Victoria’s comment > Likes and Comments
1 like · Like
It may be harsh, but it is just.
Why do you think so? I felt her only "crime" was to want to fully experience an entire life in her own world. Doesn't seem like a large enough transgression to be denied paradise, if you ask me.
What's unjust about invitations and nylons? She was generally portrayed as a loving sister otherwise, and it's silly for her to be punished for leading a lifestyle which is natural for many people her age.
What did Aslan do? As far as I can remember, Susan just wasn't on the train, and so didn't die with the others. She wasn't (necessarily) denied Paradise...at least not yet.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Philip
(new)
Feb 19, 2013 05:27PM
It may be harsh, but it is just.
reply
|
flag
Why do you think so? I felt her only "crime" was to want to fully experience an entire life in her own world. Doesn't seem like a large enough transgression to be denied paradise, if you ask me.
What's unjust about invitations and nylons? She was generally portrayed as a loving sister otherwise, and it's silly for her to be punished for leading a lifestyle which is natural for many people her age.
What did Aslan do? As far as I can remember, Susan just wasn't on the train, and so didn't die with the others. She wasn't (necessarily) denied Paradise...at least not yet.
