Billie’s comment > Likes and Comments
Like
i was disappointed at first about the circumstances in which Harvey died..he deserved something more tragic, worse and then it would have been a happy ending for the readers but that would have been just another conventional ending...this plot lingered in the minds of its readers due to its twisted ending...it bemused us, annoyed us and we thought its unfair - but such is life...then we interpret it as a revenge by mother nature - karma..i thought in the same lines as u Billie..like ur comment
I like the way Mr. Harvey got it in the end. Poetic justice. Yes, something more tragic could have happen to him but in the end he died. What I didn't like about the book is the transferring spirits or whatever happen when Susie kissed the boy. I did not appreciate that. The book was sad to me; the author really did a good job bringing the characters to life; I really felt for the Salmon family.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Rashmi
(new)
Sep 26, 2013 10:57PM
i was disappointed at first about the circumstances in which Harvey died..he deserved something more tragic, worse and then it would have been a happy ending for the readers but that would have been just another conventional ending...this plot lingered in the minds of its readers due to its twisted ending...it bemused us, annoyed us and we thought its unfair - but such is life...then we interpret it as a revenge by mother nature - karma..i thought in the same lines as u Billie..like ur comment
reply
|
flag
I like the way Mr. Harvey got it in the end. Poetic justice. Yes, something more tragic could have happen to him but in the end he died. What I didn't like about the book is the transferring spirits or whatever happen when Susie kissed the boy. I did not appreciate that. The book was sad to me; the author really did a good job bringing the characters to life; I really felt for the Salmon family.
