Rosh’s review of The Women of Wild Hill > Likes and Comments

Glad you enjoyed Rosh beautiful review as always ♥️

Great review Rosh! I enjoyed this one too!

Weird that for every positive, you also have something to argue against it. Though you do have some really good points. Strong female characters for example doesn’t have to mean that the men are cardboard cutout characters. Sorry it went a bit too wild and enthusiastic in the final quarter, but it’s clear this was still a blast. Sounds like this was written by a talented author who’s not afraid to challenge herself. Good review, Rosh.

I'm not a fan of fantasy but glad this one was a good one for you - at least the 75%! Great review, Rosh

Outstanding review, Rosh. Even when books (the electronic or tree kind) have maps or family trees I find myself flipping back and forth. I get what a pain that is. 🤗💕😆

Love the review! ❤️

Okay witchy feminist fantasy is absolutely up my alley! This sounds so appealing?! Also a bit dystopian? Exceptional review dear Rosh, I’m happy the overall tilt was positive for you! I’ll be investigating this for sure ❤️🥰

Fantastic review, Rosh!

Great review, love! I'm glad you enjoyed this somewhat, unfortunate that the ending slipped a bit! ♡♡

This sounds so good! Great review, Rosh!

Ooh love the sound of this! I can take the last 25% being wild if the first 75% was fantastic! A fabulous review Rosh 💖

Glad you enjoyed this one, Rosh!

I also usually stop caring about complicated family trees and choose to go with the flow :) This doesn't quite seem like a perfect read, but I love multigenerational stories (especially about magical families). I'll be checking this out! Wonderful review!!

I’m digging the ✔️❌ format of this review, Rosh. Too bad it went a little wild at the end. 🖤

Fantastic review, sweet Rosh!! 🥰❤️😘 I'm so happy you enjoyed it, even though the ending was a letdown!! 💗💗

The author sounds like a very talented lady Rosh. This sounds really good. Excellent review once again! 💜

Even with the remarkable LaVoy, I think I'd read this one. Informative review Rosh.

Now that's a really balanced review, lol. Been a while since you had a book like this, right?
Whoever thought it was a good idea to club all backstories together in a single chapter and plonk it into the plot?
Still, it has many good things, too, so I might give it a chance. eyeball reading obviously.
Terrific review, Rosh. 💖

This sounds really interesting - great review Rosh!

Oh very interested in this

It's so interesting that every positive had a somewhat negative thing associated with it, though it's clear the positives still won. I'd be in the same boat as you though, not willing to open up that PDF every time it's needed to clear things up. Very helpful review, Rosh!

Oh you really drew me into this book. Stunning review Rosh. ♥ It's been awhile since I read a good book about witches. ♥

Fantastic review, beautiful Rosh💕!!!!!!!! I'm so glad this was such an enjoyable read for you😘!!!!!!!!!

Alya ( 20 comments restriction ) wrote: "Glad you enjoyed Rosh beautiful review as always ♥️"

Thanks so much, Alya! 💖

Debbie H wrote: "Great review Rosh! I enjoyed this one too!"

Thanks, Debbie! I'm glad you liked it too!

Thibault wrote: "Weird that for every positive, you also have something to argue against it. Though you do have some really good points. Strong female characters for example doesn’t have to mean that the men are ca..."

Yeah, it was a strange experience to have balanced points on both sides of the scale and still ending up enjoying the book. 😅
Sadly, many women-oriented novels end up writing cardboard cutout men, just as many action thrillers have only a stereotypical depiction of women. Realism works so much better!
Thank you, Thibault. This is an author I'd love to read again.

Canadian Jen wrote: "I'm not a fan of fantasy but glad this one was a good one for you - at least the 75%! Great review, Rosh"

Thanks much, Jen! Too bad, because you would have really enjoyed the witchy historical content!

Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Outstanding review, Rosh. Even when books (the electronic or tree kind) have maps or family trees I find myself flipping back and forth. I get what a pain that is. 🤗💕😆"

Thanks so much, Shelley! 💖 Right? At least in my physical books, I can pop in another bookmark on the relevant pages. But in the digital edition, it's a nuisance to navigate back and forth. 😬

Jayme C (Brunetteslikebookstoo) wrote: "Love the review! ❤️"
Jonas wrote: "Fantastic review, Rosh!"

Thanks, Jayme and Jonas!

Esta wrote: "Okay witchy feminist fantasy is absolutely up my alley! This sounds so appealing?! Also a bit dystopian? Exceptional review dear Rosh, I’m happy the overall tilt was positive for you! I’ll be inves..."

Oh yes, this would be totally up your alley, dear Esta! Thank you so much! 💖

Faerie wrote: "Great review, love! I'm glad you enjoyed this somewhat, unfortunate that the ending slipped a bit! ♡♡"

Thanks so much, Faerie! 💖 With a stronger ending, this could have been one of 2026 favourites. 😕

Susan Kay wrote: "This sounds so good! Great review, Rosh!"

It is very clever and intricate. Thanks, Susan! Hope you love it too!

Tina wrote: "Ooh love the sound of this! I can take the last 25% being wild if the first 75% was fantastic! A fabulous review Rosh 💖"

Thanks much, Tina! 💖 Yes indeed! That's why I didn't go too low in my rating, because the initial chapters were really good.

Katelyn wrote: "Glad you enjoyed this one, Rosh!"

Thank you, Katelyn!

AG (I'm back!) wrote: "I also usually stop caring about complicated family trees and choose to go with the flow :) This doesn't quite seem like a perfect read, but I love multigenerational stories (especially about magic..."

Going with the flow is so much easier on the patience. 😅
Thanks, AG! 💖 Given your fondness for multi-generational stories and magical realism, I think you'll enjoy this one.

Nancy wrote: "I’m digging the ✔️❌ format of this review, Rosh. Too bad it went a little wild at the end. 🖤"

Thanks much, Nancy! 💖 I always like it when I can switch formats to this method.

Sarah wrote: "Fantastic review, sweet Rosh!! 🥰❤️😘 I'm so happy you enjoyed it, even though the ending was a letdown!! 💗💗"

Thanks so much, dear Sarah! 💖

Maureen wrote: "The author sounds like a very talented lady Rosh. This sounds really good. Excellent review once again! 💜"

She certainly is! Thanks, Maureen! 💖

Barbara wrote: "Even with the remarkable LaVoy, I think I'd read this one. Informative review Rosh."

I wouldn't blame you, Barbara. I missed having a digital copy.
Thank you.

Srivalli wrote: "Now that's a really balanced review, lol. Been a while since you had a book like this, right?
Whoever thought it was a good idea to club all backstories together in a single chapter and plonk it i..."

Oh yes, it's been quite some time since I wrote ✔️ and ❌ for a review. But this one used that format easily.
I swear! It was even worse on audio. I hope you enjoy it whenever you get to it, Sri.
Thank you! 💖

Rachel wrote: "This sounds really interesting - great review Rosh!"

It definitely it. Thanks, Rachel!

Mai wrote: "Oh very interested in this"

You'll like the feminist content,Mai!

A wrote: "It's so interesting that every positive had a somewhat negative thing associated with it, though it's clear the positives still won. I'd be in the same boat as you though, not willing to open up th..."

Opening such PDFs is really a pain. Going with the flow is way more sensible. Thanks, A!

Kealyn wrote: "Oh you really drew me into this book. Stunning review Rosh. ♥ It's been awhile since I read a good book about witches. ♥"

Thanks much, Kealyn! I love witchy books, so it was nice to find a good book connnected to that topic.

Terrific review, Rosh! Sorry, the ending was a bit of a letdown but glad it was enjoyable up until that point. I did get a chuckle about the PDF.

Very interesting! I personally don’t like a book that centres around witches, I think this is the only kind of supernatural creatures/beings which I steer clear of lol. But the premise is interesting, and I like how you described your mix feelings with each point! Glad this was still a good one 💗