Julie’s comment > Likes and Comments
Like
Yeah, I completely agree with your point of view. The strong love mixed with their youth and impulsivness drove them to tragically end themselves. Additionally, her parents are a reason too but not so major that they would be ultimately the cause of their death.
Respectfully, I disagree with your comment. It wasn't Romeo or Juliet's fault, it was just bad luck. The reason why Romeo wanted to actually kill himself is that he was never informed of the plan to fake Juliet's death. In Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence is told that the letter was never sent in which he says "Hath had no notice of these accidents" (Act 5, Scene 2). The messenger, Friar John, was accidentally halted from delivering the letter of the plan. It was plainly due to bad luck that he was stopped from delivering the letter. If Romeo was informed he would never want to kill himself . Demonstrating that it was all purely due to an accident.
I disagree with your claim. The plan would have all gone to plan if only friar Lawrence had sent the letter properly, but he had failed too. Which is what lead to romeo thinking Juliet was actually dead and them him killing himself because he cant live without Juliet and vice versa with Juliet.,
While I agree with you, this feud has been happening for many years at this point. Eventually, this feud would need to stop. I believe that fate caused Romeo and Juliet’s deaths because this was bound to happen eventually and fate picked them to fulfill it.
I agree with your claims. I think that Romeo was just overly-impulsive, also shown by his fight with Tybalt. I also really agree with you that the parent's feud was not a good enough reason to die. They could have easily left their families behind for each other, especially if they were willing to end their own lives for each other.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Anjali
(new)
Mar 11, 2024 08:49AM
Yeah, I completely agree with your point of view. The strong love mixed with their youth and impulsivness drove them to tragically end themselves. Additionally, her parents are a reason too but not so major that they would be ultimately the cause of their death.
reply
|
flag
Respectfully, I disagree with your comment. It wasn't Romeo or Juliet's fault, it was just bad luck. The reason why Romeo wanted to actually kill himself is that he was never informed of the plan to fake Juliet's death. In Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence is told that the letter was never sent in which he says "Hath had no notice of these accidents" (Act 5, Scene 2). The messenger, Friar John, was accidentally halted from delivering the letter of the plan. It was plainly due to bad luck that he was stopped from delivering the letter. If Romeo was informed he would never want to kill himself . Demonstrating that it was all purely due to an accident.
I disagree with your claim. The plan would have all gone to plan if only friar Lawrence had sent the letter properly, but he had failed too. Which is what lead to romeo thinking Juliet was actually dead and them him killing himself because he cant live without Juliet and vice versa with Juliet.,
While I agree with you, this feud has been happening for many years at this point. Eventually, this feud would need to stop. I believe that fate caused Romeo and Juliet’s deaths because this was bound to happen eventually and fate picked them to fulfill it.
I agree with your claims. I think that Romeo was just overly-impulsive, also shown by his fight with Tybalt. I also really agree with you that the parent's feud was not a good enough reason to die. They could have easily left their families behind for each other, especially if they were willing to end their own lives for each other.
