Initial impressions > Likes and Comments
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
L.S.
(new)
Sep 15, 2026 08:44AM
A compelling, uncharacteristically straightforward narrative unfolds in the initial chapters.
reply
|
flag
I'll have to play catch up as my copy hasn't been dispatched yet. I ordered a signed copy so I guess China needs to get it 1st
Paul wrote: "I'll have to play catch up as my copy hasn't been dispatched yet. I ordered a signed copy so I guess China needs to get it 1st"It's okay. I don't plan to race through it. Kinda wish I'd gotten a signed one now...
For what it's worth the Guardian review was very positive and they also highlighted the fact that the 1st hundred pages or so were almost social realism.Apparently after that there's a shift.
I hope I'm not giving anything much away here.
Jonfaith wrote: "Keep checking my phone every twenty minutes to see when it is out for delivery."Thanks for joining. I love it when I have that feeling of anticipation.
Paul wrote: "For what it's worth the Guardian review was very positive and they also highlighted the fact that the 1st hundred pages or so were almost social realism.Apparently after that there's a shift.
I ..."
I figured that Mieville would not be content to stick to a typical Realist plot. I like that there's very little hint of a shift in tone or form in the beginning. It lulls you into an easy beach read type mentality.
I'm pretty sure I'm #1 on the library hold list, so I should get it soon (If it's good, I'll buy the paperback). I'll admit, I'm a bit less excited for a 1200+ page Mieville novel than I would've been about 10 years ago, but I'm still gonna read it.
Richard wrote: "The official pub date is tomorrow - will pick one up from the bookstore."Looking forward to your initial impressions.
Jacob wrote: "I'm pretty sure I'm #1 on the library hold list, so I should get it soon (If it's good, I'll buy the paperback). I'll admit, I'm a bit less excited for a 1200+ page Mieville novel than I would've b..."So far it is different from most of his other books. But I have a lot left to read.
I read the opening "chapter" a few times, sifting through the sentences thinking there was a vital clue which I'd failed to recognize. I started the second chapter this morning and absolutely loved it. Alas we are hammered at work today and that appears to be a lifetime ago.
Jonfaith wrote: "I read the opening "chapter" a few times, sifting through the sentences thinking there was a vital clue which I'd failed to recognize. I started the second chapter this morning and absolutely loved..."There are a lot of weird chapter divisions in this book. Luckily, the beginning chapter is breezy. I was absorbed. Things do start to get darker in the following chapters.
Just started this - it is very unlike other Mieville novels and looks like a long hard slough. I will post my thoughts as I go but this looks like what I call a “double read” book where you have to read each chapter twice. (It’s not a negative, late Henry James is like that, Proust). I might not make it but I will try.
Less sinuous and more subtle than Proust or James but especially demanding given the lack of explication: it approaches Arendt’s thinking without rails. Welcome aboard and I look forward to your comments.
Richard wrote: "Just started this - it is very unlike other Mieville novels and looks like a long hard slough. I will post my thoughts as I go but this looks like what I call a “double read” book where you have to..."I would say a 'double read' may not be too rewarding in my opinion. I was really into the 1st section of the book. But Mieville diverges significantly. He abandons a straightforward narrative. His abstruse terminology and odd focus on side currents of story and character seem like a mash-up Realist post-modern style. There is simply no explanation why certain through-lines are pursued. Perhaps we will be provided answers by the end, but it will require great patience. I am reminded a little of Dhalgren. You get these weird characters driving the book, and most, if not all of their behaviors do nothing more than create atmosphere. We are hanging out with characters, and that seems to be the point of the book.
L.S. wrote: "But Mieville diverges significantly. He abandons a straightforward narrative. His abstruse terminology and odd focus on side currents of story and character seem like a mash-up Realist post-modern style. There is simply no explanation why certain through-lines are pursued."Mieville recently did a short Youtube video for Waterstones talking about three books that influenced The Rouse. He points out that Gayl Jones's Mosquito "uses the fact of its own length [and] digressions, diversions, the dream of the book itself...to do things that you couldn't do with a more terse piece of work." So, there's that.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cj1V_...
Just got my copy from the library, so starting tonight.
I'm 400 pages in. Still the 2 parallel narrative lines, although I see the connection between them. There's a slow accretion of detail but otherwise not much new information added. It can't go on in the same way for another 800+ pages - surely?
Yeah. It has a low density of ideas throughout. I'm stalled. Might pick up the audiobook to finish the rest. The scenes need more variation. Or simply could've been reduced in number.
I'm starting to agree with. Very repitious and it's just the same two narrative threads. No variation.I'll keep slogging my way forward for now but I don't hold out a lot of hope.
To be honest this has been my experience with a few baggy books over the years. Why can't editors get stuck in and whip the books into shape.
I do wonder whether the publishers feel the whole "took twenty years to write" and "look, it's over 1200 pages long" are the main selling points.
Paul wrote: "I'm starting to agree with. Very repitious and it's just the same two narrative threads. No variation.I'll keep slogging my way forward for now but I don't hold out a lot of hope.
To be honest t..."
Yeah, I question why this took so long to write. A professional writer should produce 1000-2000 words per day generally. Especially when you are writing mostly dialogue, as is the case here. Unless you are writing Finnegans Wake, a book of this size is nothing to brag about. The prose is not even as dense as Perdido Street Station. I keep thinking I am missing some hidden layer to the novel. But it's just dialogue and suggestive narration. Minimal description. A sales strategy is the only explanation I can come up with.
I know we're supposed to be talking about The Rouse, but I think we're all a little done with it by now. I was hoping someone would be interested in this promising title for a future reading group: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2...
