Questions About The Swiss Family Robinson

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Swiss Family Robinson, please sign up.

Answered Questions (3)

Is this anything like the Disney adaptation?

Amber Not really. I started reading this because I thought it was an old classic, up there with Treasure Island category, plus I loved the Disney movie. I'm…moreNot really. I started reading this because I thought it was an old classic, up there with Treasure Island category, plus I loved the Disney movie. I'm having a hard time getting through it. The movie is way better. The book is so old fashioned. The Dad and the boys are out hunting and killing literally everything in sight including bears, kangaroos, gorillas, and platypus. They are killing animals to stuff as "curiosities". They kill ALL the monkeys because they trashed one of their huts. It's totally not politically correct according to today's thinking. Besides the fact that I don't what island they are on that has all the animals of Africa, Australia, and North America, all in one place. Meanwhile "the Mother" as they refer to her, is doing the domestic thing. I thought there would be more about the building of the tree house and finding creative solutions, like the movie, but there isn't that much. Lots more killing instead, which isn't my bag. They don't even live principally in a tree house, they move to a cave. The Dad knows everything about anything, plants, animals, manufacturing processes, so it's so unbelievable. I'll finish it, but if I'd known it would suck, I wouldn't have bothered. Treasure Island was awesome compared to this. (less)

flag

Did this really happen or just a story?

Rick It is purely fiction. I read that Wyss wrote the book as an educational piece for his children.

flag

Hasta ahora solo tengo una pregunta: ¿DÓNDE DEMONIOS ESTÁ LA ISLA? ¿Qué isla tiene canguros, pingüinos, chacales, flamingos, aves del paraíso, y monos, y este cerca de la línea ecuatorial?

Jane La isla no existe. Todos los animales y plantas juntas en un lugar en el mundo no es posible. Piensa que este libro es como un libro de texto con un t…moreLa isla no existe. Todos los animales y plantas juntas en un lugar en el mundo no es posible. Piensa que este libro es como un libro de texto con un trama o historia. (Lo siento, mi español no es bien) (less)

flag