?

[Tracy's comment: The Torah is the first five books of the Old Testament (Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy), important to Christians as well as Jews].


message 4: by Tracy (new)

Tracy Marks Although being (mostly) raised Jewish, I was not familiar with some of the explanations of Judaism in this book, and hadn't remembered a lot about the holidays.

My mother was Presbyterian. My father was a Reform Jew, and I was raised in Reform Judaism from age 9-16 (attending Sunday school and for two years, also Saturday school), though my family only went to Yom Kippur services. In Reform Judaism, one's religious identity is not determined by the mother. Also I was "confirmed" in Reform Judaism when I was 14.

But mostly due to my mother not being Jewish, my family didn't celebrate the Jewish holidays at home (we celebrated Christmas, but only in a gift-giving way). Nor was I exposed to the Yiddish expressions or the food emphasis of Jewish households.

On the other hand, I learned a lot about the Old Testament and Jewish history, and took an ethics class in Saturday school, weekly for a full year. These facets of Judaism (and further study in college, with a religion major) meant a lot to me, as did the emphasis upon the value of education and the humanitarianism -- compassion and engrained sense of service regarding the most vulnerable members of our society (of which I am now one).

I do believe in the messages of Jesus, and that he was one of God's prophets or messengers, but not that he was the "son" of God. There is nothing in the Bible that implies that he was the son in a biological sense anyway. I prefer the Gnostic viewpoint, that God has many emanations (Buddha, Mohammed etc) and that Jesus was likewise was of several emanations that interfaced with us on earth.

Much in Reform Judaism never spoke to me spiritually. I view myself as a cultural Jew, though feel deeply rooted in the essence of Judaism (particularly as related to the Jewish mysticism, the Baal Shem Tov, Martin Buber, Kabbalistic thinking in the westernized manner that we read about it).

For years I've been interested in the first half of the first century, which was critical to both Jews and Christians, and also of considerable significance to both Greeks and Romans. I've studied what we know of the Greek and Roman mystery religions, with its focus on death and resurrection in this life - and was fascinated to learn that almost all the disciples and apostles, as far as we know, had been members of one of the mystery religions, and undoubtedly influenced by it.

And I am grateful to learn more about Judaism in the first century, as Jesus (as far as we know) would have experienced it.


message 5: by Laurie (new)

Laurie Pollack I enjoyed the book and it gave me more understanding of the time and culture Jesus lived in. It brought Jesus down to earth for me. I have always regarded Jesus as a very wise human teacher who was misunderstood by the less wide human beings around him. I always felt that his message was distorted as history progressed, like a giant game of whisper down the lane or telephone (where kids repeat down a row the message whispered to them and it ends up totally different.

This book opened a door way. I will never believe ABOUT Jesus. But he had some very important advice that, IF ONLY his followers followed if, would greatly improve the world.


back to top