Questions About Stalin

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Stalin, please sign up.

Answered Questions (1)

Who was worst: Stalin, Mao, or Hitler? The book "Nazis Were Socialists" (by Ian Tinny) answers "Stalin" for a question that Radzinsky overlooks. Stalin is guilty in part for Mao & Hitler. Soviet socialism joined German socialism to launch WWII, invading Poland together, & going onward. "Socialism" was touted by the very word in voluminous speeches & writings by Hitler, Stalin, & Mao. Stalin promoted Mao.

Bill Are you mentally ill? The Nazis werent socialist. Ian Tinny exposed himself as an idiot for saying that. I researched Ian Tinny and he was a mental he…moreAre you mentally ill? The Nazis werent socialist. Ian Tinny exposed himself as an idiot for saying that. I researched Ian Tinny and he was a mental health counselor not a Historian, and he peddles lies such as the swastika was "S" for socialism which is comical since the swastika was used by the Hindus before socialism as a movement existed. The Swastika was also used in Europe before socialism existed due to them borrowing it from people from Asia. Hitler and the Nazis claimed that the symbol originated from the Aryans and was the property of the Aryan people. Thus he used it because he falsely thought it was an Aryan/Germanic symbol. Furthermore, the Hindu swastika looks way more like an S than the clockwise variation the Nazis decided to use as a symbol. This idiotic lie seems to come from someone named Rex Curry who pretends to be a Historian when he's not and it shows. He's an attorney not a historian. IN one of the rate my professor entries, a student says "when you ask him a question he would tell you he don't know". Now you could say that rate my professor isnt accurate, but its more accurate than his made-up history.(less)

flag

Unanswered Questions

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more