Michael’s comment > Likes and Comments
Like
I agree
i do not agree that the movie makes the story more coherent. I think the 5th is the less interesting, but not worse than the movie at all ;)
Interestingly, the movie is the only one that Steve Kloves didn't write.
I absolutely agree. As a huge HP fan, I hate bashing any of the books, but half of OOTP was written in angsty, capital letters. Usually I tend to enjoy the books more than the films (I think of the two as different entities), but the film made me appreciate the book more. In fact, the fifth film is probably my favorite Harry Potter movie.
I hated the movie, I find most of the time that the book is always better than the movie. Now I know that everyone has their own options on this subject but this is just my view. I love harry potter but I just think that some of the movies in the series just didn't meet the books standards. Not complaining though because I still do love all the movies.
I think the movie was okay compared to the book, but like all the others, they left things out.
i may take same stand as staci , ya i like the book better
If you havn't noticed, the books are always better than the movies. It's just how it works.
I am re-reading the book for the 6th time, and I have to say it is good.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Patricia
(new)
Jun 20, 2011 12:04PM
I agree
reply
|
flag
i do not agree that the movie makes the story more coherent. I think the 5th is the less interesting, but not worse than the movie at all ;)
Interestingly, the movie is the only one that Steve Kloves didn't write.
I absolutely agree. As a huge HP fan, I hate bashing any of the books, but half of OOTP was written in angsty, capital letters. Usually I tend to enjoy the books more than the films (I think of the two as different entities), but the film made me appreciate the book more. In fact, the fifth film is probably my favorite Harry Potter movie.
I hated the movie, I find most of the time that the book is always better than the movie. Now I know that everyone has their own options on this subject but this is just my view. I love harry potter but I just think that some of the movies in the series just didn't meet the books standards. Not complaining though because I still do love all the movies.
I think the movie was okay compared to the book, but like all the others, they left things out.
i may take same stand as staci , ya i like the book better
If you havn't noticed, the books are always better than the movies. It's just how it works.
I am re-reading the book for the 6th time, and I have to say it is good.
